A controversy erupted during the Karnataka Common Entrance Test (CET) after students were allegedly asked to remove their janivara (sacred thread traditionally worn by many Brahmins) before entering exam halls at centres in Bidar and Shivamogga districts.
In Bidar, a student reportedly missed the Mathematics paper after refusing to remove the thread, sparking outrage and protests from community organisations. Authorities have since suspended officials at the exam centre and launched inquiries, while Karnataka’s Higher Education Minister M. C. Sudhakar said there were no instructions requiring removal of religious symbols and promised action if wrongdoing is established.
The matter has now reached the Karnataka High Court through a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by a Brahmin organisation alleging that students were denied entry for wearing the sacred thread and that their rights were violated.
Student Questions Exam Protocols
The controversy came to light after a CET candidate from Bidar alleged that staff at the Sai Spoorthi PU College exam centre instructed him to remove his janivara before entering the hall for the Mathematics exam.
The student reportedly argued that the sacred thread is an essential part of his religious practice and requested permission to keep it on, pointing out that he had already written the Physics and Chemistry papers the previous day without any objection.
However, after waiting and pleading with the staff for nearly 45 minutes, he ultimately left the centre without writing the Mathematics paper. Officials later confirmed that he was allowed to appear for the Biology paper in the afternoon while wearing the thread.
Similar allegations surfaced in Shivamogga, where three students at the Adichunchanagiri PU College exam centre were reportedly asked by security personnel to remove their sacred threads before entering the hall. According to police inquiries, one student refused but was eventually allowed to write the exam, while two others reportedly removed the thread to avoid missing the test.
The incidents triggered protests from members of the Brahmin community, who argued that the instruction hurt religious sentiments and amounted to unnecessary interference with cultural practices.
Probe Launched Amid Protests, Legal Challenge
Following the public outcry, authorities initiated inquiries into the incidents. District officials in Bidar issued show-cause notices and conducted investigations into the conduct of exam staff. Reports indicate that the principal and a clerk at the Sai Spoorthi PU College exam centre were dismissed after a district report found negligence in implementing the CET dress code guidelines.
The report suggested that exam staff may have mistaken the sacred thread for a prohibited accessory, leading to a misinterpretation of the rules.
In Shivamogga, two home guards deployed at the exam centre were suspended after allegations that they had instructed students to remove the sacred thread during frisking. Police also registered a case against officials involved in conducting the exam to determine whether protocols had been misapplied.
Authorities clarified that the CET guidelines prohibit certain accessories but do not explicitly require candidates to remove religious threads such as the janivara.
The issue soon expanded beyond local administrative action and entered the legal arena. The Akhila Karnataka Brahmana Mahasabha filed a Public Interest Litigation before the Karnataka High Court alleging that students had been denied entry into exam halls for wearing sacred threads.
Hearing the petition, the High Court issued notices to the state government and the Karnataka Examinations Authority (KEA), seeking their response to the allegations. The petition argued that forcing students to remove religious symbols or denying them entry violated their constitutional rights, including freedom of religion and the right to education.
Meanwhile, Karnataka’s Higher Education Minister M. C. Sudhakar described the incident as “unfortunate” and emphasised that no official instruction had been issued to remove religious symbols during the CET examination process. He stated that the government respects all faiths and that strict action would be taken if officials were found responsible for misconduct.
The state government also explored options to ensure that the affected student does not lose out academically, including offering the possibility of retaking the Mathematics exam or receiving an average score based on his other subject marks.
The Logical Indian’s Perspective
Competitive examinations such as the CET play a crucial role in shaping the educational futures of thousands of students across India. While maintaining exam integrity and security is essential, it is equally important that such procedures are implemented with clarity, sensitivity, and respect for cultural diversity. The janivara controversy underscores how unclear guidelines or overzealous enforcement can unintentionally disrupt a student’s academic opportunity and create social tensions.
Educational authorities must ensure that security protocols are clearly communicated to staff and candidates alike so that religious or cultural practices are not misinterpreted as violations. Transparency in investigations and accountability for mistakes can help restore public trust and reassure students that fairness and dignity remain central to the examination process.
Also read: From Farmlands to First Rank: Sitapur Girls Top UP Board Class 10 and 12 Results
