Punjab Must Share Water With Haryana: Supreme Court

The Logical Indian

November 11th, 2016

Punjab-Haryana Water Dispute

Source: tribuneindia | Representational Image: factly

The decades-long legal dispute between Punjab and Haryana on the sharing of river waters has finally come to an end. The Supreme Court has ended the Punjab Termination of Agreement Act, 2004. It declared in its verdict today that Punjab must share water with its neighbor Haryana and it is illegal to bypass the law which has been enacted in the interest of the state.


What is the issue?
The issue goes back to the creation of the state of Haryana. After Partition, a dispute arose between India and Pakistan on the sharing of water from the rivers of Punjab: Indus, Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi, Beas, and Sutlej. The two countries signed the Indus Water Treaty in 1960, under which both were allowed unrestricted use of three rivers each. India was allocated the eastern rivers – Sutlej, Beas, and Ravi. Once this treaty was signed, the water from these three rivers was shared between Punjab, Delhi, and Jammu and Kashmir. Punjab was reorganized in 1966, and the state of Haryana was established. As a successor state, Haryana was eligible to receive a share of Punjab’s river waters. The river Yamuna – whose course took it  through undivided Punjab but now flowed only in Haryana – was never considered a part of this arrangement. This led to contention between Punjab and Haryana and in 1979, Haryana approached the Supreme court to implement the allocation. and Punjab filed a civil suit as a challenge to the agreement.
The construction of the canal that would carry water from Punjab to Haryana was dropped.


The Judgement

With the judgment passed today, the Punjab Termination of Agreement Act, 2004 becomes invalid. The agreement through which Punjab had terminated its pacts with Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Rajasthan, Jammu and Kashmir, Delhi and Chandigarh for sharing the water of Ravi and Beas rivers was struck down by the Supreme Court today.

The Bench headed by Justice Anil R Dave said that the 2004 act was in violation of the apex court judgments, the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, and other Constitutional provisions.  A five-judge constitution bench said that Punjab cannot unilaterally wriggle out of an agreement involving other states.The court also said that the Sutlej Yamuna Canal or SYL canal, proposed for water-sharing between Punjab and Haryana, has to be completed. Owing to this decision, the Supreme Court has also rejected Haryana’s plea for extending the status quo order passed on March 17, 2016. The plea mentioned  that Punjab did not notify the state about the law meant for returning about 4,000 acres of land acquired for the construction of the Sutlej-Yamuna Link SYL canal.

The farmers of Haryana says that they are elated to hear about the decision of the court, and now they will be able to grow vegetables, which are more profitable, throughout the year.

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Update: 17 Dead And At Least 70 Injured As Dera Followers Riot After Ram Rahim’s Rape Conviction

“Messenger Of God” Convicted Of Rape – All You Need To Know

Dera Sacha Sauda

Guru Ram Rahim Rape Case: Punjab And Haryana Govts On Alert, 50,000 Followers March To Panchkula

Punjab CM Announces Free Education For Girls From Nursery To PhD

Jat Agitation

Evidence Reveal That Women Were Raped In Murthal During Jat Agitation: High Court

Punjab: Congress Copies BJP-Led Haryana Government’s Sports Policy After Six Months Of Planning

Latest on The Logical Indian

Exclusive

This Initiative From Pune Recycles Plastic To Turn It Into Cheap Fuel For Villagers

News

MP: Police Arrest 30 Carol Singers Singing On The Road, Right Wing Group Sets Priest’s Car Ablaze

News

On Nirbhaya’s Death Anniversary, Women To Meet & Sleep On Parks To Reclaim Public Spaces

News

BSP Corporator Takes Oath In Urdu, Stirs Controversy

Awareness

66% Dip In The Disbursement Of Funds To Promote RTI

Get Inspired

Remembering Param Vir Subedar Joginder Singh Who Laid His Life Fighting Chinese Until His Ammunition Ran Out