Former CMs Not Entitled To Occupy Government Bungalows: SC

The Logical Indian Crew

May 7th, 2018

Image Credit: India.com

On May 7, the Supreme Court revoked the law by the Uttar Pradesh government which allowed former chief ministers to permanently reside in government bungalows. As per ANI, SC while quashing the UP government’s law, said that section 4(3) of UP Ministers (salaries, allowances and miscellaneous provisions) Act, 2016 is unconstitutional.



The SC called this legislation “arbitrary, discriminatory and unsupported by the Constitution.”

This move by the apex court comes after an NGO named “Lok Prahari” had moved the top court challenging the validity of the Ex-Chief Ministers Residence Allotment Rules, 1997. The NGO argued that as per SC’s ruling, allotment of government bungalows to former CMs was bad in law. It further said that these rules circumvent the SC order.

As per the August 2016 ruling of the apex court, it had ruled that former CMs were not entitled to have any government accommodation. However, in Uttar Pradesh, the then Samajwadi Party government brought in a bill in the same month which permitted former chief ministers to permanently occupy government bungalows.

At the time, those affected by the SC order were Union home minister and BJP leader Rajnath Singh, Rajasthan governor Kalyan Singh, Samajwadi Party chief Mulayam Singh Yadav, BSP supremo Mayawati and Congress leaders N D Tiwari and Ram Naresh Yadav.

On April 3, 2017, too, the SC had held that government quarters and bungalows offered to former chief ministers of the state was unconstitutional and further directed the concerned persons to vacate the bungalows and hand it over to the government. The court also asked the state government to recover appropriate rent from occupants of the said bungalows.

In Monday’s ruling, the bench of SC justices Ranjan Gogoi and R Banumathi which was passing judgement on a PIL by NGO Lok Prahari observed that “such laws create a separate class. Once a public servant demits office there should be nothing to distinguish them from a common man”.

The bench further said, “We had set out few questions for determination. Whether retention of official accommodation by such former public servants after they demit office is violative of the Constitution.”

It added, “We have extensively relied on the preamble of the Constitution which embodies the principle of equality and recognizes only a single class of citizens. In a democratic republic government, public servants must act in a manner that ultimate authority is vested in its citizen.”

In January, the Supreme Court said it would hear law officers of the central government before considering the plea of amicus curiae Gopal Subramaniam who asked for the rule banning chief ministers to occupy government bungalows once they demit office to be extended to former Prime Ministers and Presidents too. In his plea, Subramaniam said, “While the present matter relates to an attempt by the State of Uttar Pradesh to overcome the judgment in Lok Prahari v. State of UP which quashed the allotment of Government bungalows to former Chief Ministers. The matter raises a substantial question of law: Whether the equality clause contained in Article 14 of the Constitution of India enables public houses to be retained by persons even after they demit office?”


The Logical Indian take

The Logical Indian wholeheartedly supports the apex court’s judgement. It is discriminatory that a person is given preferential treatment over other. It is imperative for proper functioning of a democracy to view every citizen as equal. While rendering minimal post-retirement benefits like pension is understandable, however, alloting government bungalow permanently is not required.

Share your thoughts..

Propelled by

VOLVO

Make Your City Safe

Related Stories

Student Urges NDMC To Initiate Proceedings Against Former Chief Secretary Of Govt Of NCT For Illegally Occupying Govt Bungalow

Rajasthan Govt Increases Salaries

Rajasthan Govt Increases Salaries & Allowances For All MLAs & Ministers, Know About It

Red Beacons

Welcome Move: Government To Remove Red Beacons From Cars Of All Ministers

Red Beacon

Punjab Govt. Does U-Turn On VIP Culture: Red Beacon To Chief Minister & The Ministers

National Anthem

No Need To Stand Up When National Anthem Is Played As A Part Of A Film: Supreme Court

Supreme Court: Strong Criticism Against The Government Is Not Defamatory Or Seditious

Latest on The Logical Indian

News

Ministry of I&B To Set Up Social Media Monitors in 716 Indian Districts

News

CBI Grills Sify Technologies Staff in SSC Paper Leak Case

Get Inspired

Residents Contribute Money To Make Road On Their Own In Village Due To Administration Apathy

News

No Salary For Last Five Months, Bengaluru Sanitary Workers Struggle To Survive

Environment

The Water Crisis In Punjab: Illegal Industrial Discharge Destroying Rivers, Threatening Human Lives

News

Caught On Camera Asking Money To Peddle Hindutva; Cobrapost Exposes The Newspapers You Read