After Pictures Of Patients Chained In UP Mental Asylum Surfaced, SC Issues Notice

The Logical Indian Crew Uttar Pradesh

January 4th, 2019 / 3:41 PM

Mentally Ill Patients

Image Credit: ANI

“No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.”

These words are enshrined in Article 21 of the Indian Constitution, which seeks to protect the dignity of the people. However, the case was different for persons with mental illness who were kept chained at a mental asylum in Uttar Pradesh.

Patients mistreated

The pictures of the horrific case, which went viral on social media, show people tied like cattle with iron chains on their feet, kept visibly mistreated inside a dirty shed. The incident which took place at a “faith-based mental asylum” in Badaun district came to light after petitioner, advocate Gaurav Kumar Bansal furnished the pictures and told the Supreme Court that such treatment of patients violates the provisions enshrined in the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 as well as Article 21 of the constitution.

The Public Interest Litigation (PIL) also sought direction to states and union territories to establish state mental health authority and also to start a programme to provide mental health care, reported NDTV.

What did Supreme court say?

Not only did the Apex court express shock at the issue, but it also took cognisance of the issue. A bench of Justices A K Sikri and S Abdul Nazeer said that people with mental illnesses are also human beings and keeping them chained, as is practiced in some asylums, is in complete violation of human rights. While violent patients can be kept in isolation, chaining them is not a solution, reported The Times Of India.

The bench said, “People suffering from mental illness are also human beings and their dignity cannot be compromised. It is atrocious and something has to be done immediately.”

Moreover, it also hit out at the Uttar Pradesh government and sent notices to the Centre and the state governments seeking their response. Meanwhile, the solicitor general, Tushar Mehta has assured that the case will be looked into. The matter is expected to be taken up early next week.

The Logical Indian take

According to the National Mental Health Survey, 2016, nearly 14% of the Indian population required active mental health interventions while around 2% suffered acute mental disorders. Our lack of understanding of mental health problems often results in harassment and mistreatment and for people belonging to less privileged backgrounds, the problem multiplies manifold, as seen in this case.

The Logical Indian strongly condemns the treatment that has been meted out to the inmates and urges the authorities to look into the matter.

Also Read: This Psychiatrist From Kerala Is Providing Free Mental Health Care To Poor Patients


Written by : Sromona Bhattacharyya

Edited by : Poorbita Bagchi

Related Stories

Doctor Payal Tadvi Suicide Note

Pictures Of Doctor Payal Tadvi’s Missing Suicide Note Found In Her Phone

Mental Health School kids

Most School-Going Children Are Unaware Of Mental Health Issues, Says Study

Saudi Teen Surname

Saudi Teen Drops Surname After Given Asylum In Canada; Receives Protection After Threats

Dr Manoj Kumar Free Mental Health Care

This Psychiatrist From Kerala Is Providing Free Mental Health Care To Poor Patients

New Act Decriminalising Suicide, Humane Treatment For Mental Health Patients Announced By Centre

Madras High Court Banners Living Persons

Pictures Of Living Persons Can’t Be Used For Banners & Hoardings: Madras High Court

Latest on The Logical Indian


Sex Ratio At Birth Drops To 896 During 2015-17, Nearly 1.1 Crore Girls Have Gone Missing In India


Himachal Pradesh: 13 Army Personnel Killed, 28 Injured After Building Collapsed Due To Heavy Rain


Pakistan Opens Its Airspace After 140 Days Of Balakot Strike; Indian Flights Start Using The Closed Air Routes


Senior Lawyer And Rajya Sabha Member KTS Tulsi Introduces Bill For Gender Neutral Rape Law


Bihar Floods: 44 Lives Lost And 70 Lakh Affected

Fact Check

Fact Check: No, Drinking Cold Drinks Are Not Mixed With Ebola Virus-Infected Blood


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.