Autonomy vs. Accountability: Govt. Attempt To Dilute Educational Institutions?

The Logical Indian

June 23rd, 2015 / 2:31 PM

The HRD Ministry has drafted a new IIM bill, which allegedly gives the ministry authority over the Indian Institutes of Management in a number of affairs. However, the bill has been at the centre of controversy as the academia is of the opinion that political interference and micromanagement can adversely affect the educational excellence of these premiere institutes.

The bill has a few positive provisions as well, such as giving degrees to students instead of diplomas. However, a number of clauses seek to centralize power: • The Centre can override the Board of Governors, which was hitherto the independent governing body of each IIM. • The Board can make regulations regarding tenure, remuneration, etc. for IIM employees, but only after taking approval from the Centre. • The ministry’s approval will be required for matters related to admission criteria, scholarships and conducting Board meetings.

This is not the only recent instance of the Government trying to impinge on the autonomy of institutes of higher education.

► On June 10, Padma Shri Prof. Bimal Roy was sacked from his post as the Director of Indian Statistical Institute, Kolkata, by the Union Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation. The disciplinary action was reportedly taken on grounds of “financial and administrative irregularities” reported in a letter to the ministry by former BJP MP, Arun Shourie, in his capacity as the chairman of ISI Council. Massive student protests demanding justice and proper investigation followed.

► Students of Film and Television Institute of India, Pune recently went on strikes to protest against the appointment of television actor Gajendra Chauhan as the new chairman of FTII’s governing council. The students are of the opinion that the appointment to the key post was done purely out of consideration of Chauhan’s affiliation with BJP, and not because of his merits.

Why is autonomy important?

Autonomous institutions usually have a board composed of senior faculty and administrative members that takes all the decisions pertaining to the institute’s welfare. Thus, the institute is free to do whatever the educated academia thinks is appropriate for education and research. Political interference in such administrative structures, however, might tend to shift the focus to political gains rather than educational excellence. Appointments and admissions should definitely be free from any political influences whatsoever.

However, it is also true that there should be a certain level of accountability, especially in financial matters. The Logical Indian believes that the government should form policies that allow it to oversee institutional policies without interfering in matters which our educated academia can handle more efficiently than our politicians.

-Spandan Mondal


Contributors

Edited by :

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Dalit IB Ministry

Govt Tells News Channels To Use “Scheduled Caste” Instead Of “Dalit”, Activists Say This An Attempt To Erase Their Identity

Fact Check: An Educational Video From Pakistan Is Edited And Shared To Spread Fear Of Child Kidnappers

UGC Grants Autonomy To 52 Universities Including JNU, BHU

Defence Ministry Refuses To Review Rs. 10,000 Cap On Educational Expenses Of Martyrs’ Children

Rajya Sabha Passes IIM Bill, Grants Them Autonomy And Power To Give Degrees

Operation White Coat

Sting Operation By Cobrapost Reveals Pvt Hospitals Paid Doctors To Redirect Their Patients To Their Institutions

Latest on The Logical Indian

News

Telangana: Grievance Redressal System For 23 Rural Development Schemes Reduced To 4; Lakhs Affected

Awareness

The Three Judges Cases: How Three Judgments Made The Modern Indian Judiciary

News

Asianet Says They Acted In Accordance With Law In Sexual Harassment Case Filed Against Abhinav Khare

Awareness

Growth Promoting Antibiotics Banned In US & Europe Continue To Be Sold In India

News

Sabarimala Temple: Even After 24 Hrs, No Woman Allowed To Enter Sanctum Sanctorum Of Lord Ayyappa Shrine

News

Kabaddi Coach from SAI Hangs Himself After Being Found Guilty Of Sexual Harassment

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.