Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Mahua Moitra on Thursday, November 19, alleged that BJP supporters hurled stones, eggs and sticks at her car and convoy in the Gobra gram panchayat area of Kaliganj in West Bengal’s Nadia district. The Krishnanagar MP accused the West Bengal Police of failing to protect her despite a Calcutta High Court order mandating security during her visits to the constituency.
Sharing videos of the confrontation on social media platform X, Moitra claimed that 80-90 BJP supporters had gathered in advance to disrupt her programme and alleged that police personnel failed to intervene despite receiving prior information. The BJP, however, defended the protest, describing it as a spontaneous expression of public anger over her alleged remarks about Hindu deities. The police had not issued an immediate response to her allegations.
Protesters Surround MP’s Vehicle
The incident reportedly took place around 11 am on Thursday when Moitra was travelling from Krishnanagar towards Kaliganj. According to reports, a group of protesters surrounded her vehicle, waved black and BJP flags, raised ‘Go Back’ slogans and allegedly threw eggs and stones at her convoy. The MP also claimed that protesters physically pushed her car and attacked it with sticks while police personnel present at the location failed to disperse the crowd. In a series of posts on X, she tagged the West Bengal Police, the state Director General of Police and Krishnanagar Police District, alleging that authorities had prior information about the gathering.
“My safety under the order of Hon’ble HC Kolkata is your responsibility. 80-90 BJP goons waiting at Gobra GP, Kaliganj to attack me. All info with you,” she wrote. During a live video recording of the confrontation, Moitra expressed frustration over the police response, alleging that officers were asking her to leave instead of clearing the protesters. She also questioned the implementation of the court-mandated security arrangements, claiming that the two police personnel accompanying her were unable to control the situation.
BJP Defends Protest
Responding to the incident, Sandipan Majumdar, BJP’s Nadia North organisational district media convener, defended the protesters, describing their actions as a spontaneous expression of public anger over Moitra’s alleged remarks about Hindu gods and goddesses. He said, “After all, bombs weren’t thrown at her, only eggs were. Considering what she has done, she will have to endure at least this much.” The incident comes amid an ongoing dispute over the MP’s security arrangements.
On September 16, protesters allegedly hurled eggs at Moitra and her vehicle as she left a party meeting in Tehatta, Nadia district. She had accused BJP workers and local office-bearers of being involved, allegations the BJP had previously denied. On July 1, she had also accused BJP workers of gathering outside her Krishnanagar office and pelting eggs. Following the September incident, Moitra approached the Calcutta High Court on September 21, alleging police inaction. Under an interim court order, two constables have been assigned to accompany her for personal protection during visits to her Krishnanagar constituency until November 30.
The dispute over the adequacy of her security is currently pending before a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court, which is scheduled to hear the matter next on November 27. Meanwhile, neither the West Bengal Police nor the BJP had issued an official response to Thursday’s allegations at the time of reporting.
The Logical Indian’s Perspective
Political disagreements and public criticism are essential parts of a functioning democracy. However, intimidation, physical aggression and attempts to obstruct elected representatives cannot be justified as expressions of public anger. Equally, allegations of police inaction, particularly when court-directed security arrangements are involved, deserve a fair and transparent investigation. Political parties must ensure that their supporters express dissent through peaceful and democratic means rather than confrontation or intimidation.
Law enforcement agencies must remain impartial and ensure the safety of every citizen, irrespective of political affiliation or ideology. Democracy thrives when opposing voices can coexist, question one another and engage in dialogue without fear. How can political parties and law enforcement agencies work together to ensure that democratic disagreements do not turn into violence?
Also Read: Reel Makers Vs Journalists: Delhi Police Explains Who Deserves Protection While Covering Protests













