The Intolerance Debate Is Flawed. Here’s Why

Sudhanva Shetty

November 27th, 2015 / 3:08 PM

Image Source: tehelka

For the past many weeks, there has been a major national debate on whether India is becoming an intolerant nation. The proponents of this argument cite two trends: one, the recent string of attacks on journalists and freethinkers; and two, the extremism of the anti-beef lobby. The opponents of the argument brand the proponents as anti-Government and politically biased.

Controversial statements by certain political leaders have added fuel to the fire. A growing number of celebrities and civil society activists have given their opinions on the topic. Also, many Sahitya Akademi awardees have returned their awards in protest – and others opposed the same in what has come to be known as ‘Award Wapsi’.

While approaching the issue of intolerance, it is important to note a few valid points with a broad mind:
• No country on earth can claim to be fully tolerant; all countries have friction between communities.
• India is not like any other country – we are a staggeringly diverse nation. As such, it is practically impossible to expect zero cases of communal violence in a nation as dynamic as India.
• We are a robust democracy, but still a young democracy.
• It is the right of every Indian to protest non-violently for anything, even if the cause is unnecessary; free speech is constitutionally guaranteed.

Understanding the aforementioned points, let us now try to accept two very important and hard truths:
• There are elements in Indian society which wish to inflict disorder and which are inherently intolerant.
• However, for a democracy of 1.26 billion people, a dozen religions, three thousand castes and countless ideological factions, India is relatively peaceful.

The debate on intolerance is both important and flawed: important because any debate that involves the country is worth having, and flawed because of the direction it has taken. Problems arise when people give it a religious dimension; India has communal elements, but they are fringe elements. The majority of Indians are not driven by religious divisions; our Constitution is highly liberal and so is our legal system. There are loopholes and imperfections, but ignoring the bigger picture would be unwise and agenda-driven. If India was a religiously intolerant country we would not have survived 70 years of being the most diverse democracy on earth.

In conclusion:
• India, like every country, has both tolerant and intolerant elements in it.
• India is not religiously intolerant. We are a diverse nation and we are largely proud of our diversity. A few violent fringe elements do not represent the rest of us.
• Opposing people who return their awards by asking them to “Go to Saudi Arabia or Pakistan,” is uneducated and stupid.
• The media has largely failed in giving people the full picture, leaving them to come to their own, half-informed conclusions.
• Anytime we have a national debate, it is important to approach it in as apolitical a manner as we can. Otherwise, we risk losing whatever we can accomplish by having the debate.


Contributors

Edited by :

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Marital Rape

“Marital Rape Laws Will Be Misused By Women” Is A Flawed Argument; Here’s How The Accused Can Be Punished

Here Kids Debate Their Problems With Their Teachers And Gain Knowledge Through Experiential Learning Methods

Intolerance

A Week Of Intolerance: An Atheist Murdered & Many Arrested/Imprisoned For Facebook Posts

Do Not Throw Away Expired Credit, Debit Cards, Here’s Why

Here’s Why: All Aeroplane Windows Have Round Edges

Here’s Why: Next Time You Help A Road Accident Victim, No One Can Harras You

Latest on The Logical Indian

News

UP: Over 70 Children Die In A Span Of Two Months In A Govt Hospital

My Social Responsibility

Poverty Didn’t Let Him Study, Now He Provides Free Schooling To Children Of Widows, Prisoners & Ailing Parents

News

“BJP Govt Was A Silent Spectator During Gujarat Riots,” Says Assam Text Book; FIR Against Authors & The Publisher

Exclusive

“Don’t Need To Dissociate Myself From My Religion To Be A Gay,” One Of India’s First Gay Rights Activists

News

PM Modi Launches Ayushman Bharat Yojna: Know All About It

News

Dr Kafeel Khan And His Brother Arrested In A Nine-Year-Old Alleged Bank Fraud Case

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.