Khap Panchayats Can’t Question Adult’s Choice Of Marriage: SC

From our friends at
LiveLaw
Mehal Jain

January 16th, 2018 / 3:18 PM

Image Credits: Odisha TV

“You can take it from us. Whatever the Amicus may say about the Khap Panchayats, we are not concerned. What we are concerned with is the freedom of an adult girl or boy to pick their spouse. Even if a legislation is not passed, the concept will be evolved. But the changes cannot be expected to come in a regressive society”, said CJI.

On Tuesday, the Supreme Court bench of Chief Justice Dipak Misra, Justice D. Y. Chandrachud and Justice A. M. Khanwilkar, hearing a 2010 writ petition filed by NGO Shakti Vahini seeking directions to the Central and state governments for the prevention of honour crimes, remarked, “The Khap Panchayat as a collective body cannot summon adult girls or boys on their choice of marriage. Whenever there is a collective attack on girls and boys who have attained majority, it is absolutely illegal”. Senior Counsel Raju Ramachandran, appointed Amicus Curiae in the matter, having filed suggestions in the same behalf, referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Vikas Yadav v. State of UP, whereunder it has been observed, “…neither the family members nor the members of the collective has any right to assault the boy chosen by the girl. Her individual choice is her self-respect and creating dent in it is destroying her honour. And to impose so called brotherly or fatherly honor or class honor by eliminating her choice is a crime of extreme brutality, more so, when it is done under a guise. It is a vice, condemnable and deplorable perception of “honour”, comparable to medieval obsessive assertions”.

Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Pinky Anand sought time to peruse and submit reply in respect of the suggestions so filed. Further, the Amicus Curiae submitted, “The 242nd report of the Law Commission deals with the proposed legislation for prevention of interference with matrimonial alliances in the name of honour and tradition. The Centre has been consulting states on whether a law should be passed. We had also filed suggestions in 2012 but were subsequently asked to update the same. The latest suggestions have been served on the central agency as well. The Court may consider passing directions until the enactment of a law”.

However, it was clarified that the present petition is not directed at opposing the Khap Panchayats per se.

In response to the submissions of D. P. Vats, a retired Lieutenant General, and a former chairman of the Haryana Public Service, intervening in person, to the effect that any legislative measures may not be allowed to extend to the control of the Khap Panchayats, Chief Justice Misra remarked, “You can take it from us. Whatever the Amicus may say about the Khap Panchayats, we are not concerned. What we are concerned with is the freedom of an adult girl or boy to pick their spouse. Even if a legislation is not passed, the concept will be evolved. But the changes cannot be expected to come in a repressive society”.

The bench, requiring a copy of the suggestions to be served on the ASG and granting 2 weeks’ time to reply thereon, scheduled the matter for February 5.

 

The article was first published at: 

http://www.livelaw.in/khap-panchayats-cant-question-adults-choice-marriage-sc/

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

LGBT Marriage Story

My Story: “While Fight For LGBT Marriage Is On, No Law Can Stop Me From Calling Her My Wife”

Women Cremate Father Khap Outcast

Rajasthan: Four Girls Cremate Their Father As Per His Last Wish, Khap Panchayat Declares Them As “Outcasts”

My Story: “Everyone Has The Choice To Be A Victim Or A Victor & I Still Choose To Emerge As A Victor”

Adult Couples Can Live Together Even If Not Married, Says Supreme Court

Hadiya

We Cannot Question The Legitimacy Of An Adult Woman’s Choice Of Marriage: SC On Hadiya Case

ASER

21% Of India’s Youth Don’t Know The State They Live In; Preparation For Adult Life ‘Worryingly Low’: ASER

Latest on The Logical Indian

Legal

Contempt Notice Issued To Rahul Gandhi For Attributing “Chowkidar Chor Hai” Remark To Supreme Court

Get Inspired

A Daughter Like No Other: Girl Donates 65% Of Liver To Her Ailing Father To Save His Life

News

Situation In West Bengal Like Bihar 15 Yrs Ago, Says EC Special Observer Over Violence In State

News

“Will Popularise Cow Urine After I Win The Elections,” Says Sadhvi Pragya

Awareness

How CJI Being On Bench That Judged The Allegations Of Sexual Assault Against Him “Threatens The Judiciary”

Legal

SC Orders Rs 50 Lakh Compensation To Gujarat Riots Victim Bilkis Bano; Know About Her

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.