Bloomsbury India Withdraws Publication Of Book On Delhi Riots After Receiving Backlash Over Launch
Writer: Devyani Madaik
A media enthusiast, Devyani believes in learning on the job and there is nothing off limits when it comes to work. Writing is her passion and she is always ready for a debate as well.
India, 23 Aug 2020 9:15 AM GMT | Updated 23 Aug 2020 12:35 PM GMTcheck update history
Editor : Shubhendu Deshmukh |
Shubhendu, the quint essential news junky, the man who loves science and politics in equal measure and offers the complete contrast to it by being a fan of urdu poetry as well.
Creatives : Abhishek M
" An engineer by profession, Abhishek is the creative producer of the team, graphic designing is his passion and travelling his get away. In more ways than one, he makes the content visually appealing."
Leading publisher Bloomsbury India on Saturday said it has withdrawn the publication of the book on Delhi riots that broke out in February this year.
Leading publisher Bloomsbury India on Saturday said it has withdrawn the publication of the book on Delhi riots after receiving flak on social media.
The virtual launch of the book included BJP leader Kapil Mishra, who had been earlier accused of delivering inflammatory speeches and instigating hate against other religions and minority communities, along with Bhupendra Yadav, filmmaker Vivek Agnihotri and Nupur Sharma.
Mishra took to twitter announcing the launch.
The Book is Public Now— Kapil Mishra (@KapilMishra_IND) August 22, 2020
India and the world will read it and know the Truth of Anti Hindu Delhi Riots
No Hate Campaign and Propaganda Machinery Can STOP the Truth to come out#DelhiRiotsUntoldStories pic.twitter.com/QkHlRtcHPf
Soon after the news about the launch of the book broke, individuals including authors, actors, intellectuals, journalists and others condemned the publishing house for its publishing, questioning the company's credibility by approving the book that clearly targets minorities and freedom of speech and is far apart from delivering facts.
I'm now ashamed at having contributed to a chapter in a @BloomsburyIndia book. When the history of our times is written, the role of publishers who colluded and published falsehoods to serve current powers will also be noted. Shame on you. You're no longer a credible publisher. https://t.co/NIFrlWKplS— Jayati Ghosh (@Jayati1609) August 22, 2020
(Thread)@BloomsburyIndia is releasing a book on the Delhi Riots 2020 --- and guess who the Guest of Honours are:— meena kandasamy || இளவேனில் (@meenakandasamy) August 21, 2020
KAPIL MISHRA, the hate-monger and brain-child of goli maaron saalon ko (shoot the bastards) slogan, who explicitly called for violence against Muslims and Dalits. pic.twitter.com/bC2HoFlmSg
The willingness of Bloomsbury to publish that book is more of a comment on us than it is a comment on them.— Omair Ahmad (@OmairTAhmad) August 21, 2020
They think this will sell in India.
They would never show this level of contempt in a working democracy.
This is what the world thinks of us.
Protesting @BloomsburyIndia's decision to publish a book on Delhi riots the launch of which would be attended by riots-accursed Kapil Mishra and the fakenews factory Opindia's Nupur Sharma tomorrow. It's a shame.— Stanly Johny (@johnstanly) August 21, 2020
--A Bloomsbury India author.
The publishing company later said the event was organised without their knowledge and has now decided to cancel the release of the book titled 'Delhi Riots 2020 - The Untold Story'.
"Bloomsbury India had planned to release Delhi Riots 2020: The Untold Story in September, a book purportedly giving a factual report on the riots in Delhi in February 2020, based on investigations and interviews conducted by the authors," the company's statement as quoted by NDTV.
"However, in view of very recent events including a virtual pre-publication launch organised without our knowledge by the authors, with participation by parties of whom the Publishers would not have approved, we have decided to withdraw publication of the book," it added.
The company said it strongly supports freedom of speech but also has a deep sense of responsibility towards society.
The book is authored by Delhi University teachers Sonali Chitalkar and Prerna Malhotra, and advocate Monika Arora. It says that the riots were orchestrated by 'jihadis' and 'urban Naxals', that had links with the Islamic State, and involved 'professional sharpshooters'. It also states that Muslim mobs were the instigators for the anti-CAA protests at Jamia and Shaheen Bagh that led to the riots.
The book claims the involvement of PFI (People's Front of India) or ISIS of providing the list of names of individuals to be targeted by the mob and snipers, especially against security forces, police, intelligence agencies or persons belonging to Hindu organisations.
The book claims the Muslim mob to have made the first attack and target key areas like Northeast Delhi like Shiv Vihar. In response to the publishing house's decision and public flak, Mishra said it was nothing but a campaign against writers.
Earlier at the launch, Mishra had said, the self-proclaimed torchbearers of freedom of speech are afraid of the book.
एक किताब से डर गए अभिव्यक्ति की आज़ादी के फर्जी ठेकेदार , ये किताब छ्प ना जाएं, ये किताब कोई पढ़ ना लें— Kapil Mishra (@KapilMishra_IND) August 22, 2020
तुम्हारा ये डर इस किताब की जीत हैं
तुम्हारा ये डर हमारी सच्चाई की जीत हैं
My Statement During Book Launch
Bhupender Yadav, in his speech at the virtual launch, discussed the anti-CAA protests, stating that it clearly shows people's belief in the very Constitution. "The people of Shaheen Bagh who protested, we have no problem with that, people can stage dharnas anywhere. But tell me one speech in which they said the rights of minorities in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan should be safeguarded," Yadav said.
He further urged the government to initiate an investigation to unearth the involvement of foreign funding for the protests, possible networks of people who instigated the protests.
One of the authors, Sonali Chitalkar told The Sunday Express that they haven't received any official message from Bloomsbury regarding the withdrawal of the publication of their book. On the contrary, she also claims that Bloomsbury knew about the launch.
"The publishers should have spoken to us first. Without even reading, a lobby has pressured the publishers to withdraw a book… We have spoken to both the communities, their people and leaders," the media quoted Chitalkar as saying.
Speaking to the media, co-author Prerna Malhotra said it was a 'sorry state of affairs' for the company to take decisions under certain pressure. Adding, she said the book speaks nothing but the truth about the events and the books did go through multiple levels of scrutiny.
Many people criticised the publishing company of barring the publication of the book, saying the company was bullied into withdrawing the book and questioned the censorship.
Amazing isn't it? The same gutter trash that howl about FoE for their terror subsidising boyfriends & naxal buddies are at the forefront of deplatforming @KapilMishra_IND for his speech exhorting the police to do their job.— Abhijit Iyer-Mitra (@Iyervval) August 22, 2020
So the 3M lobby of Marxists-Mullah-Missionaries managed to bully @BloomsburyIndia into backing out from the publication of @advmonikaarora's book on #AntiHinduDelhiRiots, but truth cannot be hidden. The book is now available on @AmazonKindle to read.— Shefali Vaidya. (@ShefVaidya) August 22, 2020
Some alleged that the mob that forced the cancellation of 'Delhi Riots 2020' is no different from the Nazi mob and claimed the banning of book as an act of Fascism.
The Truth : Pseudo left liberals are the worst radicals. They don't believe in freedom of speech neither do they believe in others' view point. They work in herds with closed mind and are most radically indoctrinated group. Still they call themselves liberals. Pseudos!— Manish Mundra (@ManMundra) August 22, 2020
1. I am appalled to see @BloomsburyIndia, publisher of two of my books, buckle under threats by fascists and withdraw the book Delhi Riots - 2020. I stand in complete solidarity with the authors.— Anand Ranganathan (@ARanganathan72) August 22, 2020
This is an assault on Freedom of Expression and on those who cherish this freedom.
Many alleged the publishing company to show their biasness towards the two books on a similar issue, one that was approved, 'Shaheen Bagh' by Zia-Ur-Aslamand the other one withdrawn 'Delhi Riots 2020'.
Publisher like @BloomsburyIndia should not have backtracked on its commitment to publish a book on #Delhiriots. It's sad state of affairs about the intellectual discourse in our country.#bloomsburyindiahttps://t.co/tJy31ktJwE— P Muralidhar Rao (@PMuralidharRao) August 22, 2020
. #bloomsburyindia the real story is , you have denied to publish a book based on facts related to the #DelhiRiots2020 while you carried a fictional book based on the same topic. Shows your hypocrisy on all the blabbering about FoE. #DelhiRiotsUntoldStory https://t.co/a1CoFQqvDE— prafulla ketkar 🇮🇳 (@prafullaketkar) August 22, 2020
Also Read: Pakistan Orders Seizure Of Dawood Ibrahim's Assets In Karachi, Denies His Presence In Country