Doctors In USA Tweet Heart-Wrenching Incidents As A Response To Gun Advocates

The Logical Indian Crew

November 13th, 2018 / 4:36 PM

Doctors Hit Back NRA

Image Credit: Dr Dave Morris/ Twitter 

While the locations, faces and the numbers change, the weapon remains the same – a gun. With the recent mass shooting at a South California bar which left 12 dead, the debate over gun control has once again come to the fore.

Mass shootings in USA

While mass shootings have become the norm in the United States Of America, the number of victims in absolute terms is harrowing. While little study has been done to quantify the overall damages of mass-shootings in the US, CNN, by using their own criteria for listing such shootings has found out that there have been 288 school shootings in the USA since 2009 where at least one person was killed. This number is 57 times higher than six other G7 countries in the world, combined. Even as mass shootings in the US get deadlier, the number of victims still represent a small fraction of those who are killed as a result of firearm assault as BBC reported that in 2016 alone, a staggering 11,000 people have died as a result of manslaughter involving a firearm.

More conventionally, mass shootings since 2013 have been defined as cases of attacks involving three or more victims. Going by this, the number of mass shootings may appear fewer, however, the problem – threat involving firearms – continue to persist unabated.

While gun control activists and politicians have been advocating stricter gun laws for the country, at the federal level, the situation is dismal. Meanwhile, the NRA (National Rifle Association of America), an organisation which works for gun rights has been challenging the gun control activists on various grounds, mainly on its advocacy of the 2nd Amendment which is enshrined in the constitution. It says, “a well-regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed”.

NRA, which has been vilified for its staunch lobbying of gun rights has once again come under the radar for a controversial tweet which prompted doctors and trauma surgeons in the USA to tweet with #ThisIsOurLane.

NRA tweets and doctors respond

Just a day before the mass shooting at a Thousand Oaks bar in southern California, USA’s powerful pro-gun organisation, NRA tweeted an editorial saying, “Someone should tell self-important anti-gun doctors to stay in their lane. Half of the articles in Annals of Internal Medicine are pushing for gun control. Most upsetting, however, the medical community seems to have consulted NO ONE but themselves.”

“Everyone has hobbies. Some doctors’ collective hobby is opining on firearms policy,” reads the first sentence of the editorial which suggests that anti-gun rights doctors should not debate on gun rights. This tweet caught the attention of many doctors who deal with the horrors of gun-violence, first hand on a routine basis. Doctors’ response to NRA’s tweet was prompt and personal.

With heart-wrenching stories, doctors also posted pictures of blood splattered clothes and trauma centres.

Doctor Morris told BBC, “We are anti-violence. Violence is the real problem; guns are simply a vector. What we hope for is the opportunity to study the problem and apply the sound scientific methodology to making things better.”

There were hundreds of other tweets which showed how real the threat and the subsequent trauma is. The USA is the world’s topmost gun-owning country and only next to it is Yemen, a nation which is torn by civil wars.

NRA, most powerful

Reportedly, US public opinion on banning handguns has changed drastically over the last half a century and now, a significant majority opposes banning handguns. What facilitates such a change is NRA’s lobbying. According to a BBC article, the NRA spends about $3 million (Rs 21,77,85,000) per year to influence gun policy in the country.

Their armour is most primarily the abovementioned 2nd Amendment and the NRA argues against all forms of gun controls and advocates that guns make the country safer. It also supports legislation that expands gun rights such as “open-carry” laws. What further makes the NRA so powerful is its political affiliations and the bigwigs who are members of it.

Politicians also have a big role to play in the situation, along with lawmakers. Present US President Donald Trump’s views on gun laws have changed over the years. Reportedly, while in the 1990s and early 2000s, Trump expressed support for a ban on assault weapons, his views have since changed. After securing the endorsement of NRA in May 2016, right before the US elections that year, Trump’s opinions seem to echo those of NRA’s, reports BBC. On several occasions too, Trump has taken a jibe at then Presidential candidate Hillary Clinton and her views on staunch gun control.

The Logical Indian Take

Gun advocates in the USA base their arguments on an amendment which was formulated in 1791. While the grounds for the enactment is itself disputed till date, it made up for a valid argument back in the day when the citizens of the newly independent country had to protect themselves against British imperialist forces. However, in the modern world, countless innocent lives have been lost over the years because of the existence of the law which gives US citizens the right to own firearms. 

Much like the legalisation of marijuana, different US states have enacted different laws which either empowers pro-guns groups or limit its use. However, changes are yet to be made on a federal level. The onus now lies upon the Congress (US’s legislative branch) to enact laws that restrict usage of firearms and stop such killings on a mass level. Heartfelt prayers can only do so much, it’s time people realise the drastic consequences of their decisions.

Also Read: [Read/Watch] Barack Obama’s New Proposals To End Gun Violence Display Both Courage & Recklessness


Written by : Sromona Bhattacharyya

Edited by :

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Ashish Pandey

Delhi Police On Lookout For Ex-BSP MP’s Son Who Waved A Gun Outside Posh Hotel

Forensic Reports Suggest That Same Gun Was Used To Kill Gauri Lankesh And Kalburgi

India Today

India Today Terminates Journalist For Refusing To Remove Tweet On ‘Fake News’

Gujarat: ‘Bal’ Doctors To Be Appointed From Primary Schools To Tackle Shortage Of Doctors

“Is There No Difference Between Doctors & Goons?” Corruption In NEET Creating Fake Doctors

celebratory gun firing

Haryana Bans Carrying Firearms And Celebratory Gun Firing At Weddings

Latest on The Logical Indian


Govt Overlooks Major Concerns While Proposing New Groundwater Rules


Karnataka: Cabinet Gives Nod To Amend RTE Act; To Give First Preference To Govt Schools


Meet Meerut’s Club 60, A Group Of Senior Citizens Working Towards A Greener Environment

Get Inspired

Going Forward: After Two Trains Ran Over His Legs, This Man Found A Passion For Dancing

Fact Check

Fact Check: From Pakistan’s Flag Waved In Rajasthan To Rahul Gandhi’s U-Turn On Loan Waiver


Central Govt Spent Rs 5,245 Cr On Ads Since 2014 Says Union Minister Rajyavardhan Rathore


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.