Rafale Deal: SC Dismisses Objection Raised By Centre; Says ‘Leaked Documents’ Admissible

The Logical Indian Crew India

April 10th, 2019 / 1:42 PM

SC Examine Review Petition Rafale Deal

Image Credit: India TV

The Supreme Court bench on April 10 dismissed objections raised by the Centre against the pleas filed for reviewing the SC’s decision on Rafale deal. The three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Ranjan Gogoi said, “We deem it proper to dismiss the Union’s plea.”

SC dismisses Centre’s plea

The SC said that all the review pleas in the Rafale deal will be heard by the court, the date for which will be fixed. The apex court further added that all the defence related documents are allowed to be reviewed.

CJI Gogoi further said that for examining the review petition, the court will consider the papers. He added that the review petition would be considered on the basis of the three documents whose admissibility was earlier questioned. Petitioner Arun Shourie said that he was elated by court’s decision.

Centre’s earlier objection to the documents presented

The Ministry of Defence (MoD) in its affidavit submitted to the Supreme Court said that documents attached by the petitioners in the Rafale deal review case are sensitive to national security. MoD in its affidavit held the petitioners guilty of leaking sensitive information of the Rafale deal and for “putting National Security in jeopardy.”

The Supreme Court on March 14 reserved orders on the preliminary objections raised by the government regarding the “privileged” documents in the Rafale deal case. The court was hearing a review petitions filed by Prashant Bhushan, Yashwant Sinha and Arun Shourie against the court verdict dismissing all petitions seeking court-monitored probe into the Rafale deal.

Attorney General KK Venugopal, representing the government said in the Rafale review case that the documents so presented by petitioners were privileged documents which could not be considered in evidence. He cited Section 123 of the Indian Evidence Act, saying that the documents are protected under the Official Secrets Act. AG further said that the disclosure is exempted under Section 8(1)(a) of the RTI Act.

However, the SC had said that the RTI overrides the Official Secrets Act as per Section 22 of RTI act. He further added that Section 24 of the RTI Act does not exempt security and intelligence establishments from disclosing information pertaining to corruption and human rights violation.

Also Read: SC Reserves Orders On Objections Raised By Govt Regarding ‘Privileged’ Documents In Rafale Deal


Written by : Shraddha Goled

Edited by : Bharat Nayak

Related Stories

Consumer Spending, Essential Items, NSO, Rural, Urban, Poverty

Consumer Spending: Govt Scraps NSO Data Over ‘Quality Issues’, Leaked Report Says Spending Falls First Time Since 1970s

Supreme Court, Review Petition, Rafale Deal, BJP, Congress, Corruption, Defence

Supreme Court Dismisses All Review Petitions In Rafale Deal

Rafale Deal Waivers

Rafale Deal: “Exceptional & Unprecedented Waivers” Given By Modi Govt In Offset Contracts, Says Report

RTI Overrides Official Secrets Act SC

SC Reserves Orders On Objections Raised By Govt Regarding ‘Privileged’ Documents In Rafale Deal

Rafale Deal Documents Stolen

“Documents Related To Rafale Deal Have Been Stolen”: Attorney General Of India To Supreme Court

Rafale Deal CAG

While The Hindu Report Says Rafale Deal Not Better Than UPA Era, CAG Says It Is 2.86% Cheaper

Latest on The Logical Indian


Over 1500 Migratory Birds Found Dead Around Sambhar Lake, Botulism Suspected To Be The Cause


‘Lord Ram Is Ancestor Of All’ Says Shia Waqf Board Chairman, Donates Rs 51000 For Temple In Ayodhya


‘Economy Doing Fine’, Airports Are Full, People Are Getting Married: Union Minister, Suresh Angadi

My Story

My Story: “I Lost My Father To A Brutal Murder On November 18, 2017. A Part Of Me Died With Him”


‘Mere Registration Is No Proof Of Marriage’: SC Rules

My Social Responsibility

Educating Cab Drivers On Necessary Matters Related To Banks, This Woman Entrepreneur Is Making Them Financially Literate


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.