No Plates, Patient With Fractured Hand Gets Food Served On The Floor In Ranchi’s Top Hospital

The Logical Indian

September 23rd, 2016

Ranchi Hospital Food

Source: NDTV | Image: Facebook

[Update: As reported by Telegraph, after the story got published on social media, chief minister Raghubar Das has asked principal health secretary K. Vidyasagar to send the fact-finding team to the hospital. Jharkhand High Court also stepped in. Taking suo motu cognisance, a bench of Chief Justice Virender Singh and Justice S. Chandrashekhar also issues notices to the chief secretary, principal health secretary and RIMS director. After a daylong probe, Vidyasagar’s team concurred with RIMS director Dr B.L. Sherwal that the woman was not a patient but a destitute but added she was served food on the floor. Later, RIMS director Dr Sherwal sacked trolley man Chandramani Prasad who served the woman food on the floor.

Thanks to media houses and the social media users, the story created an impact and there was a quick action. The Logical Indian would also like to thank the community members for spreading the word.]

At a time, when a spate of reports over the last one month — ranging from Chikungunya in New Delhi, the mournful case of Odisha’s tribal Dana Majhi and several other such cases — are clearly reflecting the deplorable state of healthcare facilities in India, another such disturbing event has been reported from Jharkhand.

In a photo surfaced recently, a patient can be seen eating food straight from the floor of a ward in the state’s biggest government hospital, the Ranchi Institute of Medical Sciences.

A woman named Palmati Devi, with her arms fractured and wrapped in the bandage, ate her meal of rice, dal and vegetables that were served by ward boys on the floor. This incident happened on Wednesday. She was also ordered to clean the floor.

Palmati Devi, at the orthopaedic ward of the hospital, had asked for a plate from the hospital staff as she didn’t have one. But she was rudely told off by the kitchen staffs that there are no plates in the hospital as well.

The hospital that has an annual budget of Rs 300 crore couldn’t arrange for a plate and food was served to her on the floor.

BL Sherwal, the hospital’s Director, told NDTV, “It’s not a common practice but we have started an inquiry and will take action those who served the food on the floor and then forced her to eat from there.”


Share your thoughts..

Propelled by


This Women’s Day Spread The Message Of Equality

Related Stories

BSF Jawan Who Posted Video Alleging Poor Quality Of Food Files Plea Against Termination  

UP: Doctors Perform 32 Cataract Surgeries Under Torch Light In A Govt Hospital

Raman Singh

Hospital Vacates Entire Floor For CM Raman Singh’s Daughter-In-Law, Pregnant Women Forced To Share Beds

MP: Pregnant Woman Allegedly Denied Treatment For Being HIV Positive, Loses Both Her Newborn Twin Daughters

Wheelchair Mini-Scooter

Asked To Pay Bribe For Wheelchair, An Accident Victim In Telangana Uses Son’s Mini-Scooter To Reach Hospital Ward

14-Year-Old AIDS Patient Made To Run Around 4 Hospitals In 24 Hours Looking For Treatment

Latest on The Logical Indian


Delhi Economic Survey 2017-18: City’s Per Capita Income Grows Almost Three Times The National Average


Small Changes In Our Lifestyle Can Lead To A Greener Tomorrow


Under New Policy, Passengers Need Not Pay For Food Purchased On Train If Bill Is Not Provided

Get Inspired

Meet Smt Lekshmikutty Who Was Awarded Padma Shri For Her Knowledge And Service In Traditional Medicine


Telangana: Govt To Remove Parking Fee In Malls And Multiplexes For First 30 Minutes


Kerala: RTI Reveals Murder Convict Of Left Leader Gets 217 Days Parole In Two Years