Citing Noise Pollution, National Green Tribunal Bans Protests At Jantar Mantar, Delhi
October 6th, 2017
A National Green Tribunal (NGT) bench, headed by Justice R.S. Rathore with the assistance of expert member Dr. Satyawan Singh Garbyal on Thursday, 5 October, instructed the Delhi government to halt immediately all dharna (sit-in), public speeches, agitations and assembly of people at the Jantar Mantar area, New Delhi.
The Jantar Mantar road area had become a symbolic protest battle ground, although the same had been earmarked as a residential area, noted the judgement.
“The respondents Government of Delhi, New Delhi Municipal Corporation and Police Commissioner, Delhi to immediately stop all the activities of dharna, protest, agitations, assembling of people, public speeches, using of loud speakers, etc. at Jantar Mantar Road,” the bench said, reported by The Hindu.
NGT was hearing a plea filed by Varun Seth and others alleging that Jantar Mantar Road were a major source of noise pollution in the area due to processions and agitations held by social groups, political parties, NGOs. They had claimed that regular protests “violate their right to live in a peaceful and healthy environment, right to silence, right to sleep and right to life with dignity.”
Besides noise pollution, large crowds, inadequate measures to maintain hygiene and vehicular obstruction had compelled the residents in the area to approach the tribunal. This was after several other representations to concerned authorities and litigation in the matter had failed to yield satisfactory results.
NGT observed that violation of environmental laws do take place, including that of Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 as the agitators continue to use the site.
The Green tribunal said that residents of the surrounding area have a right to live peacefully in an atmosphere free from pollution. The NGT reiterated that the right to free speech and expression under Article 19 cannot encroach upon fundamental rights under Article 21.
The alternative recourse
Green court ordered the authority to relocate agitators and the people holding dharna to an alternative site at the Ramleela Grounds in Ajmeri Gate “forthwith”.
Earlier, protests used to be held at the Ram Leela Maidan which gradually began to shift to the Boat Club lawns near India Gate.
When the traffic obstruction rose in this area, an administrative order was passed by the Delhi Police to shift venue to Jantar Mantar Road. This itself was deemed to be improper by the NGT.
If the number of participants exceeded five thousand, then the Ram Leela Maidan was the designated protest site. However, this is not feasible option as has been pointed out NGT – once a massive protest is going on, no one is there to relocate the agitators.
The NGT also admonished the government for its negligence on this issue.
New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC) was directed by Green panel to remove all temporary structures encroaching surrounding area used for agitations. NDMC was also instructed to stop to use of loudspeakers and public address system from a road near Connaught Place.
The entire judgement can be read here.