Know About Justice Chelameswar Who Retired Today After A Seven-Year Tenure In Supreme Court

The Logical Indian Crew

June 22nd, 2018 / 4:02 PM

Justice Chelameswar

Courtesy: News18Scroll | Image Credit: The Week

Justice Jasti Chelameswar, the second most senior judge of the Supreme Court (SC) retired today after serving for seven years in the top court. Earlier this year, he and three sitting judges of SC held a press conference mounting a virtual revolt against Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra.


Who is Justice Chelameswar?

The second-most senior judge in the apex court, Justice Chelameswar has frequently differed with his colleagues and been a part of headline-worthy judgements but hasn’t received the deserved attention.

In 1997, he was made the additional judge in the Andhra Pradesh HC and was then made the CJ of the Gauhati High Court in May 2011. He wasn’t elevated to the Supreme Court until October 2011 and this unexplained delay denied him the chance Chief Justice of India.

The January press conference was held at his home where he made some of the strongest statements ever made by a sitting justice. “Democracy will not survive without a free judiciary.”


What are some of his landmark decisions?

In 2015, Justice Chelameswar was the lone dissenter, when he said that the Collegium system must go, for an exclusive authority to appoint judges was not the only means for an independent judiciary. The centre’s main criticism against the Collegium system was that it creates an ‘empire within an empire’, establishing a give-and-take culture in the country’s top judicial body.

As the Supreme Court, by a 4:1 majority, upheld the Collegium system, Justice Chelameswar said that it has “a euphemism for nepotism” where “mediocrity or even less” is promoted and a “constitutional disorder” does not look distant. Every judge on the constitutional bench had criticised the Collegium system, including the current CJI, but only Chelameswar decided to dissent.

His judgement was seen by many as a way to vent his personal sentiments against the Collegium system that has been an impediment to his promotion to become the Chief Justice. But a judge who has been affected by the flaws of the system and desired transparency cannot be blamed. He preferred the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) to the Collegium system which would comprise the Chief Justice of India, the two most senior judges of the Supreme Court, the Law Minister, and two ‘eminent persons’. Judicial independence in NJAC still remains with the three judges in the commission as they have the power to veto a judicial post they don’t approve of.

His decision to boycott meetings of the Collegium caused the CJI to disclose decisions the secretive Collegium made on the Supreme Court’s website.

His other landmark decision was to strike down the centre’s plea and deem the draconian Section 66A of the IT Act unconstitutional. “It is clear that Section 66A arbitrarily, excessively and disproportionately invades the right of free speech and upsets the balance between such right and the reasonable restrictions that may be imposed on such right,” said a Bench of Justices J. Chelameswar and Rohinton F. Nariman.

He was also the judge behind referring the medical council bribery case and Aadhaar’s privacy concerns to a larger Constitution bench.


Also read: 


Contributors

Written by : Pooja Chaudhuri

Edited by :

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Death Penalty Rohtak Rape

Haryana: High Court Upholds Death Penalty For Seven Convicted In 2015 Gang-Rape & Murder Of Woman

Army Veteran Organic Food

How A 91-Year Old Retired Army Veteran Has Started His New Life As A Social Entrepreneur In Organic Food

Public Has Right To Know; Supreme Court To Live Stream Court Proceedings

100 SC Lawyers & Former CJIs Protest Against Centre’s Decision To Not Elevate Justice KM Joseph To Supreme Court

Supreme Court Dismisses PIL Seeking Independent Probe Into Justice Loya’s Death

Justice Chelameswar

Know About Justice Chelameswar, Who Appealed To The Nation Today To Save The Judiciary

Latest on The Logical Indian

News

Kerala Leads The Way: Records 77.68% Voter Turnout, 3.7% Higher Than 2014 Lok Sabha Elections

News

After US Refusal To Extend Waiver, India May Stop Importing Iranian Oil

Awareness

Powerful Portfolios Lok Sabha 2019: Candidates From Major Political Parties Who Deserve To Be In Parliament

News

Karnataka: Applications Under RTE Admissions Drop To Just 17,336 From Last Session’s 1.2 Lakh

News

Telangana: Faulty Board Results Triggered 13 Student Suicides This Week. It’s Time We Pay Attention

News

Islamic State Claims Sri Lanka Attacks Which Killed 359 People; India Sent Three Alerts But Was Ignored

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.