Adani Group Issues Defamation Notice To EPW Journal For Story On Rs 500 Crore Favors From Govt

Sudhanva Shetty

July 12th, 2017

Image credits: quintype, facebook

Academic journal Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) has been served a defamation notice by the Adani Group. The notice was served over a story EPW ran on how the government altered rules for special economic zones (SEZs), which led to the Adani Group reaping a profit of Rs 500 crore.

The EPW article was titled “Modi Government’s ₹500 Crore Bonanza to Adani Group Company”. It claimed: “By frequently changing the rules relating to power projects located in special economic zones, the department of commerce in the ministry of industry and commerce has allowed Adani Power claims for refunds of customs duties to the tune of ₹500 crore. Curiously, the duties were never paid.”

The story was run by EPW in Vol. 52, Issue No. 24, 17 Jun, 2017.

In response to the article, EPW received a legal notice from a lawyer representing Adani Power, which is headed by Gautam Adani. The legal notice accused EPW and the writers of the article of defamation and threatened legal action unless the piece was retracted, an unconditional apology was issued, and any defamatory material on Adani not be published by the magazine “in any manner whatsoever”.

EPW, however, refused to budge and in his reply to Adani Power’s lawyer, EPW’s advocate reaffirmed that each and every word in the article was truthful and backed by documentary evidence.


The EPW story can be read here.
Adani Power’s legal notice can be read here.
EPW’s reply to the legal notice can be read here.


The debate over defamation laws

Speaking to The Logical Indian, EPW Editor Paranjoy Guha Thakurta – and one of the four authors of the aforementioned article – said this was not the first time he had received a legal notice.

“I have been a journalist now for 40 years,” he said. “I have received legal notices alleging defamation from a number lawyers representing many organisations. These include companies headed by Shri Subrata Roy, Shri Anil Ambani, Shri Mukesh Ambani, the Times group – and now Gautam Adani of the Adani Group. There are many other personalities whose lawyers have sent me legal notices. But none of these individuals have taken me to court – yet. Even in the current case, the lawyers have not gone to court. As of 5 pm, 11 July 2017, the Adani Group’s lawyers have not gone to court.”

Section 499 and Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code make defamation a criminal offence under law. How should journalists ensure that their independence is not compromised in such a climate?

Mr Guha Thakurta replied, “I have been co-author of a book, Sue the Messenger; the subtitle of the book is “How legal harassment by corporates shackles reportage and undermines democracy in India.” It was published in May 2016 and it documents over a dozen instances where large corporates in India have sought to muzzle and stifle dissenting voices, whether from writers, journalists, social activists etc. You will find that there are a large number of such cases. There is also a case that goes back to the 1950s in the book.”

A recent judgement by the Supreme Court, from a bench headed by Dipak Mishra, upheld the law on defamation, saying the freedom of speech and right to expression are fundamental rights, but these rights are not absolute.

“In my opinion,” Mr Guha Thakurta said, “I disagree with the judgement of the Honourable Supreme Court. In my opinion, the judgement seeks to give the right to his reputation as much importance as the right to free speech, which is a fundamental right enshrined in Article 19(1A) of the Indian Constitution. And then there is Article 19(2), which allows for “reasonable restrictions” on free speech. The problem is who decides what is “reasonable” and what is not. In India, the way Article 19(2) has been interpreted has often been very contentious.”

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

With 11 Journalists Killed In 2017, India Goes Further Down On International Press Freedom Ranking

Adani Loses Defamation Case Against The Wire & Economic And Political Weekly

Failing To Get Loan, Adani To Handle Carmichael Mine In Australia By Itself

As Per Report, Adani Group Uses Tax Havens In The Caribbean To Minimise Tax Payments On Australian Projects

Adani Group

India’s Customs Intelligence Agency Accuses Adani Group Of Laundering Rs 1500 Crore To Offshore Accounts

Journalists Don’t Enjoy Special Privilege, Rights Of Press Not More Than Rights Of Common Man: Delhi Court

Latest on The Logical Indian

News

How Jatin Mehta Of Winsome Diamonds Pulled Off A Rs 7000 Cr Scam & Is Living Peacefully In Caribbean Islands

News

Kerala HC Rules Against Controversial ‘Chooral Muriyal’ Ritual

News

A Much Needed Step: 4 Fathers Jailed By Hyderabad Police For Allowing Their Kids To Drive

News

Bhopal: SSC CHSL Examination Cancelled Over Alleged Paper Leak

Legal

After 7 Years, Delhi High Court Removes Gag Order From The Caravan’s Cover Story On IIPM’s Arindam Chaudhuri

Health

Tobacco Increases The Risk Of Cancer No Matter How It Is Used: Study