Did Demonetisation Fail To Fulfil Its Purpose? Certainly Not, Says Arun Jaitley

The Logical Indian Crew India

August 31st, 2018 / 6:35 PM

Arun Jaitley Demonetization

Image (Representational) Credits: Hindustan Times, Indian Express

Recently, an RBI report said that 99.3% of the demonetised notes have been returned. After this, finance minister Arun Jaitley claimed that PM Modi’s widely debated demonetization move has resulted in stronger economic growth and higher tax revenue. In his reply to the opposition’s claims that demonetization gravely failed in its objectives, He said in a Facebook post that the purpose of demonetisation was not defeated as it was done to make India more tax compliant.


Was the invalidation of the Non-deposited currency the only object of demonetisation? Certainly Not. The larger purpose…

Posted by Arun Jaitley on Thursday, August 30, 2018


In a Facebook note “Demonetisation and its impact on Tax collection and Formalisation of the Economy”, Jaitley explained that the invalidation of the undeposited currency was not the only objective of the move, but rather the bigger purpose of note ban was to change India from a Non-tax compliant society to a tax compliant society. In his post-Jaitley goes on pointing out factors that support his argument.


Posted by Arun Jaitley on Thursday, August 30, 2018

 

FM Arun Jaitley asserts that income tax collection two years before demonetisation was 6.6% and 9%, and two years post-Demonetisation it has increased to 15% and 18%. He stated that income tax collection from 2013-14 was 6.38 Lakh crores and after Demonetisation in 2017-18 it had increased to 10.02 Lakh crores. He maintains that in the past years since Demonetisation, the number of new returns filed has increased by 85.51 Lakhs and 1.07 crores. He also said that in the past two years, there has been a phenomenal increase in the Income-tax returns by 19% and 25%. He also goes on to explain how close to a million people have been slammed with tax and penalties after they deposited their money in the bank as part of demonetisation. “More formalisation of the Economy, More Money in the System, Higher Tax Revenue, Higher Expenditure, Higher Growth after the first two quarters,” is what resulted from demonetisation, Arun Jaitley claimed.

Earlier, during the release of Reserve Bank of India’s Annual Report for 2016-17, Arun Jaitley had told reporters that the objective of demonetisation was not confiscation of money. “The object of demonetisation was that India is predominantly a high-cash economy and, therefore, that scenario requires to be significantly altered,” he added.


What PM Modi Said? 

In his 2017 Independence Day speech, Narendra Modi was all praise about the benefits of his note ban. He claimed that because of his move, Rs 1.75 lakh crore that was deposited in banks and over 1.8 million people with disproportionate assets are under government watch, also claiming that the crackdown of black money will continue. “More than Rs 2 lakh crore black money has reached banks, and now people depositing such money are being made to answer questions on their origin,” he said.

He added that the registration of 175,000 companies out of 300,000 shell companies identified during the demonetisation process had been cancelled. He also claimed that they were able to confisticate around Rs. 800 crores worth of  ‘Benami’ property. Last year, on the eve of completing one year of Demonetization, PM Modi tweeted with #AntiBlackMoneyDay calling a victory on black money.



On the same day of the announcement of demonetization, BJP President, Amit Shah had also lauded the move made by Prime Minister Modi as an attack on black money.



Background

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on November 8, 2016, brought India to a standstill when he announced on the national news that from midnight onwards Rs.500 and RS.1000 notes will be banned. His made tall claims, stating that the motive was to clear the black money menace in I down economy, force its citizens to pay taxes for every unaccounted cash, fight terrorism funding and make India a cashless economy by promoting digital India initiatives.


What India achieved from demonetization

The Modi government was able to establish some of its objectives while they failed terribly some other areas. According to The Economic Times, the demonetization was able to curb terrorism by obstruction of terror funding. It was also successful in making Indians accountable for the money laying around their homes and depositing it in bank accounts. This has led to a record 80% increase in the number of income taxpayers, as 9.1 million new taxpayers were added. The demonetization has also arguably pushed India forward to the digital age by making cashless online transactions popular.


Aftermath

It is debatable if the demonetization has succeeded in curbing the black money flow in the Indian economy as around 99% of the money was reportedly deposited back to RBI. As several financial experts have said time and again, those involved in the black money business, less than 6% illicit wealth in India is held in the form of cold cash. Within a year of demonetisation, GDP has fallen by 5.7%, and the world bank had reduced the India GDP growth forecast to 7% for 2017-18 solely based on demonetization and GST. Medium, Small and Micro Enterprises (MSME) is another area that demonetization had a lasting effect on. MSME owners were never a part of the black money market, and because of that, they were badly affected by the ban. Many had to give up and return to their villages that the growth rate of these companies went down to a mere 1%.


Deaths due to Demonetization:

Media reports have shown that 66 people including 11 bank employees had died directly or indirectly due to demonetization. Causes of death ranged from heart attacks from shocks of the news, suicide, exhaustion from standing in bank ques, deaths when hospitals refused to accept banned currency notes and many more.


The Logical Indian take

The question remains, was it worth it? Was it worth the troubles the common man faced immediately following note ban, to catch just .7% of the illegal wealth? Was it worth the death of so many people to crackdown counterfeit notes which is estimated to be fewer than 0.02% of all currency notes? Was it indispensable?


Also Read: 99.3% Of Demonetised Currency Back In System: RBI Report

Also Read

99.3% Of Demonetised Currency Back In System: RBI Report


Contributors

Written by : Bindiya (Intern)

Edited by : Abhinav Joshi

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Arun Jaitley Demonetisation

Hits And Misses Of Arun Jaitley’s Facebook Post On Demonetisation’s 2nd Anniversary

Arun Jaitley Demonetization

Did Demonetisation Fail To Fulfil Its Purpose? Certainly Not, Says Arun Jaitley

AAP

IAS Officers Refuse To Listen To Orders From AAP, Arun Jaitley Says Centre Is Above Both LG & Delhi Govt

After Apology, Delhi High Court Acquits Arvind Kejriwal And Others In Arun Jaitley Defamation Case

Aadhaar-Linked Accounts Of 5 Customers Breached, Over Rs 5 Lakh Swindled Off: Arun Jaitley In Lok Sabha

We Put Manmohan Singh At Highest Regard, Says Arun Jaitley On PM Modi’s Remark

Latest on The Logical Indian

Awareness

Made In India Stents Just As Good As Their International Counterparts, Study From Germany Shows

Exclusive

This Website Needs Your Personal Details For NaMo T-Shirts. Here’s Why It’s Worrisome

News

Monkey Menace: Two People Killed In Agra On Same Day; Monkey Population Reaches 50,000

Exclusive

My Story: “I Saw A Kid Staring At The Ferris Wheel, He Didn’t Have Money Or Courage To Go Up”

News

On Family’s Request Kathua Victim’s Lawyer Removed From Case Over “Non-Appearance” In The Case

Awareness

Low IQ Among Indian Children, Is Iodine Deficiency The Secret Reason?

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.