My Five Year Old Son Asked: “Dad, Are ‪All Muslims Our Enemy?”

The Logical Indian

July 7th, 2015 / 5:40 PM

Image: ashtoncentralmosque

 

“Dad, are ‪‎Muslims‬ our enemies?”
I dropped my book on my lap and looked up with my best WTF look on my face.
My 5 yr old Son was standing in the front of me, his hands on his hips giving me an impish look.
“Why do you ask that?”, I enquired a bit hesitantly.
He frowned, “We have this guy Altaf in our class and everyone says he is our enemy because he is a Muslim. No one sits with him anymore and we are going to beat him up tomorrow in the recces.”
Okay !!! This was more serious than I thought it was. And kinda scarier too, especially coming from the mouth of a 5 year old.
“But why do you think that Muslims are our enemies”, I asked him trying to keep my voice calm.
“Dad, we are reading Shivaji Maharaj’s history in class. Muslims came to our country and killed a lot of our people, so Shivaji Maharaj fought against them …. so Muslims are our enemy, no?”

Hmm, this was gonna be a tough one. “Well, Shivaji Maharaj also had a lot of Muslims in his own Army, who fought against the Moghuls. Just like there are a lot of Muslims in our Indian Army fighting for our protection against Pakistan”, I told him.
He seemed to pause for a moment, thinking about it, so I got another chance.
“And British invaded our country and killed a lot of our people, so are Britishers our enemy too?”

He made a face, “No, I like Martin Uncle (a friend of mine from UK who visits often). He is nice. He is not my enemy”.
I smiled at him. “So what do you think now?”
He grinned, “Okay bye bye” he said and started walking off.
“Whoa Whoa Whoa !!! Wait up !! What about Altaf? You and your friends were planning to beat him up tomorrow”, I inquired.
He turned and smiled, “Nah !!! Plan Cancel. I am going to sit with him tomorrow.”
My smile grew wider, “But, what about your friends? They will think you are their enemy because you are sitting with a Muslim”
He didn’t even spend a moment before replying, “When I was born, I didn’t have those guys as my friends. I didn’t have Altaf as my enemy either. I think I will choose my friends and my enemies according to what I like.”
He turned and went to play. And I smiled a rather proud smile.

Innocent Minds can think the most rationally perhaps.
Maybe, tomorrow he will come back with a broken nose. But atleast he is going to stand for what he believes in and not because of something fed to him.
I wonder how many people here have friends or enemies just because of who they were born as…… Me??
I like making them as I grow based on my experiences with an individual. And it appears, so does my Son.

Disclaimer: This Story is absolutely true with no changes made. I wonder, sometimes, how kids can actually teach us grown ups a lot of things. Perhaps we should have all remained innocent loving kids than growing up into Adults filled with hate.

From the timeline of Darshan Mondkar

Twitter-Banner


Contributors

Edited by :

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Urban Naxals

Know About The Five Petitioners Who Are Fighting For The Five Activists Arrested

Custodial Death

After 13-Yr-Long Fight, A Mother Gets Justice For Son; Five Policemen Convicted For Custodial Death

Dalit

“They Asked Him What His Caste Was And Then Arrested Him” Brother Of 14-Year-Old Dalit Boy Recalls

Madhya Pradesh Farmers Protest

Madhya Pradesh: Police Opened Fire On Protesting Farmers, Five Killed And Five Injured

Mother Buy Her Son Back

Mother Travels 2,000 KM To Earn Rs 2,000 To “Buy” Her Seven-Year-Old Son Back

Wheelchair Mini-Scooter

Asked To Pay Bribe For Wheelchair, An Accident Victim In Telangana Uses Son’s Mini-Scooter To Reach Hospital Ward

Latest on The Logical Indian

My Social Responsibility

Diwali Everyday: This NGO Is Lighting Up India’s Villages With Solar-Powered Lamps

News

Two Months On, Farmers In Drought-Hit Maharashtra Yet To Receive Compensation

Fact Check

Fact Check: Man Claims To Be Uncle Of Child Priyanka Chaturvedi Tweeted Photo With

News

Dera Chief Gurmeet Ram Rahim And Three Others Get Life Term For Journalist’s Murder

News

First Dalit Akhara Head In Kumbh Mela Calls For “Gharwapsi” Of Those Who Left Hinduism

News

IISERs, IITs To Mentor Schools To Ensure Students Do Not Lag Behind: Prakash Javadekar

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.