Maharashtra: CBI Probe Turns Attempted Murder To Suicide; Asked To Pay Rs 15 L Compensation

The Logical Indian Crew

March 12th, 2018

Courtesy: Times Of India, Newsbytesapp | Image Credit: Amarujala

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has been directed by the Maharashtra State Human Rights Commission (MSHRC) to pay Rs 15 lakh to the father of an MBA student for seven years delay in the delivery of justice owing to the “shoddy” probe into the student’s mysterious death.

The careless investigation carried out by the CBI as noted by the magistrate court had put up serious questions on the credibility of the investigators.


Case history

Santosh was found dead under mysterious conditions on July 15, 2011, in the balcony of a first floor flat. Santosh stayed with three others – Vikas Kumar, Jitendra Kumar and Dheeraj Kumar on the fourth floor of Janardan Sadan building.

On the basis of Jitendra’s statement where he said that Santosh had committed suicide by jumping from the toilet window under the influence of alcohol, the Kharghar Police Station registered an accidental death report.

Not satisfied with the investigation by the local police, Santosh’s father, Vijay Singh, a resident of Patna, filed a petition in the High Court. Based on the writ petition, High Court ordered a CID probe. However, Vijay was not satisfied with the progress, so he approached the court again 2013, after which a CBI probe was initiated. The CBI probed the murder case and concluded it to be a suicide and filed a closure report in the magistrate court at Panvel.

Rejecting the closure report in his December 2017 order, Magistrate J M Chavan said that chemical analysis report did not say that Santosh was under the influence of alcohol. He said, ”It is impossible for the deceased to climb atop the flush tank under the influence of alcohol and remove the window panes.

The magistrate also noted other discrepancies based on the medical report, including time of death. The court said, “Material showed that the investigation was not proper, and it was done in a manner to save the accused.”

The court also noted that the deceased had multiple injuries caused due to a sharp object, because of which he died. It was also observed that evidence showed that the accused threw Santosh’s body down after killing him, to make it appear like a suicide. The magistrate slammed CBI for declaring it a case of suicide even though pieces of evidence indicated it was a murder. The order said, ”It was unnatural death, but still even the medical officer had not preserved viscera for analysis.

All the three accused are at present in judicial custody. Additionally, the court charged the CBI for trying to save the accused. The court said, ”Material showed that the investigation was not proper, and it was done in a manner to save the accused.”


MSHRC asks CBI to pay compensation to the father

MSHRC has asked the compensation to be paid within six weeks, for violation of fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution. Disciplinary actions have been initiated against the officers who were found to be at fault.

MSHRC member M A Sayeed, asked the CBI to sensitise officers about the importance of a proper investigation which should be in accordance with the rules and procedures.

Share your thoughts..

Art Has The Power To Transform Lives

Related Stories

Kathua: Medical Report Confirms 8-Yr-Old Was Raped & Uterus Mutilated, Chargesheet Filed Amid Lawyers’ Protest

SC Reserves Verdict On Plea Seeking Independent Investigation In Justice Loya’s Death

Citing Justice Loya Death, CBI To Oppose PIL Against Amit Shah’s Discharge In Sohrabuddin Encounter Case

Hadiya

We Cannot Question The Legitimacy Of An Adult Woman’s Choice Of Marriage: SC On Hadiya Case

CJAR

Medical Colleges Admission Scam: CJAR To Challenge SC Order On No Investigation Of Sitting Judges In India

Gulberg Riots

Gujarat HC Upholds Clean Chit To PM Modi And Others In Gulberg Riots Case

Latest on The Logical Indian

Opinion

BJP’s Reaction To Three Different Rapes: Protest March Against One, Support To Rapists In Other Two

Fact Check

Fact Check: Image Shared By ShankhNaad Of Woman Being Beaten In Kerala By Muslims Is Fake

News

Govt Asks Banks To Pay Tax On Free Services Like ATM Transactions; Burden To Fall On Customers

News

Govt Accepts Supreme Court Never Made Linking Aadhaar to Mobile Compulsory

News

India Slips Two Places, Ranks Just One Place Above Pakistan In 2018 World Press Freedom Index

News

From Death Threats To Stopping Daughter’s Education: The Struggle Of Top Cop Who Led Asaram’s Arrest & Conviction