Govt Asks Banks To Pay Tax On Free Services Like ATM Transactions; Burden To Fall On Customers
April 27th, 2018 / 12:12 PM
Image Credit: Times Of India
The Directorate General of Goods and Services Tax Intelligence (DGGST) issued show cause notices to the country’s top banks including State Bank of India, ICICI Bank, HDFC Bank, Kotak Mahindra Bank and Axis Bank, demanding them to pay service tax, penalties and interests on the free services provided to their customers.
The tax will be levied on the services provided to minimum balance account holders for the last five years, including the pre-GST era for which the previous service tax cases can be opened. This could amount of thousands of crores of rupees.
Banks offer several free services to account holders who maintain a minimum balance. These services include – ATM transactions, issue of cheque books and debit cards and refund of fuel surcharge and more. Authorities have calculated the total tax liability after considering the charges that banks have recovered from customers who do not maintain a minimum account balance. The DGGST has presumed the recovered amount as the value for such services provided by the banks to their customers. Therefore, the tax is being levied on per account charge of the free services provided to their customers who hold a minimum balance.
An Axis bank spokesperson told The Economic Times, “We are in receipt of the said notice, which we understand, relates to an industry-wide matter. We are, currently, engaged with experts to evaluate the observations made in the SCN” (show cause notice),”
Another official raised concerns that the total tax liability could be about Rs 6,000 crores. However, bankers fear it could be much more than this estimated amount.
The notice has raised much apprehension among bank officials as they cannot collect retrospective tax from their customers. If the tax is upheld, customers would be the worst sufferers as they would have to bear the tax burden going ahead.
The Indian Banks’ Association is planning to lobby the government against this tax notice. “The association has already met once on the issue and has been empowered to take it up with the government,” State Bank of India’s chief financial officer Anshula Kant told The Economic Times, “The notice imputes value to every free service rendered by the bank which is not possible. Besides, they also want to do it retrospectively, which is difficult, to say the least.”
Tax experts opine that this issue requires being dealt with a lot of attention and scrutiny since it will pose a significant impact on the banking sector.
Pratik Jain, indirect tax leader at PricewaterhouseCoopers, said: “Banks provide banking services in all cases, including where customers are required to maintain a minimum balance. To break it into various components and infer it to be a distinct service does not seem to be the intention of the law.”
“If service tax has to be paid for the past period, ultimately the burden would fall on the consumers,” added Jain.
Written by : Disha Thakrar (Guest Author)
Edited by : Pooja Chaudhuri