The Hindu Apologises & Retracts The Story ”Dying Woman Get Molested”; Other Media Need To Follow Suit

The Logical Indian Crew

October 5th, 2017

Image Credit: Indian Express

The Hindu withdrew its story which claimed that a man had molested a dying woman on the foot over-bridge at Elphinstone station, Mumbai, where a deadly stampede claimed the lives of at least 23 citizens. The media house issued an apology for its “failure to adhere to journalistic norms”.



When The Logical Indian came across this story on different portals and went through the clip, we realised that the video used as the source was incomplete and inconclusive. The original report, written by journalist Vedika Chaubey, was eight seconds long and nothing much could be deciphered from it.  Many news portals, including international media houses, picked up the news and published similar stories. Following this, other videos of the incident surfaced on social media; these were longer and more descriptive – and showed that the man was actually trying to rescue the dying woman and not molest her. We carried a story on the same on October 3. You can read the story here:

After Report Of Man Molesting Dying Woman In Elphinstone Station, Another Video Shows He Was Trying To Help Her

The news of the men actually helping not just holds importance from a journalistic point of view but also from a humanist point of view. The news of the “molestation” was widely shared and many who came across the original report and other reports base on it felt hopeless over how such a thing could take place but the full video tells us a different side of the story, convincing is to have faith in humanity no matter what. 

The Hindu duly retracted the story and issued an apology on the first page of the its Mumbai print edition.

Firstpost and ScoopWhoop also issued apologies, while some other media houses either deleted the story, retracted/updated it without an apology, or did nothing at all.

There were mixed reactions to The Hindu’s apology. Some appreciated the media house for taking responsibility. However, a greater number of people regarded The Hindu’s mistake as “unforgivable”. Some also urged that the media house to fire Chaubey.


The Logical Indian take

While there is no justification for publishing misleading content, especially by a credible media house, we cannot ignore that The Hindu rectified its mistake and apologised for the same. It retracted the original story, published articles with updated information, and apologised profusely. We live in an era where some media houses intentionally publish fake stories/maligning information for political encashments and don’t even apologise for this. One such example is of Zee News not even apolgising after getting a notice from the NBSA. In such times, The Hindu’s apology should be appreciated and commended by us, as readers.

There are many urging The Hindu to fire Chaubey for writing the story; the decision on the appropriate action lies with the media house. Chaubey’s story was damaging and there are sections in the Indian Penal Code and the Norms of Journalistic Conduct that will decide the necessary penalty for the journalist.

As readers, we should be more concerned with media houses acting responsibly in case of errors and keeping us informed of the same. We should pressurise other media and digital platforms that covered the original “molestation” story to issue an apology for their story on this issue. Tackling fake news falls upon each of us and we should know where to direct our anger – at those voluntarily spreading fake news or the ones rectifying their errors?

It is now for other media and news portal to follow the suit and apologise to their readers for such mistakes.

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

“We Have Been Doing Undercover Investigations Since 2000,” Says Aniruddh Bahal, Editor Of Cobrapost

No, Karnataka DGP Who Allegedly Faced Mamta Banerjee’s Ire Did Not Get Transferred

Missing JNU Ward Najeeb Ahmed’s Mother Sues Media Houses For Linking Son With IS, Seeks Rs 2.2-Cr Damages

After Report Of Man Molesting Dying Woman In Elphinstone Station, Another Video Shows He Was Trying To Help Her

From Now On, Facebook Pages That Share Fake News Will Be Blocked From Advertising  

Fact Check: From Times Now’s “Rate Card” To A Speech-Impaired Man Trolled As “Drunkard”

Latest on The Logical Indian

Get Inspired

Tripura: Father-Daughter Duo’s Presence Of Mind Averts Major Train Accident, Authorities Promise Reward

News

Bihar: Refused To Give Free Vegetables To Cop, 14-Year-Old Rots In Jail For 3 Months

Exclusive

Telangana: This IPS Officer Is Saving Lives By Fighting The Menace Of Fake News

Awareness

5,000 Fine If Caught With Plastic Bag, Maharashtra Plastic Ban From Tomorrow

Awareness

Know About Justice Chelameswar Who Retired Today After A Seven-Year Tenure In Supreme Court

News

Bank Whose Director Is Amit Shah Collected Rs 745 Crore Worth Old Notes During Demonetisation: RTI