Consumer Court Orders Insurer To Pay Woman As Weight-Loss Surgery Not Always Cosmetic

The Logical Indian Crew Gujarat

November 9th, 2018 / 6:32 PM

Weight Loss Surgery Consumer Court

Representational Image

The Consumer Court in Ahmedabad has ordered the insurer to pay Rs. 3.17 lakh spent on bariatric surgery by a patient, stating that surgery need not be of cosmetic nature.

What had happened?

A 64-year-old woman in Thatlej area, identified as Leenaben Desai weighed 102kgs. She suffered from chronic gastroesophageal reflux disease and hyperacidity. Dr Chirag Desai, her physician had advised her to undergo gastric bypass surgery for the mentioned illness along with morbid obesity and fatty liver. She underwent bariatric surgery in May 2016.

The patient had claimed her medical insurance for obesity treatment. The insurance company didn’t oblige to pay her believing the myth that bariatric surgery is for cosmetic concern. Desai approached the Consumer Dispute Redressal Forum in Ahmedabad in 2017 to sue the insurer.

The court asked the company to pay the reimbursement with 8% interest along with Rs. 5000 compensation for causing legal expenditure and mental agony as reported by Times Of IndiaThe court has refused the company’s arguments about their policy that excluded the bariatric surgery as it is not always purely for cosmetic means as various other reasons might turn life-threatening to the patient.

Bariatric Surgery

As of July 2017, India stood third in the World Obesity Ranking, with 44,332,755 obese adults – accounting for 4.9% of its adult population.

Bariatric surgery is common in recent years and is suggested for people suffering from obesity. It is a process where the size of the stomach is reduced to control the intake of food. It is done by either removing a portion of the stomach or using a gastric band.

Obesity associated with diabetes, arthritis, blood pressure and sleep apnea syndrome needs surgery and doctors do not encourage people who enquire for cosmetic reasons.

The Logical Indian spoke to Dr G Moinoddin, consultant, bariatrics, and advanced laparoscopic surgeon at Gleneagles Global Hospitals, who said, “Hypothyroid and polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) are two conditions that lead to weight gain in women. I suggest a surgery when there is no chance for weight loss by other methods like dieting or going to the gym.” 

There prevails a myth that bariatric surgery is done for cosmetic reasons for a person to look beautiful, fit and slim but it has a lot of reasons that may turn fatal if not addressed with surgery. Bariatric surgery has changed the lives of many people in India, yet it can’t be a solution for obesity as there is a risk in surgery.

Skilled surgeons are required as there might be bleeding during surgery. We give counselling before and after surgery. Reduction can’t be seen immediately but within a year,” says Dr. Satish TM, senior consultant, bariatric surgery, Lenus Hospital, told The Logical Indian. 

Also Read: Consumer Court Asks IRCTC To Pay Rs 25,000 To Passenger For Sending Wrong Text Alert


Written by : Abbinaya Kuzhanthaivel (Student, IIJNM)

Edited by : Sromona Bhattacharyya

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

IVF Cheats Man

Bengaluru: IVF Centre Cheats Man Of Rs 4.75 Lakh, Consumer Court Orders Refund & Additional Fine


Consumer Court Asks IRCTC To Pay Rs 25,000 To Passenger For Sending Wrong Text Alert

Samsung Defective Television

Telangana: District Consumer Court Orders Customer To Pay Rs 10,000 To Samsung For Defective TV

Pay Us Rs 577 Crore For Demonetisation Loss: Govt Printing Presses To RBI

Airtel Fined

Airtel Fined Rs 44.50 With 12% Interest By Consumer Court For Data Loss

My Story: My Daughter Always Takes Me Away From A Fight Saying, ‘Mum, This Is Not Your Fight, It’s Not Personal’

Latest on The Logical Indian


“Fantastic. Ex-Minister Not Traceable”: SC Slams Bihar Police For Failing To Arrest Manju Verma Linked With Shelter Home Sex Abuse


Goa: Over Formalin Scare In Fishes, Govt Bans Import From Karnataka & Other States


Burdened With Debt, Maharashtra Farmer Builds A Pyre & Sets Himself Alight


In Just 3 Hours Of Rain, Chennai Apartment Collects 1 Lakh Litres Of Water


Kolkata-Based NGO Rescues One Out Of 62 Indians Enslaved In Malaysia


Head Of Dept Sexually Harassed 28-Yr-Old Trainee Doctor, Post Which She Committed Suicide: CID Report


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.