The Supreme Court on November 20 dismissed two applications filed by Tamil Nadu seeking directions to Karnataka to release around 11 thousand million cubic feet (TMC) of Cauvery water to make up for what the state described as a shortfall. A Bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Singh passed the order. Tamil Nadu told the Court that it was facing an 11.719 TMC shortfall at Biligundlu up to October 6, and argued that inadequate water was affecting crops and farmers.
Karnataka opposed the demand, citing drought, reduced reservoir inflows and the need to conserve water for drinking and other priority requirements. The decision comes amid continuing disagreements between the two states over how Cauvery water should be shared during a distress year.
Tamil Nadu Seeks Backlog
Tamil Nadu’s latest plea was part of a series of applications filed before the Supreme Court over Cauvery releases this year. The state argued that, even after accounting for reduced water availability during a distress year, Karnataka had not released the quantity due to it. It told the Court that the shortfall at Biligundlu, the inter-state measuring point, stood at 11.719 TMC as of October 6.
Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for Tamil Nadu, argued that the water was urgently needed because the delay was affecting cultivation in the Cauvery delta.
Tamil Nadu has maintained that a water deficit cannot simply be carried forward because farmers need water during the crop cycle itself. During the October hearing, Rohatgi argued that the backlog should be addressed rather than allowing the shortage to continue. The state also contended that the releases ordered periodically by the CWRC and CWMA were insufficient to eliminate the accumulated deficit.
The latest application therefore sought additional releases from Karnataka to make good the alleged backlog. The Court, however, declined to grant the requested relief. Justice Nath also indicated in open court that a third application filed by Tamil Nadu on November 20 would also be dismissed, according to LiveLaw.
Karnataka Cites Drought
Karnataka opposed Tamil Nadu’s demand, arguing that the state itself was experiencing severe water stress. Senior advocate Shyam Divan, appearing for Karnataka, told the Supreme Court that several areas were drought-affected and that water needed to be conserved to protect drinking-water supplies. Karnataka also argued that Tamil Nadu could benefit from the Northeast monsoon, while the same rainfall would not provide comparable relief to Karnataka’s Cauvery basin.
Karnataka’s position was also presented before the CWRC earlier this month. At its November 6 meeting, the state said inflows into its four major Cauvery basin reservoirs were 53.88% below the 30-year average, while 55 of 56 taluks in the basin were drought-hit. Karnataka said that, between June 1 and November 6, 54.964 TMC had flowed at Biligundlu and that the flow during the relevant CWRC/CWMA directive period was above the quantity prescribed by those authorities.
Karnataka Water Resources Minister N Cheluvarayaswamy said the state government would take necessary steps to protect Karnataka’s interests while considering its available water and priority requirements.
Fresh Release Direction
The Supreme Court’s decision follows another round of negotiations before the Cauvery regulatory authorities. On November 6, the CWRC directed Karnataka to release enough water from its reservoirs to ensure a flow of 3,000 cusecs at Biligundlu every day for 15 days from November 7. The CWMA subsequently approved the decision. The release over the 15-day period was estimated at about 3.88 TMC.
Tamil Nadu, however, told the CWRC that it had a 16.895 TMC shortfall as of November 4 and alleged that flows had fallen below the prescribed 3,000 cusecs on several days between October 24 and November 4. It sought a larger release to address the outstanding quantity and support its Samba crop.
These competing figures underline the central disagreement: Tamil Nadu says it has not received its proportionate share even after accounting for distress conditions, while Karnataka argues that the available water is itself severely constrained and that further releases could jeopardise its drinking-water and other priority needs.
What The 2018 Order Says
The current dispute is governed by the Supreme Court’s February 2018 Cauvery judgment, which modified the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal’s allocation. The Court awarded Karnataka 284.75 TMC and Tamil Nadu 404.25 TMC of the basin’s water allocation, with Kerala receiving 30 TMC and Puducherry 7 TMC.
Under that framework, Karnataka is required to release 177.25 TMC at Biligundlu for Tamil Nadu in a normal water year. The arrangement also recognises that releases have to be adjusted when the basin experiences distress and water availability is lower than normal.
The difficulty lies in applying that principle during a year when both states report water scarcity. Tamil Nadu has argued that the available water must be distributed proportionately and that the lower-riparian state cannot bear a disproportionate share of the deficit. Karnataka, meanwhile, has argued that it too must retain sufficient water for its own essential needs.
A Recurring Conflict
The dispute has continued through several rounds of CWRC and CWMA directions this year. In September, the authorities directed Karnataka to ensure specified flows at Biligundlu, while Tamil Nadu repeatedly argued that the quantities being released were insufficient to address the accumulating deficit. In October, the CWMA had directed a 3,000-cusecs flow for 15 days from October 9, following an earlier direction for 4,000 cusecs.
The Supreme Court had also questioned how Karnataka could clear the alleged backlog when both states were experiencing water scarcity. Karnataka maintained that this was fundamentally a distress-year situation and that the existing regulatory mechanism was already examining the matter through regular meetings.
The latest Supreme Court decision does not end the wider Cauvery dispute or change the underlying 2018 allocation. Instead, it rejects Tamil Nadu’s present applications seeking additional releases to make up the alleged shortfall. The two states will continue to depend on the CWRC and CWMA to regulate releases based on rainfall, inflows, reservoir storage and competing water requirements.
The Logical Indian’s Perspective
The Cauvery dispute is ultimately about people, not just numbers on a water-sharing chart. Farmers in Tamil Nadu need reliable water to protect their crops, while communities in drought-hit parts of Karnataka also depend on the same river and reservoirs for drinking water and livelihoods. In a distress year, neither state’s concerns can simply be dismissed.
Beyond court battles and periodic release orders, both states need transparent data-sharing, predictable distress-year rules and sustained dialogue so that farmers and ordinary citizens do not become casualties of an inter-state dispute. Can Karnataka and Tamil Nadu find a cooperative way to share the Cauvery that protects both farmers and drinking-water needs, even when the river itself is running short?
Also Read: India’s Sonalben Patel Scripts History With Maiden World Para Table Tennis Championship Bronze Medal













