Heavy Workload & Erratic Schedule Can’t Be Considered As Abetment To Suicide By Boss: SC

The Logical Indian Crew India

June 29th, 2018 / 4:03 PM

Senior Suicide Due To Work Overload

Representational Image: CommlabIndia

The Supreme Court has ruled that superiors cannot be held responsible if an employee commits suicide because of heavy workload, as it can’t be assumed that he/she intended to harass an employee or force him to end his life.  

This ruling by the SC came as it rejected the argument of the Aurangabad bench of the Bombay HC that the officer should be held responsible even if there was no direct abetment because the stressful workload could lead to unbearable mental tension, as reported by The Hindu

As reported by Times of India, Kishor Parashar, who worked in the office of the deputy director of education in Maharashtra government, in their Aurangabad office, committed suicide in August 2017. His wife later complained to the police against her husband’s superior officer, accusing him of abetting the suicide. She alleged that the superior used to assign a heavy workload to Parashar, requiring him to work till late evening, which led to his mental breakdown and suicide.

According to the wife, the senior officer often mentally tortured her husband and regularly created extreme work conditions making it unbearable for Parashar. She also alleged that the officer stopped her late husband’s salary. Following the complaint, an FIR was lodged against the official, who later moved the local bench of the Bombay High Court to quash this FIR.

As per reports, on January 23, the Bombay High Court decided that the FIR could not be quashed and that the case should come under IPC Section 306. The HC observed that, although the senior officer didn’t have any such intention, cases where the victims are deliberately forced to work under extreme conditions which in turn force them to take extreme step as suicide, can come under the abetment of suicide.

After the HC observation, the senior official named in the FIR approached the Supreme Court. Nishant Katneswarkar, the Maharashtra government’s standing counsel, had appealed to the SC that the case should be dismissed as the senior officer had no intention to force the victim to commit suicide. The SC bench comprising of Justice Arun Mishra and Justice UU Lalit termed the HC observation as untenable and rejected the FIR. The bench said, “It is true that if a situation is created deliberately, to drive a person to commit suicide, there would be room for attracting Section 306 of the IPC (abetment to suicide). However, the facts on record in the present case are inadequate and insufficient (to reach that conclusion).”


Also Read: New Act Decriminalising Suicide, Humane Treatment For Mental Health Patients Announced By Centre


Contributors

Written by : Bindiya (Intern)

Edited by :

Related Stories

Gopal Kanda Air Hostess

Gopal Kanda, Accused Of Abetment To Suicide Of Air Hostess, Now BJP’s Key To Power In Haryana

Considered One Of India’s First Performance Artists, Rummana Hussain’s Art Reflects Questions Of Identity, Activism And Social Welfare

Fire Fighters MTNL Rescue

Mumbai: Firefighters Save 86 People In MTNL Building Fire, Considered As Largest Fire Rescue Operation

Solar Rickshaws Introduced At IIT-Delhi Campus; Will Reduce Workload Of The Rickshaw Pullers Substantially

SSC CGL CHSL Results

SSC Results Withheld, Aspirants Express Outrage Over Erratic Court Listings And Delay In Hearings

Stonemasons Daughter Story

My Story: “I Never Realized That My Work Was Considered To Be ‘Too’ Difficult For A Girl”

Latest on The Logical Indian

Environment

While Delhi Chokes, 25 Of 29 MPs Miss Crucial Meeting On Tackling Air Pollution

Good Governance

Karnataka: No Chips, Pizzas, Burgers In, Around Schools Anymore, Govt To Ban Sale Of Junk Food

News

“A Muslim Can’t Teach Us”, BHU Students Oppose Appointment Of Professor In Sanskrit Dept

Exclusive

Indian PhD Scholar Wins BRICS Young Scientist Award For Inventing Affrodable Milk Chilling Technology

Good Governance

Telangana Gets Its First Child-Friendly Police Station; Inaugurated By 7-year-old On Children’s Day

Environment

To Combat Air Pollution, This IRS Officer Has Created Over 20 ‘Micro Jungles’ Across The Nation

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.