Could India Bring Experts Into Policy Making Positions Like The United States

Al Arafat Sherfuddeen

June 27th, 2016 / 4:25 PM

Image Source: vosizneias

Elections in India has undergone its silent evolution, today the electoral fortunes of representatives nominated by the political parties largely hinge on the pivotal figure of the party (who is most likely the Prime Ministerial candidate of India or the Chief Ministerial candidate of the state). The popularity and trust gained by this single pivotal figure swing the fortunes of his/her political party. This is a trend very similar to the presidential electoral race of the United States. While India has evolved into quasi-presidential form (when it comes to choosing you elected representatives), it has to live with the limitations of the representative democracy that India is.


So what is the biggest limitation of Indian representative democracy?
According to article 74 of the Indian constitution, the Prime Minister has to choose his council of ministers from the elected members of either house of the parliament. The elected members have no prior qualification requirements and hence it is largely by chance that Indian citizens get experts to head any specific ministry. On the contrary,  the US president has a free hand in choosing his cabinet and hence the policy making body largely has experts with domain knowledge.


Does domain expertise help in better policy decisions?
Certainly yes, but the biggest requirement of any representative would be to represent the aspirations of the people, have their ears to the ground and affect policy decisions that serve the larger good. India in the past and present have had fantastic ministers who not really have domain expertise, yet, if given a choice, India could perhaps come up with better policy initiatives with experts on their side.


How relevant is the representative democracy in India?
Relevance and irrelevance depend on how many people vote based on the candidate of a particular constituency. India still elects its fair share of independent candidates, that would mean a lot of times of the profile of the candidate do play a role. There are also a  large number of elected representatives with criminal backgrounds, that largely means, people are voting for the pivotal figure of the party and hence they overlook the profile of the candidate they vote for.
At a time when innovation drives many western nation’s growth, isn’t it time for India to think of the way where we could bring in experts into policy-making positions?
Could India take some of the aspects of presidential democracy and incorporate into our representative democracy, to make it work to our benefit?
Could we do a course change and transform ourselves into a presidential form of democracy?
We leave it to your imagination. Do share your thoughts.

Contributors

Edited by :

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

India Slips 3 Positions To The 11th Rank In The FDI Confidence Index 2018, Retains 2nd Position Among Emerging Market

GDP India

3 States’ Contribution To India’s GDP Higher Than That Of 20 States Combined

Following Tuesday’s Chemical Attack Which Killed 86, The United States Has Officially Bombed Syria

Climate Change

United States Forced G20 To Drop Any Mention Of Climate Change In Joint Statement

BJP To Win UP: We Hope They Transform One Of India’s Most Backward States Into One Of India’s Best

915 Coins Removed From Turtle’s Stomach

915 Coins Thrown Into Water To Bring Good Luck Removed From Turtle’s Stomach In Thailand

Latest on The Logical Indian

Get Inspired

Humanity At Work: Cab Driver Refuses To Abandon Two Women Alone At Night, Waits With Them For 1.5 Hrs

News

Accused Of Rape At The Age Of 16 For Consensual Sex, 46-Yr-Old Man Finally Absolved Of Charges

News

“Learning Is Not A Competition”: Singapore Will No Longer Rank Students By Exam Results

News

“You Don’t Look Hindu”: Indian Scientist Denied Entry To Garba Event In USA

Awareness

Fact Check: 2008 Bronze Statue Of Sardar Patel By Gujarati Sculptor Circulated As Statue Of Unity

My Social Responsibility

This Psychologist Reformed Nearly 4000 Criminals In Eleven Telangana Jails

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.