AI Generated

Rahul Gandhi Acquitted by MP-MLA Court in 2018 Amit Shah Defamation Case After 8 Years

A Sultanpur court ruled that Rahul Gandhi’s 2018 remarks about Amit Shah were not defamatory, while the complainant considers an appeal.

Supported by

Congress leader and Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, was acquitted by a special MP-MLA court in Sultanpur, Uttar Pradesh, on October 26, 2026, in a criminal defamation case concerning his 2018 remarks about Amit Shah, who was then the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) president. Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Shubham Verma acquitted Gandhi, observing that complainant Vijay Mishra did not qualify as an aggrieved person entitled to file the complaint under the law. The court also held that the remarks did not meet the legal threshold for criminal defamation.

The complaint was filed by BJP leader Vijay Mishra, who alleged that Gandhi’s comments damaged Shah’s reputation. Gandhi appeared before the court for the verdict, bringing the proceedings in this case to an acquittal. Following the verdict, Mishra’s lawyer, Santosh Pandey, indicated that he would examine the certified copy of the judgment before deciding on further legal action. Mishra also said he would consult his lawyer after reviewing the order before approaching an appellate court.

Court Rules Remarks Were Not Defamatory

The case stemmed from remarks Gandhi made in Bengaluru on May 8, 2018, during the Karnataka Assembly election campaign. Referring to Shah, Gandhi reportedly said, “People in India forget that the president of BJP is a murder accused.” The statement referred to the Sohrabuddin Sheikh encounter case, in which a special Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) court had discharged Shah in 2014. Mishra, a local BJP leader and former chairman of the Sultanpur District Cooperative Bank, filed the complaint on August 4, 2018, under Sections 499 and 500 of the Indian Penal Code, which dealt with criminal defamation and its punishment.

The court examined whether Mishra was legally entitled to file the complaint and whether Gandhi’s remarks amounted to criminal defamation. It held that Mishra was not an aggrieved person under Section 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, as the remarks were primarily directed at Amit Shah and, at most, the BJP. The court also found that Mishra had failed to establish that the remarks had harmed his personal reputation or that he was authorised by the BJP to represent the party in the complaint.

While acquitting Rahul Gandhi, the court observed that complainant Vijay Mishra did not qualify as an aggrieved person under the law to maintain the complaint. It also found insufficient evidence to establish that Gandhi’s remarks had damaged Mishra’s reputation.

An Eight-Year Legal Battle

The complaint moved through several stages before reaching the verdict. Gandhi appeared before the Sultanpur court in February 2024 and secured bail. During the proceedings, Mishra sought a comparison of Gandhi’s voice sample with a recording of the Bengaluru speech. The trial court rejected the application, and subsequent challenges before the sessions court and the Allahabad High Court were also unsuccessful. The court initially scheduled the verdict for October 13, 2026, before postponing it to October 26.

Following the acquittal, Mishra’s lawyer, Santosh Pandey, confirmed the outcome. Mishra has indicated that he plans to obtain the certified copy of the judgment, consult his lawyer and consider an appeal. The verdict therefore settles the complaint at the trial-court level for now, but further legal action remains possible. The case also needs to be distinguished from other defamation proceedings involving Gandhi, as each has its own facts and legal outcome.

The Logical Indian’s Perspective

Political criticism is essential to democracy, allowing citizens and elected representatives to question those in power and scrutinise public conduct. At the same time, public figures retain the right to seek legal remedies when they believe their reputations have been harmed. This case underlines the importance of examining contested statements through evidence, fair hearings and due process rather than political allegiance or public sentiment. The acquittal is a judicial decision in a specific complaint, not a blanket endorsement of every statement made during political campaigns.

If an appeal follows, the legal process must continue to be guided by evidence and fairness. A healthy democracy needs space for robust disagreement without allowing political differences to undermine mutual respect or the rule of law. How can India protect the right to question those in power while ensuring that political debate remains responsible and grounded in facts?

Also Read: EC Orders Statewide Scrutiny Of UP Voter Lists After Post-SIR Irregularities Emerge; Roll Fell By Around 2 Crore During SIR

#PoweredByYou We bring you news and stories that are worth your attention! Stories that are relevant, reliable, contextual and unbiased. If you read us, watch us, and like what we do, then show us some love! Good journalism is expensive to produce and we have come this far only with your support. Keep encouraging independent media organisations and independent journalists. We always want to remain answerable to you and not to anyone else.

Featured

Amplified by

Amazon Prime

For Two Nights in June, Mumbai’s Sea Link and Asiatic Library Wore Light Like They’ve Never Worn It Before

Amplified by

Ministry of Road Transport and Highways

From Risky to Safe: Sadak Suraksha Abhiyan Makes India’s Roads Secure Nationwide

Recent Stories

Manisha Bhanwala Makes Wrestling History, Becomes First Indian Woman To Win World Championships Gold

Delhi Mangolpuri Factory Fire: 4 Dead, 2 Injured As Massive Blaze Engulfs Shoe Unit

Panama-Flagged Tanker With 27 Indians Hit By Limpet Mines In Strait Of Hormuz

Contributors

Writer : 
Editor : 
Creatives :