Gambling Prevalent Since Ancient Times: Legalisation Of Sports Betting Proposed By Law Commission

The Logical Indian India

July 6th, 2018 / 4:26 PM

Gambling

Image Credit: Facebook/Harsha Bhogle

In India, we have strict rules against betting and gambling, mostly on moral and ethical grounds, yet various media reports have repeatedly pointed out the prevalence of this practice clandestinely. Online gambling and betting have also become increasingly difficult to curb. A lot of money is involved in the illegal gambling projects, which has flourished into a parallel economy.

Moreover, as per Indian laws, even when real money is at stake but the ‘game’ involves some measure of ‘skill,’ then it lies outside the ambit of gambling laws. Sports fantasy sites and apps like ‘Dream 11’, which is advertised by Mahendra Singh Dhoni, have become quite popular with the Indian youth.

Hence, in May 2017, the Supreme Court mandated the Law Commission of India to look into the possibility of making gambling legal in India which can generate revenue for the government. The report titled,  “Legal Framework: Gambling And Sports Betting Including In Cricket In India,” was submitted by the Law Commission on July 5, 2018. Several questions need to be addressed in the report:

“Will legalizing betting and gambling help in curbing the illegal activities undertaken by the citizens of our country in this regard? Will licensing such activities help the Government earn substantial revenue and generate employment? How far will legalizing betting and gambling be morally correct in the Indian circumstances?”

The Mudgal Committee report, made by a four-member committee, headed by former High Court judge Mukul Mudgal, found after the case of spot-fixing and betting by three players of a team in IPL, that investigative agencies lack the proper tool to track bookies or wager amount. Hence, they stated that “legalising sports betting would reduce the element of black money and the influence of the underworld besides helping them in detection and focusing their investigation”

The Supreme Court constituted a Committee under the Chairmanship of former Chief Justice, Mr Justice R M Lodha that made four suggestions:

  1. Regulatory watchdogs would see that transactions are strictly monitored or registrations would be susceptible to cancellation.
  2. The Players, Administrators and others closely associated with the sport would furnish their income to make the process more transparent.
  3. After proper verification of age and identification licenses will be issued.
  4. Strict penal sanctions would be imposed on those violating the license and the rules.

The report also suggested that players like Sachin Tendulkar, Anil Kumble, Rahul Dravid, who have impeachable records should also spread awareness among young cricketers and educate them about the consequences.


People’s opinion on the legalisation of gambling

Respected commentator Harsha Bhogle humbly asked people on Twitter to share their views on betting in sports. He said, “Never been a betting person but the traditional view is that legalising betting will tempt the poor into frittering away their savings. The other side is that it will let them bet as part of an organised system rather than through undesirable elements. Happy to hear studied views.”



Many people reacted by saying that legalising gambling would financially destroy poor families. They said that the legalisation would ultimately get the middle class and poor people legally addicted to the evils of betting. Former Indian cricketer Snehal Pradhan said that even with awareness programmes in rural India, legalisation of gambling would mean that poor families would have an easy and accessible vice.


Many came out in favour of legalisation.



Gambling in India

Despite gambling being prevalent since ancient times in India, it is heavily looked down upon as a vice that the rich do for entertainment and the poor risk in the hope of earning a quick buck. It is addictive and risky. The report mentions “References of these activities are found in both the epics, Ramayana and Mahabharata. Yudhishtir, the eldest son of Pandu had a penchant for gambling. One of the most gripping scenes in the Mahabharata shows him losing not only his whole kingdom but also his brothers and wife in the ‘Game of Dice’.” In Katyayana Smriti, it is mentioned that if gambling cannot be stopped then it should be regulated.

With the evolution of time and easy access to internet betting sites, regulating gambling has become a challenge. A five-judge bench Supreme Court observed that

“Considering the fact that gambling is evil and it is rampant, that gaming houses flourish as a profitable business and that detection of gambling is extremely difficult, the law to root out gambling cannot but be in the public interest. Such a law must of necessity provide for a special procedure but so long as it is not arbitrary and contains adequate safeguards it cannot be successfully assailed.”

It remains to be seen whether the government would pay heed to the Law Commission report.


Also Read: Australian Media Shames Their Cricket Team After Ball-Tampering Incident, Others Call For Harsher Punishment


Contributors

Edited by : Abhinav Joshi

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Gambling

Gambling Prevalent Since Ancient Times: Legalisation Of Sports Betting Proposed By Law Commission

Fortis Hospital Billed Scheduled Drug At 4.4 Times And Consumable At More Than 18 Times The Procurement Price

BHU Incident Is A Reminder Of The Misogyny & Casual Sexism Prevalent In Colleges Across India

This Teacher’s day, Let’s Give Wings To The National Sports Corps Who Are Training Grassroot Sports Champions

An Open Letter To Our Sports Fraternity: Make Sports Compulsory In Schools

Kashmir- Can sports be a stress buster in times of conflict?

Latest on The Logical Indian

Exclusive

“Fell At Officials Feet, Even Then They Razed Our Farms,” Jharkhand Farmers Claim Land Taken Forcefully For Adani’s Powerplant

Fact Check

Fact Check: Is Sikkim’s First Airport The 100th Airport Of India As Claimed By PM Modi?

News

Arrested For 22 Year Old Case, Sanjiv Bhatt’s Wife Says, ”He Is Being Punished For Criticising PM Modi”

Opinion

Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman’s Irresponsible Statements

News

Stranded At Sea, Commander Abhilash Tomy Rescued After 72 Hours Of Multinational Effort

News

Irregularities Worth Rs 97,000 Crore Found Under Samajwadi Party’s Rule In UP: CAG Report

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.