Organisations Protest Against Transgender Protection Bill For Treating Rape Against Trans-Women As “Petty Crime”

The Logical Indian Crew

August 22nd, 2019 / 4:39 PM

Transgender Bill-Rape Law

The Lok Sabha in the recently held Parliament session passed the Transgender Persons Protection of Rights bill, 2019. The bill if becomes an act will be applicable for India’s estimated five million transgenders in India. 

The bill has attracted flak from the transgender community for keeping the punishment in case of sexual violence against trans-women from six months to two years whereas in the rape case of non-transgender women the punishment varies from 10 years to a maximum of Life imprisonment. 

One of the main clauses in the bill states “Whoever harms or injures or endangers the life, safety, health or well-being, whether mental or physical, of a transgender person or tends to do acts including causing physical abuse, sexual abuse, verbal and emotional abuse and economic abuse shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than six months but which may extend to two years and with fine.”

On 15th of August, five transgender women called out on the parliament for its hypocrisy on so-called Transgender Persons “Protection of Rights” bill on

Neysara, the founder of, said the bill treats transgenders as sub-human and questioned the gender-based gradation of punishment. 

“It is unclear what Transgender Persons Protection of Rights bill is trying to imply by diluting penalties for offences against transgender people. Endangering the life, safety, health or well-being of a person is gender-neutral. Indian society treats transgender people as anyway & this bill mirrors this sentiment. Our parliamentarians are a part of our society and hence this is their way of constitutionally declaring transgender people as sub-human,” said Neysara.

A social media campaign was also initiated on Facebook as. “72 years since Independence, Still Indian Parliamentarians believe Raping a transgender person is a petty crime punishable by 6 months to max 2 years.” 

The campaign received support from across the globe under the #RapeisRape. Before the transgender bill, there was nothing explicit about the rape of a trans woman, the Indian Penal Code only talks about rape against a woman. 

Also Read: Bihar Govt Establishes Transgender Welfare Board, To Give Rs 1.5 Lakh For Sex Change Operation


Written by : Shubhendu Deshmukh

Edited by : Bharat Nayak

Related Stories

Transgender Persons Bill Lok Sabha

Transgender Persons Bill 2019 Passes In Lok Sabha, Trans Community Disappointed

Consumer Protection Bill Passed

Consumer Protection Bill Passed In Lok Sabha Amid Protest, Will Now Face The Test Of Rajya Sabha

Bhutan Doesn’t Allow Religious Figures And Organisations To Participate In Politics; Is There Wisdom In It?

Kerala Trans Woman Found Dead

Kerala: 35-Year-Old Trans Woman Found Dead; Transgender Community Allege Foul Play

Differently Abled Story

My Story: “It Was In College I Experienced People Treating Me Differently For The First Time”

Transgender Bill 2018

Transgender Bill 2018: Know Why The Bill Is Regressive & Does More Harm Than Good

Latest on The Logical Indian

My Story

My Story: “In Grieving Kashmir, My Useless Landline Turned Into A Lifeline”


Majoritarianism & Authoritarianism Taking India Down A “Dark & Uncertain Path”: Raghuram Rajan


Primary School Children Served “Turmeric-Rice” For Mid-Day Meal in Uttar Pradesh


UP: Man Goes To Bury Deceased Daughter, Finds Baby Girl Buried Alive


GST Might Have Flaws, But We Cannot Just Damn It Now: Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman

World Affairs

World Bank Slashes India’s Growth Rate To 6%, Warns Of ‘Severe’ Economic Slowdown


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.