SC Reserves Orders On Objections Raised By Govt Regarding ‘Privileged’ Documents In Rafale Deal

The Logical Indian Crew India

March 15th, 2019 / 3:05 PM

RTI Overrides Official Secrets Act SC

Image Credits: Newsclick, Ebayimg

The Supreme Court on March 14 reserved orders on the preliminary objections raised by the government regarding the “privileged” documents in the Rafale deal case. The court was hearing a review petitions filed by Prashant Bhushan, Yashwant Sinha and Arun Shourie against the court verdict dismissing all petitions seeking court-monitored probe into the Rafale deal.

Attorney General KK Venugopal, representing the government said in the Rafale review case that the documents so presented by petitioners were privileged documents which could not be considered in evidence. He cited Section 123 of the Indian Evidence Act, saying that the documents are protected under the Official Secrets Act. AG further said that the disclosure is exempted under Section 8(1)(a) of the RTI Act.


RTI overrides Official Secrets Act: SC

Petitioner Bhushan had presented the photocopies of the documents related to Rafale deal. AG argued that defence ministry documents are not allowed to be submitted in the SC under the Official Secrets Act. He further said that these documents were covered under ‘privileged information’ and should be disallowed from being brought in the public domain.

The three-judge headed by CJI Ranjan Gogoi said, “What privilege do you claim? They (petitioners) have already produced them in court. File notings have lost the sanctity they had. The RTI Act brought about a revolution, a complete change.” The bench also asked how the government decided on privilege protection.

Petitioner Bhushan argued that documents related to Rafale, that AG says are ‘privileged’, are already in the public domain. “Virtually, all these have been published. If it is relevant to decide any corruption case, it is absolutely irrelevant whether the documents are obtained through legal means,” Bhushan further.

Justice KM Joseph, hearing the case, said that Section 22 of the RTI Act gives RTI an overriding effect over the Official Secrets Act. He further added that Section 24 of the RTI Act does not exempt security and intelligence establishments from disclosing information pertaining to corruption and human rights violation.


Affidavit submitted by govt

The Ministry of Defence in its affidavit submitted to the Supreme Court said that documents attached by the petitioners in the Rafale deal review case are sensitive to national security. MoD in its affidavit held the petitioners guilty of leaking sensitive information of the Rafale deal and for “putting National Security in jeopardy.”

The  Supreme Court has been hearing a review petition on clean chit given by the court to the central government on Rafale deal. It may be recalled that on March 6, Attorney General KK Venugopal said that the important documents regarding the pricing of the deal were stolen from ministry files and given to The Hindu newspaper for publishing. N Ram, Chairman of The Hindu Publishing group earlier broke news about the serious inconsistencies in the Rafale deal through a series of articles.


Also Read: Petitioners Guilty Of Leaking Sensitive Information In Rafale Deal: MoD To SC


Contributors

Written by : Shraddha Goled

Edited by : Bharat Nayak

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Rafale Deal Documents Stolen

“Documents Related To Rafale Deal Have Been Stolen”: Attorney General Of India To Supreme Court

FIR Arnab Goswami

Sunanda Pushkar Death Case: Delhi Court Orders To File FIR Against Arnab Goswami For Allegedly Accessing Confidential Documents

Rafale Deal Parallel Negotiations

Defence Minister Says Report Saying “PMO Holding Parallel Negotiations Undermined Rafale Deal” Is Motivated

Case Against Modi Soldier Freezing

Fact Check: Case Against PM Modi Over Rafale Deal To ‘Indian Soldier’ Freezing In Cold

India's Economic Performance

Fact Check: Govt Claim Of India’s Forex Reserves Booming At $418.9 Bn & FDI Jumping To $60 Bn In 2016-17

Rafale Deal Verdict

Govt Says There Was A Typo When They Cited CAG Report In Supreme Court On Rafale Deal

Latest on The Logical Indian

News

Madhya Pradesh: Brothers & Uncle Rape & Behead 12-Yr-Old Girl

News

Proud Moment: India Bags 368 Medals At Special Olympics 2019 In Abu Dhabi

Get Inspired

This People’s Movement In Karnataka Is Fighting To Save 21 Lakh Trees On Western Ghats

News

Just 6 Days After New Zealand Mosque Massacre, PM Jacinda Ardern Bans Assault Rifles

News

India Figures 140th In UN World Happiness Report; Finland Tops List Second Year In A Row

News

Ahead Of General Elections, Social Media Platforms Agree To ‘Code Of Ethics’

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.