Bombay High Court Rules Consent For Sex Is Not Valid If The Woman Is Drunk

The Logical Indian Maharashtra

February 20th, 2017 / 5:29 PM

Sex Not Valid

Source: Consent Of Drunk Woman For Sex Invalid | Image Courtesy: ytimglocalpress

The Bombay High Court on Friday observed that consent by a woman when she is intoxicated, will not be considered valid or ‘an excuse to commit rape’.

The court observed, “a woman, when intoxicated, is incapable of giving a free and conscious consent to a sexual relationship.”

“Not every ‘yes’ is covered as valid consent defined under section 375 of the Indian Penal Code. The term ‘without a woman’s consent’ has a wider meaning and includes a broader area of her wish to have sexual intercourse,” Justice Mridula Bhatkar was quoted as saying. She added that if a woman says “no” even once, it implies that she is unwilling. Likewise, if she says “yes”, then it must be free and unambiguous, for the incident to not amount to rape.

Justice Mridula Bhatkar was hearing the bail petitions of three youngsters from Pune, who have been accused of gang rape, kidnapping and abduction of a 24-year-old woman. One of the petitioners argued that on the night of the incident, the woman had four servings of alcohol after which he took her to his friend’s flat.

However, the woman had denied that she consumed alcohol knowingly. She accused that the petitioner had spiked her drinks and she had lost consciousness. Regaining her consciousness, she found herself in an apartment and saw the four accused laughing. She experienced severe pain and asked one of the accused if he had sexually assaulted her, to which he replied that she was gang raped.

Justice Bhatkar also observed that based on statements of the waiter at a restaurant and other witnesses, it was clear there were some discrepancies in the survivor’s statements, but the petitioner could not be granted any benefits owing to the same.

She said, “Considering the social norms and culture of the family, the victim might not have disclosed that she had drinks on that evening and therefore, she might have lied to that extent to her father to save herself, but it does not mean at this stage that whatever she has stated is a complete lie. Prima facie considering her post-rape conduct and physical condition, it appears that she did not want to have sexual intercourse and if at all she had consented to it, the said consent was not valid.”

Although the court rejected the main accused’s bail application, it was held that there is no prima facie evidence against the other two accused, only a statement by the victim that the main accused had stated that others were also involved. Hence, bail was granted to the other two people.


The Logical Indian appreciates the verdict of the Bombay High Court. While consuming alcohol is a choice, sex is also a choice; it cannot be forced upon anyone unless it is entirely consensual and unambiguous.


Contributors

Edited by :

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

ST Woman Married To Muslim Has To Prove Tribal Identity Before Contesting From Reserved Seat: Bombay High Court

WhatsApp Blue Tick

Legal Notice Received And Opened On WhatsApp Is Now A Valid Evidence: Bombay HC

Pregnant Woman Delivers Baby At Hospital Gate As Staff Refuse To Admit Her Without Valid ID Proof

Traffic Rules

Understanding Traffic Rules: Know About The Law For Victims, For Vehicle Owner, On Drunk Driving & For Bystanders

Mangalsutra Sindoor Divorce

Not Wearing Mangalsutra And Sindoor Cannot Be Reasons For Divorce: Bombay High Court

After Bombay HC, Now Kerala HC Says Educated Woman Having Sex On Promise Of Marriage Isn’t Rape

Latest on The Logical Indian

Awareness

16 Yrs Since Bt Cotton Was Introduced For Commercial Cultivation – Was The Decision Correct?

Get Inspired

“We’re Really, You Know, Stuck & There’s No Fuel”: These Two Pilots Saved Lives Of 370 Passengers

My Social Responsibility

How Army Veterans & Common Citizens Came Together For Kerala Flood Relief Effort

Awareness

India Jumps One Position Up In Human Development Ranking; Improvement In Education & Life Expectancy At Birth: UNDP Report

News

Haryana: Crimes Against Women Increased By 27% Between 2014 and 2018

Get Inspired

“We’re Really, You Know, Stuck & There’s No Fuel”: These Two Pilots Saved Lives Of 370 Passengers

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.