At Least 7 Deaths Due To Aadhaar Related Issues In Jharkhand’s PDS, Says Activist Jean Drèze

The Logical Indian Crew Jharkhand

June 25th, 2018 / 6:37 PM

Jharkhand Aadhaar PDS

Representational Image: India Today, Counter View

Much has been said about the relevance and efficiency of Aadhaar in the Public Distribution System (PDS) across the country. However, noted social economist and activist, Jean Drèze said that over the last 10 months, Jharkhand has seen at least 12 cases of alleged starvation deaths. Seven of these deaths are allegedly because of the victims not getting ration due to Aadhaar seeding issues, reported The Telegraph.

Deaths Due To Aadhaar in PDS

While addressing the media, Mr Jean said, “The recent deaths of Savitri Devi in Giridih, Meena Musahar in Chatra and Chintaman Malhar in Ramgarh show the government’s lack of interest to address the issue of alleged hunger deaths in the state.”

He added that most of the victims belonged from the Dalit and tribal population, who have been living in poverty without access to any social security benefits since time immemorial, reported The Telegraph.

Hemant Soren, leader of the opposition party in Jharkhand, took to twitter to express his displeasure with the present government. Not only that, he also posted a consolidated list of all those who allegedly starved to death because of Aadhaar-related issues.

Even though over 96% of the people have expressed displeasure with the Aadhaar-linked direct benefit transfer (DBT) pilot experiment in PDS in Jharkhand’s Nagri block, the state government shows no sign of retrieving the programme.

Under the new pilot project which was rolled out in October 2017, poor households are to receive cash in their bank accounts amounting to Rs 31. By adding a rupee extra, they can buy rice from the ration shop at Rs 32 per kg. Previously, they would directly buy rice at Re 1 per kg.

To check whether the money has been credited to the bank, villagers had to make several trips to the banks which ultimately resulted in confusion.

Source: The Wire

The social audit which was conducted in April showed that an overwhelming majority of the respondents wished to go back to the old system. According to the report, 8,370 ration card holders across 13-gram panchayats were surveyed for the audit and only 16.8% said they received the DBT all six times in the last six months.

Protests Against the PDS

Ever since Aadhaar-based biometric authentication was made necessary (and later revoked) by the centre, Jharkhand’s PDS came under strict scrutiny when in February, thousands of people marched from Nagri block to Ranchi, demanding that PDS delivery return to the old system.

Food activists as well as families have alleged that the deaths have occured due to glitches in the Aadhaar-based PDS in the state.

Last year, reports came out that said in some of Jharkhand’s some of most impoverished villages, people were being denied ration due to Aadhaar linkage issues. The plight of the people of Jharkhand first came out when eleven-year-old Santoshi Kumari from Jharkhand’s Simdega district died of starvation on September 28. She died as she went without food for eight days. Koyli Devi, Santoshi’s mother said that the family’s ration card had been cancelled as it wasn’t linked to their Aadhaar. Thus, they were unable to procure food. Premani Kunwar, another woman became a victim of Aadhaar soon after that.

The Logical Indian Take

Aadhaar is being forced down the throat of the Indian citizens under the shroud of welfare. It was introduced by the government for the protection of the poor and needy, but the most problems are faced by them. Activists and journalists are shocked and appalled that a person’s fundamental right to food is being denied because of a government policy.

A government is responsible for the welfare of the people of the country. What is frightening is that even after cases of deaths were brought in front of the public, such incidents keep on happening.


Written by : Sromona Bhattacharyya

Edited by : Poorbita Bagchi

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Right To Food Campaign

Right To Food Campaign Protests Against Aadhaar Related Starvation Deaths At Jharkhand Bhawan

Jharkhand: Tribal Allegedly Dies Of Starvation; The Government Denies Hunger Deaths

2 Million People Deprived Of Ration Per Month Due To Aadhaar Related Problems: Report

Dalits Denied Ration

Karnataka: For The Last 1.5 Years, 16 Families Denied Ration For Not Linking Aadhaar With Ration Card

5,000 Villagers From 5 Villages Of Madhya Pradesh Have Same Birth Date On Aadhaar; Not Able To Avail Benefits

In One Of The Poorest Regions Of Jharkhand, Thousands Denied Ration In The Name Of Aadhaar

Latest on The Logical Indian


The Institutes Of Eminence And The Jio Institute Furor: The Wrong Debate For India And Its Youth

Get Inspired

Paralysed At 18 To Becoming A Para-athlete At 30; Meet Haryana’s Ekta Bhyan Who Won Gold For India


People Accused Of Crimes By CBI Being Appointed As CBI Officers; Complains CBI To Vigilance Commission

TLI Explains

TLI Explains: Can Aligarh Muslim University Allow Reservation For SC/ST Students?


3.5 Cr Elderly Poor Are Being Given Pension Of Mere Rs 200 For Last 12 Yrs


Chennai: 12-Yr-Old Raped By 22 Men For 7 Months In Apartment Complex; Girl Was Drugged & Filmed


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.