Delhi Not A ‘Full State’, L-G Can’t Be Obstructionist: Supreme Court On Delhi CM Vs L-G Issue

The Logical Indian Crew Delhi

July 4th, 2018 / 1:04 PM

Supreme Court

Image Credit: Wikimedia

In the power tussle between the Arvind Kejriwal government and Lieutenant Governor of Delhi, Anil Baijal, the Supreme Court on July 4 said that that the L-G cannot take decisions independently and must take aid and advice from his Council of Ministers.

The Court also observed that Delhi enjoys a special status, but is not a full state. Hence, the powers and responsibility of the L-G are a little different from that of a governor. It also stated that neither the L-G nor the state should glorify themselves and should always abide by the Constitutional obligations that they have.

“There is no space for absolutism or anarchy in our Constitution,” the SC stated, reported The Indian Express. The matter was heard by a five-judge bench which was headed by CJI Dipak Misra and comprised Justice A K Sikri, Justice A M Khanwilkar, Justice D Y Chandrachud and Justice Ashok Bhushan. It had reserved its verdict on December 6, 2017.

According to ‘The Government Of National Capital Territory Of Delhi Act, 1991’, the parliament can make laws and regulations for Delhi, and the Delhi government also has the power to legislate on all issues except land, police and public order.

The Supreme Court stated:

“Delhi enjoys special status, is not a full state. The Status of L-G is not that of a Governor. L-G cannot act independently, or be obstructionist. He must take the advice of Council of Ministers. Parliament has the power to make laws for Delhi on state, concurrent list. Delhi govt can legislate on all subjects except land, police and public order. Neither state nor L-G should feel lionized but realise they are serving Constitutional obligations. There is no space for absolutism or anarchy in our Constitution”

Arvind Kejriwal tweeted that it is a big victory for democracy.


CJI Dipak Mishra who was reading out the order said that in a provision to Article 239AA(4), the state and the Union must cohabitate peacefully. He reiterated that the power of the L-G in Delhi is different from the other states. He also mentioned that the L-G cannot be obstructionist and have to co-operate with a Council of Ministers for the smooth functioning of the state.


Reportedly, the NCT government was represented by eminent Senior Counsel Indira Jaising, Gopal Subramanium, P Chidambaram, Rajeev Dhavan and Shekhar Naphade, the Central government was represented by Additional Solicitor General Maninder Singh and Senior Advocate Sidharth Luthra.

What happened earlier?

The Delhi CM had accused L-G of taking decisions independently like an elected government and sitting on files. The Centre, which appoints the L-G, had contended that “for any Centrally administered territory… and especially Delhi in respect of its unique position… responsibility is on the shoulders of the Union Government”, reported The Indian Express.


Contributors

Written by : Poorbita Bagchi

Edited by :

Related Stories

Supreme Court Verdict Ayodhya Ram Janmabhoomi

Read: Full-Text Of The Supreme Court Verdict On Ayodhya Land Dispute

Supreme Court Agrees To Hear Plea On Women’s Full Right To Abort Pregnancy At Any Stage

Rape Survivor Supreme Court

Rape Accused Can Still Be Prosecuted Even If Survivor Turns Hostile: Supreme Court

Mutilated Currency Note

Good To Know: Here Is How You Can Claim A Full Refund Of A ‘Mutilated Currency Note’

SCST Quota Supreme Court

Cannot Claim SC/ST Benefits In Second State Unless Caste Notified There: Supreme Court

Nipah Virus Did Not Spread Through Bats; Bihar, Sikkim Issue Advisory: Reports

Latest on The Logical Indian

Fact Check

Fact Check: Right Wing Portal Claims Nidhi Razdan Attended Pakistan-Sponsored Event, Did She?

News

Uttarakhand: Despite High Court Order, Private Ayurvedic Colleges Continue With 170% Fee Hike

News

Bengaluru Police: Don’t Pay Fine, Buy A Helmet And Take Your Vehicle Home

Environment

TN Collector Organises Eco-Friendly Wedding, Sets Example To Minimise Plastic And Paper Waste

Fact Check

Fact Check: Whether Price Hike Rollback Of JNU Is Indeed A Major One?

News

India Pledges To Donate $5 Million To Palestinian Refugees In 2020

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.