Another Transfer On Sohrabuddin Case: Judge Who Questioned CBI’s Sincerity Replaced In 3 Weeks

The Logical Indian Crew

February 28th, 2018 / 11:21 AM

Courtesy: Scroll, The Wire | Image Credit: India Today

It has been 12 months since Sohrabuddin Sheikh in Gujarat was killed in an alleged fake encounter, yet the controversy surrounding his death refuse to die. Along with the fake encounter, questions were raised regarding the untimely and mysterious death of Justice Brijgopal Harkishan Loya in 2014. Now, another judge, Justice Revati Mohite-Dere who was hearing the case was replaced on February 24.

This replacement comes three weeks after she started hearing the matter on a daily basis. Justice Mohite-Dere will henceforth take care of matters concerning anticipatory bail applications, while Justice N.W. Sambre will deal with all criminal revision applications in her place, reported The Wire.


Who is Justice Revati Mohite-Dere?

On November 29, 2017, when the special Central Bureau of Investigation court in Mumbai passed the order against media reportage of the Sohrabuddin trial, Justice Mohite-Dere was the one to remove the gag order. She said that the ban on covering any part of the proceeding was contrary to the law.

Last week, she also pointed out how the CBI appeared unprepared to conduct the prosecution in the Sohrabuddin and Kauser-bi abduction and murder case in which several policemen from Gujarat are being tried.

She has also pulled up CBI because of its lack of clarity in presenting the prosecutor’s case and failing to protect witnesses who are turning hostile with time. On February 12, she questioned the sincerity with which CBI was conducting the trial. “What protection are you offering to your witnesses? It is your duty to protect the witnesses, so they can depose fearlessly. You can’t file a charge sheet and not give your witness protection,” she said, as reported by Scroll.

Justice Mohite-Dere had pointed out that the CBI had failed to put all evidence on record including the prima facie evidence against those discharged to assess whether the same warranted that they be discharged from the case. “It is the primary duty of a prosecuting agency to place all evidence on record before the court. However, in this case, despite the court’s repeated queries, the CBI has chosen to argue only on the role of the two officials whose discharge it has challenged,” Mohite-Dere had said, according to The Wire.


Many senior lawyers claim “routine” transfers

Senior lawyers said that the replacement might be “routine” and not unusual. Although, they also said that it is unusual that Justice Revati was done hearing arguments from both the sides in the three weeks.

“Although change of roster in a high court is not unusual, if a judge has heard a case for several days, then that case is normally sent to him and kept as a part-heard matter,” said Public interest lawyer and activist Prashant Bhushan. “Therefore if this particular case is not kept with her that would certainly be unusual and would make the change of roster appear to be malafide, especially in the light of her scathing observations about the CBI’s conduct,” he added, as reported by Scroll.


Previous judges

CBI judge J T Utpat, who was hearing the fake encounter case initially, was transferred in 2014 after he pulled up BJP President Amit Shah for failing to appear before court for the hearing pertaining to the case. He was replaced by Justice Loya.

Justice Loya died of a mysterious “heart attack” that same year. Now, Justice Revati Mohite-Dere, who heard the case for just three weeks, has been replaced too.


Contributors

Written by : Poorbita Bagchi

Edited by : Pooja Chaudhuri

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

ias tukaram mundhe

12th Transfer In 13 Yrs, 4th Transfer Since 2016, Who Is IAS Tukaram Mundhe?

Amit Shah Gained “Politically & Financially” From Sohrabuddin Encounter: CBI Officer’s Court Deposition

CBI CVC

People Accused Of Crimes By CBI Being Appointed As CBI Officers; Complains CBI To Vigilance Commission

Indian Railways Passengers Can Transfer Train Ticket To Another Person, Here’s How

Citing Justice Loya Death, CBI To Oppose PIL Against Amit Shah’s Discharge In Sohrabuddin Encounter Case

Loya

CBI Judge Who Heard Amit Shah’s Trial On Sohrabuddin Fake Encounter Case “Died Suspiciously”, Claims Family

Latest on The Logical Indian

My Story

My Story: “I Invited Our Ola Outstation Driver To Stay With Us In The Hotel, Rather Than His Car”

News

Karnataka: Almost 90 Kids Fall Sick As Dead Lizard Surfaces In Mid-Day Meal

News

Identity Of Sexual Assault Victims, Even If Dead, Can’t Be Revealed, Says SC

Awareness

Businesses In China Are Using Cockroaches To Crunch Kitchen Waste; Know About it

Awareness

The BJP ‘Star Campaigner’ Yogi Failed Juggernaut Modi-Shah Team

Fact Check

Fact Check: PMO Indeed Sent Rs 1,064 Back To Onion Farmer, But Didn’t Ask To Transfer Again Online

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.