Justice Delayed Again
“After 23 years in jail, I am free but what you see now is a living corpse. I am thankful to Supreme Court to give my freedom back. But who will give my life back?” says Nisar to Indian Express, Acquitted in Babri anniversary train blasts case. Nisar was among three men who walked out from Jaipur prison after the Supreme Court acquitted them of all charges, setting aside their life sentence and ordering their immediate release on May 11. The accused were booked for five blasts on board trains on the first anniversary of the Babri Masjid demolition that killed two passengers and injured eight.
Arrested On His Way To College
Nisar was picked up on January 15, 1994 by police near his home in Gulbarga, Karnataka. He was a second-year student in Pharmacy and had an exam in 15 days. He was on his way to college where a police vehicle was waiting. A man showed him his revolver and forced him to get in. The Karnataka Police had no idea about his arrest. This team had come from Hyderabad. They took him to Hyderabad. His family knew nothing of his whereabouts until he was produced before a court on February 28, 1994. His older brother Zaheer-ud-din Ahmad, who was working in Mumbai as a civil engineer, was picked up that April. Like Nisar, Zaheer, too, was sentenced to life imprisonment but was released on bail on May 9, 2008 by the Supreme Court on health ground as he was diagnosed with lung cancer in jail. It was at this time that his brother Zaheer started fighting for justice and kept on making applications to court saying how they had been wronged. Finally, the Supreme Court gave a verdict exonerating both of them and two others.
His Father Died Without Hope
“I felt a terrible heaviness in my legs. I froze. For a moment, I had forgotten I was free,” said Nisar-ud-din Ahmad when he stepped out the prison and saw his elder brother Zaheer-ud-din Ahmad, waiting for him. By the time they were acquitted, their families had been left shattered by the fight to prove their innocence. “Our father Noor-ud-din Ahmad left everything to fight a lonely battle to prove our innocence. He didn’t see any hope until he died in 2006. Now there is nothing left.” “Nobody can imagine what it means to a family whose two young sons are jailed,” said Nisar’s brother Zaheer. What he has attained today is freedom but a generation has already skipped from his life. He was yet to be 20 years old when he was thrown in jail. He is 43 today. Her younger sister was 12 when he last saw her, her daughter is 12 now. His niece was a year old. Today she is already married. His cousin was two years younger than him, she is now a grandmother.
Police records link the two to five separate bomb blasts in trains at Kota, Hyderabad, Surat, Kanpur and Mumbai in the intervening night of December 5-6, 1993. The Hyderabad Police picked up Nisar, later his brother Zaheer and their neighbour in Gulbarga, Mohammad Yusuf, a car mechanic. Initially, police booked them for a bomb blast that had taken place in October 1993 in a Muslim educational institute in Hyderabad. This case was registered in Abid Road Police station. They were also booked in few unsolved bomb blasts that had taken place in August and September that year. Subsequently, they were booked in the serial train blasts. The only evidence police produced was their alleged custodial confessions – the provisions of Terrorist and Disruptive Activities Act (TADA) were later invoked to make these admissible. These alleged confessions of Nisar, Zaheer and Yusuf, as per court records, were taken by Hyderabad Police officers at Abid Road Police station. In his alleged confession, police claimed that Nisar accepted his role in planting of Bomb in the compartment of A.P. Express on 06.12.1993 and that he was also having two other bombs which were meant for use in K.K. Express on the same day but because of his ill health he could not use them. Similarly, the others too had allegedly confessed their role in the train bombings. In these alleged confessions, however, there was no mention of the case in which Nisar, Zaheer and others from Gulbarga were first arrested and brought to Hyderabad. While different state police forces had registered cases in each of these blasts, the government handed over the investigation to CBI. Apart from these three from Gulbarga, the CBI filed charges against 13 more, including Jalees Ansari of Mumbai who was dubbed as the mastermind of the blasts apparently carried out to avenge the demolition of Babri Masjid. On May 21, 1996, the Metropolitan Sessions Judge, Hyderabad, revoked the provisions of TADA from the case. The Andhra government challenged this order before Supreme Court, which said the use of TADA was “very casual” and issued notice to the Police Commissioner, Hyderabad, to show cause why “adverse remarks against him be not made”. On July 17, 2001, the AP government sought withdrawal of its appeals. Thus the invocation of TADA became invalid in the case where the alleged confession of Nisar, Zaheer and Yusuf was recorded, making the confessions impermissible. Nisar’s alleged confession recorded by DCP K V Reddy on March 11, 1994, was a verbatim copy of another alleged confession of his, taken by police Inspector B Shyama Rao on February 27, 1994 which wasn’t even signed. “It was fabricated and I kept on raising it. While the alleged confessions were not accepted in Hyderabad after TADA was dropped, the same confessions were used to charge us in Ajmer,’’ said Nisar. One of the accused went absconding after he was released on parole in 1999. On February 28, 2004, the designated TADA Court at Ajmer convicted the other 15 accused, including Nisar, his brother Zaheer and Yusuf, and sentenced them to life imprisonment. One among them, a juvenile, was later released by Supreme Court in 2012. They approached Supreme Court and challenged the TADA Court’s order. Justice Fakkir Mohamed Ibrahim Kalifulla and Justice Uday Umesh Lalit observed that the confessions of the four accused, including Zaheer, Nisar and Yusuf, were “without any legal sanction and cannot be relied upon”. According to the judgment, Nisar’s “role is neither referred to in the confessions… Nor is there any material other than the confession of (Nisar) himself on record. The conviction and sentence of (Nisar) is therefore completely unsustainable”. Regarding his brother Zaheer, the judgment said, “In the absence of any other material on record to lend any semblance of corroboration to the confession (of the co-accused), we find it extremely difficult to sustain the conviction and sentence of (Zaheer) simply on the basis of confession of (the co-accused).” Advocate Nitya Ramakrishnan, who represented five among the accused, including Nisar and Zaheer in the apex court, says that “their alleged confession in police custody is the beginning and end of the case”. The Supreme Court upheld the conviction of ten others, including one who is now 85, another is 79 and a third is a 74-year-old. “They are going to die inside jail,” said Nisar.
The Logical Indian have always appreciated the great work security agencies and the government has done to keep our country and citizens safe and secure. However, more often terrorism related arrests turns out to be false and done in haste. We request the government and the security agencies to get the arrests right and nab the real terrorists as false arrests have ruined many families, their hope, dignity and a dream for a better future. We as Indians are united against the menace of terrorism and it is for that reason we don’t want some of our beloved innocent fellow citizens to face what they have.