Supreme Court Collegium Under Question After Madras HC Chief Justice VK Tahilramani Resigns Over Transfer

The Logical Indian Crew India

September 11th, 2019 / 5:58 PM

Madras HC Vijaya Tahilramani

Image Credits: India Today

The due process of High Court judges transfer by the Supreme Court collegium is once again under question after the resignation as Madras High Court Chief Justice Vijaya K Tahilramani.

The chief justice submitted her resignation on Friday in the wake of Supreme Court collegium’s August 28 decision to transfer her to Meghalaya High Court. The apex court had earlier refused her request to reconsider her transfer and said that the collegium had made the recommendation in the “interest of better administration of justice.”

Tahilramani served as a judge in Bombay High Court for 17 years and has been its acting chief justice. She is the senior-most among the High Court judges currently holding office. She was transferred to the prestigious 75 judges Madras High Court on August 2018. Her tenure at the Madras High Court has so far been smooth. Thus it becomes even more intriguing to know why she was transferred to three-judge Meghalaya High court.

How Are High Court Judges Transferred?

A judicial transfer is generally made by Presidential orders with the advice of the Chief Justice of India. The CJI can only advise such transfers after the resolution of the collegium. The collegium may also take opinion from the Supreme Court Judge hailing from the concerned High Court from which the judge is being transferred or the chief justice of that High Court.

According to a report in The Print, the collegium headed by CJI Dipak Mishra in January 2018 refused Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal’s claims for appointment as the chief justice of the Himachal Pradesh High Court. The collegium cited a 14-year-old intelligence bureau report and his “poor performance” as a judge to overlook the Punjab and Haryana High Court as reasons to counter his claims.

The members of the same collegium including the current CJI Ranjan Gogoi had cleared Justice Mittal’s name in June 2017 for the appointment as the Chief Justice of Delhi HC. The whole process was kept opaque and no one was informed.

The consultation process has been criticised over the years for becoming erratic. The case of Justice Tahilramani is a classic case where a High Court chief justice is transferred without any public knowledge on why the transfer was made.

Also Read: Clean Chit To CJI Ranjan Gogoi In Sexual Harassment Case; Complainant Says She Is “Dejected And Terrified”


Written by : Shubhendu Deshmukh

Edited by : Shweta Kothari

Related Stories

Supreme Court Woman Judge R Banumathi

Justice Banumathi Appointed As First Woman Judge In SC Collegium After 13 Years

Breaking: Office Of Chief Justice Of India Under RTI, Conditions Applied

In The Name Of Transparency, We Can’t Destroy Judiciary: SC On Bringing Chief Justice Under RTI

ias tukaram mundhe

12th Transfer In 13 Yrs, 4th Transfer Since 2016, Who Is IAS Tukaram Mundhe?

Justice Chelameswar

Know About Justice Chelameswar Who Retired Today After A Seven-Year Tenure In Supreme Court

“Life & Existence Of SC Under Threat”, SC Judge Writes To CJI As Centre Sits On Collegium’s Recommendation

Latest on The Logical Indian


Modi Govt May Cut School Education Budget By ₹3000 Crore Amid Cash Crunch, Likely To Affect Teachers’ Salaries


Citizenship Bill: Former IAS Officer Calls For Civil Disobedience Against Centre

Get Inspired

From Fighting Against Casteism To Ensuring Education For All, These 15-Yr-Old Girls Are Agents Of Change In Rajasthan

Fact Check

Fact Check: Delhi Minister Imran Hussain’s Statement On Cremation Adding To Air Pollution Made Viral Out Of Context


US Federal Commission Seeks Sanctions Against Amit Shah Over Citizenship Amendment Bill


‘Instead Of Building Gigantic Statues, India Should Build More Modern Schools, Universities’: Former RBI Governor Raghuram Rajan


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.