Italian Court Rules Stealing Food Is Not A Crime If You’re Hungry

The Logical Indian

May 5th, 2016

Image Courtesy:

The highest court of Italy on Monday has ruled that if impoverished Italians end up stealing small amount of food to satiate their hunger, then it will not be considered as committing a crime.

The Supreme Court of Cassation made this decision overruling a theft conviction against Roman Ostriakov, after the homeless Ukrainian stole cheese and sausages worth €4.07 ($4.50) from a supermarket in 2011. He was caught by another customer and convicted to theft. For this, he was sentenced to six months in jail in 2015 and was asked to pay a fine of €100.

The court decided that Ostriakov had taken the food “in the face of the immediate and essential need for nourishment” and hence, it was not a crime.

The decision drew a lot of support from the citizens. Massimo Gramellini, an editor at La Stampa newspaper, wrote in an opinion column that the judges were more keen on prevailing right to survival over right to property and such a judgement advocates that no one should at least starve in a civilized country.

Italy was hit by a major financial crises. In 2013, the poverty rate had hit a 16-year high. An estimated 30 per cent of the population was living below the poverty line in 2012. Statistics suggest 615 people are added to the ranks of the poor in Italy every day. Being close to the Mediterranean, it is also in the frontline of Europe’s migrant crisis.

Mr Ostriakov’s case heaps of criticism because for stealing food worth under €5, he went through three rounds in the courts before being thrown out.

The Supreme Court of Cassation ruled that stealing small quantities of food to satisfy a vital need will not constitute a crime.

The Logical Indian appreciates the decision taken by the court and giving an upper hand to right to survival, because such a decision will at least not keep the impoverished starved.

Share your thoughts..

Propelled by


This Women’s Day Spread The Message Of Equality

Related Stories

Rs 9.5 Lakh Fine Imposed On Domino’s For Failing Cheese Test

Malegaon Blast Case: Special NIA Court Drops MCOCA Against Sadhvi Pragya, Lt Col Purohit

Minor Children Stripped & Made To Wear Garland Of Slippers For ‘Stealing’ Food

Jyoti Singh Rape Case

Jyoti Singh Rape Case: Supreme Court Upholds Death Penalty For 4 Of The Rapists

Naval Officer Jail

Hyderabad: Naval Officer Sentenced To Two Years In Prison For Sending Obscene Messages To A Minor Girl Online

Sasikala Convicted

Sasikala Convicted, Taken Into Custody, To Spend 4 Years In Jail

Latest on The Logical Indian


Bhagwant Mann Resigns As AAP Punjab Unit Chief After Arvind Kejriwal’s Apology To Majithia For Calling Him Drug Lord


MoS For Home Kiren Rijiju Informs Lok Sabha That Six Privately-Owned Airports In India Owe Rs 797 Cr To CISF


Jharkhand: 11 ‘Gau Rakshaks’ Who Lynched Alimuddin Last Year, Convicted Of Murder & Conspiracy


Bangalore’s Bannerghatta National Park Threatened By Illegal Quarrying; City Officials Silent


Railways Under-Reported Expenses By Rs 5,025 Cr To Make Pension Bill Look Smaller: CAG

Fact Check

Fake News Claims Narendra Modi Is Second Most Corrupt Prime Minister In The World