Plastic Ban: A Patchwork Of Good Intentions And Half-Hearted Implementation

The Logical Indian Karnataka

March 23rd, 2019 / 3:51 PM

Plastic Ban BBMP Karnataka

Image Credit: Indian Express (Representational)

The Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagar Palike (BBMP) carried out raids across five zones in the city on 20th March. They fined top restaurants and bars, including KFC, CCD, and Adyar Anand Bhavan, for using plastics and not segregating waste, reported The News Minute. While four of the establishments were shut, penalties of Rs.14.42 lacs were also imposed on all the raided establishments. The amount of banned plastic seized was to the tune of 1,074 kgs.

Another such raid was conducted on 16th March across 6 shopping malls wherein the total amount of plastic seized was 1,010 kgs and the penalties imposed amounted to Rs.13.15 lacs.

In the three years since the Karnataka Government banned the manufacture and use of plastics the BBMP has conducted several such raids and surprise checks throughout the city, levying hefty fines from every establishments that violated the plastic ban. But three years down the line, traders/businesses continue to use plastics, choosing to risk a raid instead.

India has been more-or-less active in addressing the issue of waste generation and its impact on the environment. Himachal Pradesh became the first state to ban plastic shopping bags in 2009. Since then, all but 4 Indian states have instituted a similar ban on various forms of plastic. But is simply banning a material so deeply embedded into our economy the answer? According to DownToEarth, “… outright bans have a poor track record in altering behaviour of stakeholders, which is key to developing sustainable policies.”

It then becomes imperative to look at the implications of plastic ban on the stakeholders to understand why it has such a marginal impact.

In the case of production, a sudden ban has a huge impact on small scale manufacturers as is evident from the case of Maharashtra’s ban on plastic bags. These manufacturers work on a very small margin and a lack of adjustment time between the announcement and the implementation of the ban makes it impossible for them to switch to newer technologies. A lack of any cheap alternatives only adds to their woes. Large companies on the other hand start lobbying for exemptions and almost always succeed. A lack of accountability on their part and the confusion on the part of the authorities makes for a complicated situation where the low-income traders get a the shorter end of the stick.

The result is a strong resistance from the industry which eventually causes a change in policies and/or a delay in implementation.

In case of consumers, a lack of awareness and the know-how of alternatives contributes to an unwillingness on their part to accommodate the change. This again results in a form of resistance wherein the consumers try to find ways to beat the ban.

The result is thus a patchwork of rules and penalties which despite being good in intention have little to no impact on the problem at hand. Constant lobbying, backtracking, and confusion on the part of stakeholders goes on to show that there is no one-size-fits-all solution in an economy as diverse as India.


Also Read: Mumbai: 6 Lakh Rs Collected As Fine Within Three Days Of Plastic Ban, McDonald’s And Starbucks Among Fined


Contributors

Written by : Samarth Kashyap (Intern)

Edited by : Debarghya Sil

Related Stories

Assam Gogoi NRC

CJI Ranjan Gogoi Defends NRC Implementation In Assam, Calls It Document For Future

ANI Military Veterans

Military Veterans Accuse ANI Of ‘Defaming’ Intentions Of The Appeal Against Politicisation Of Army

Universal Basic Income

Universal Basic Income: The Meaning, Merits & The Feasibility Of Its Implementation In India

CAG Report Irrigation

“Deficiencies In Planning, Implementation & Monitoring” In Irrigation Projects Led To Increased Costs: CAG

Pay Commission Demand

Govt Rejects Army’s Demand For Implementation Of 7th Pay Commission

Majerhat Bridge Collapse

Hasty Patchwork, Dubious “Fit Certificate” & Unexplained Delays – Was Kolkata Bridge Disaster On The Cards?

Latest on The Logical Indian

Exclusive

Kashmir Denied Its Faith: “How Do We Live Without Hope?”, Citizens Ask As Every Practice Restricted

News

Modi Govt Overruled RBI To Bring ‘Secretive Channel’ For Party Funding Via Electoral Bonds

News

Agra To Be Renamed As Agravan? UP Govt Mulls Name Change

News

India Jumps Up Two Spots In The International Schools Race, One Place Behind China

Fact Check

Fact Check: IANS Photo Of MiG-29K Crash That Happened In Goa Is Old & Is From Peru

News

Activist Cites India Repealing Article 377 While Demanding Removal Of Ban On Gay Sex In Singapore Court

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.