Contradictory Reports In Media, Is Kashmir Really At Peace?

Shubhendu Deshmukh India

August 13th, 2019 / 2:02 PM

Kashmir Peace Media Reports

Muslims of Jammu and Kashmir, unlike other states, are celebrating Eid under a complete lockdown. It has been a week since the Centre abrogated Article 370 which granted special status to the state of Jammu and Kashmir. Since then, the valley has been placed under lockdown. The government did withdraw section 144 on Saturday but was again imposed on Sunday.

All the communication lines are cut. Hardly any news is coming out of the state, but the state is making headlines in every newspaper. As per the government account, the valley is at peace. But not according to some of the reporters and media organisations. 

On August 9 there were media reports of 10,000 people protesting against the Centre’s move. The police even had to use pellet guns to stop them. The New York Times article on August 10 put out a detailed report on the ground situation in the valley with the headline ‘Inside Kashmir, Cut Off From the World: ‘A Living Hell’ of Anger and Fear’

On August 10 the Ministry of Home Affairs denied any protest involving 10000 protestors and said there were protests were scattered and few.

Moreover, the Jammu and Kashmir police on August 11 denied any reports of violence saying there hasn’t been a single bullet fired in the past week.

BBC and Al-jazeera’s videos of people protesting against the lockdown were termed as ‘fabricated’ by the Indian government. The Information and Broadcast ministry even send notices to the two media organisations over the videos.

BBC then put out the statement defending its video and journalism.

Telegraph’s Kashmir reporter Sankarshan Thakur even wrote a dairy on the lockdown.

While the BBC and Al-Jazeera got notices for there videos, Indian news agency Asia News International (ANI) tweeted a photo of Eid prayers from a Mosque in Jammu claiming it to be from Srinagar. AltNews fact check showed how the news agency misled people. Moreover, the photo was even used by a renowned Hindi media without even verifying it.

While the valley continues to be under lockdown, the government is firm on its stand of ‘peace in the valley’.

Also Read: Understanding Kashmir, From Conflict To Becoming An Integral Part Of India


Written by : Shubhendu Deshmukh

Edited by : Shweta Kothari

Related Stories

JNU Student Najeeb Ahmed

Delhi HC Directs Media To Remove News Reports Linking JNU Student Najeeb Ahmed To ISIS

RTI Reveals Contradictory Number Of EVMs Supplied By Companies & Received By Election Commission

Nirav Modi

PNB Scam: Reports Show Rs 3000 Cr Additional Fraud From 17 Other Banks; SBI Reports Exposure Of Rs 1,360 Cr


Journalist Reports Harassment On Social Media After UP Police Ignore Distress Calls; Accused Arrested

News vs Newsance 2017: Unnecessary News Reports That Occupied The Media Space

Rajasthan Ordinance

Rajasthan’s New Ordinance Bans Media From Naming Public Servant In Reports Without Prior Permission

Latest on The Logical Indian


Southern Railways Receives Rs 50 Crore To Clear Dues, To Continue Housekeeping Services


Centre Approves Rs 4,432 Crore Financial Aid To Fani Affected Odisha And Drought Hit States


Organisations Protest Against Transgender Protection Bill For Treating Rape Against Trans-Women As “Petty Crime”


Rape Is When Woman’s ‘Consent’ Is Vitiated By A ‘Misconception Of Fact’ Arising Out Of A Promise To Marry: SC


Southern Railway To Cancel Housekeeping Services In 86 Long-Distance Trains Amid Cash Crunch


‘This Case Has Shocked Court’s Conscience’: Madras HC After Quashing False Case Of Daughter’s Rape By Her Father


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.