SC Orders Doctor To Plant 100 Trees For Attempting To Murder As A Juvenile In 2004

The Logical Indian Crew India

July 15th, 2019 / 4:57 PM

Juvenile Supreme Court Plant Trees

Image Credit: Naturetalkies, Hindustan Times

The Supreme Court directed a 32-year-old doctor who was accused of attempting to murder at the age of 16, to plant 100 trees over the course of next year. The accused was convicted under Section 307.

Dr Solemen S.K, who is practising at Murshidabad in West Bengal, was sentenced to three years’ imprisonment for the crime. The Calcutta High Court later upheld the decision.

However, Solemen knocked the doors of the Supreme Court and reiterated the fact that he had committed the crime when he was a minor in August 2004.

According to the Live Law, Solemen’s special leave petition was dismissed by the Apex Court. However, in the disposed of Special Leave Petition, an under Section 9 (2) of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 was filed seeking a declaration that he was a minor on the date of offence.

After hearing the doctor’s plea, the apex court’s bench headed by Justices Hemant Gupta and L. Nageswara Rao asked the District and Sessions Judge, Berhampore, Murshidabad, West Bengal on February 25, 2019, to cross-check Solemen’s story.

After checking Solemen’s story, the district judge fortified that the doctor indeed attempted to commit murder when he was a minor of 16 years seven months and 28 days. Multiple identity cards and school records proved that Solemen was born in February 1987.

Section 18 of the Juvenile Justice Act states that if a juvenile is found accused, then he would be a child in conflict with the law and he has to referred to the Juvenile Justice Board.

However, considering the present age of the accused (32), the top court said that since the crime was committed in 2004, it is inappropriate to send the accused to the Juvenile Justice Board. Instead, the court came up with a punishment that is better for the environment and will also serve as a community service.

Also Read: This NGO Helps Juvenile Delinquents Get A Fresh Lease On Life


Written by : Debarghya Sil

Edited by : Shraddha Goled

Related Stories

Hyderabad Juvenile Life Sentence

Hyderabad: In A First, Court Sentences 19-Yr-Old To Double Life Imprisonment For Crime Committed As A Juvenile

My Story: From Attempting Suicide And Running Away From Home To Scoring Highest In Class

Grow-Trees Earth Day Plant

In 10 Yrs, This Organisation Has Planted 3.9 Million Trees & Lets You Plant A Tree To Honour Your Dear One

Delhi High Court Child Labour

For Employing A Minor, Delhi HC Directs Couple To Pay 1.5 Lakh Fine & Plant 100 Trees

Bonded Labour Trafficking

Hands Of These Two Men Were Chopped Off For Attempting To Escape From Human Traffickers

Green Challenge Plant Trees

Jungle Man Of India, VVS Laxman, Saina Nehwal & Others Take Challenge To Plant Trees

Latest on The Logical Indian


IIT Madras Student Fathima Latheef Commits Suicide, Blames Professors For Religious Discrimination


1,400 UK Academics Come Out In Support Of Indian Cambridge Scholar Who Was Asked To Leave Country


Bihar: Panchayat Asks 15-Year-Old Girl To Sell Baby Born After Her Rape For Rs 20,000 As ‘Compensation’

Fact Check

Fact Check: No, Ranu Mondal Didn’t Demand Church Land In Ayodhya

Get Inspired

Five Vizag Divers Remove Nearly 5000 Kg Of Plastic Waste From Sea In 13 Days

Get Inspired

These Transgender Cabbies Are Helping Women Reach Home Safe


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.