From Calling Aadhaar A ‘Fraud’ To Overruling His Father On Adultery Case: Meet Justice DY Chandrachud

The Logical Indian Crew India

September 28th, 2018 / 1:32 PM

Justice DY Chandrachud

Image Credit: The Times of India

In the past few days, we have seen the Supreme Court hearing some of the most important cases. This is also Dipak Misra’s last week as the CJI, he retires on October 2. In what could be termed as an action-packed week for the SC, judgements on several cases, including the Aadhaar law, Adultery law, live streaming of court proceedings, among others have been pronounced. Among all the judges, one person has emerged as the new dissenting voice in the highest court – Justice DY Chandrachud.

Justice DY Chandrachud was born on November 11, 1959, to Justice YV Chandrachud, the longest-serving CJI, and Prabha, a classical musician. A Harvard University alumnus, before becoming a judge in SC in 2016, Justice Chandrachud also served as the Chief Justice at Allahabad HC and a judge at the Bombay HC.

From being the minority in the judgement in the Aadhaar law to overturn his father’s 33-year-old judgement on the Adultery law, Justice Chandrachud’s stand on several pertinent issues has been nothing but progressive and rational.

“Aadhaar programme is unconstitutional”

On September 26, SC upheld the constitutional validity of Aadhaar, however, it did strike down multiple sections of Aadhaar as unconstitutional. The SC bench in a 4-1 decision backed the legality of the Aadhaar, Justice Chandrachud was the lone dissenting judge. He minced no words when he said, “Aadhaar programme in its entirety is unconstitutional.” He posed questions on privacy, data collection, authentication and biometrics to the government.

He also objected to the fact that the Aadhaar act was passed as a money bill. A money bill doesn’t require debate in Rajya Sabha and would require passage only through the Lok Sabha. “It constitutes a fraud on the Constitution,” he said, adding, “The ruling party in power may not command a majority in the Rajya Sabha. But the legislative role of that legislative body cannot be obviated by legislating a Bill which is not a Money Bill as a Money Bill.” Notable, the ruling party, BJP, does not enjoy a majority in the Upper house.

Petitioners and critics of the Aadhaar lauded Justice Chandrachud. Legal expert Usha Ramanathan told Newslaundry that he actually “Justice Chandrachud’s judgement is extremely important not just because he encapsulated what the petitioners have been saying, but also because he got what that relationship is that the technology is introducing between the state and the people”.

Judgement on Adultery law

By striking down the criminalisation of adultery under section 497 of Indian Penal Code, Justice Chandrachud overturned the 33-year-old judgement authored by his father, Justice YV Chandrachud. In 1985, while giving the judgement on the Sowmithri Vishnu vs Union of India case, the bench had upheld the constitutional validity of the section.

Saying that this law compromised the dignity of the women and treated them as man’s property. Chandrachud did not hesitate to call the earlier judgement “seriously flawed”.

“Dissent is the safety valve of democracy”

In a nationwide crackdown, the Pune police had arrested five activists-Sudha Bharadwaj, P Varavara Rao, Gautam Navlakha, Arun Ferreira and Vernon Gonsalves last month. In judgement pronounced on September 28, SC refused to allow the release of five activists. The bench headed by CJI Dipak Misra allowed Maharashtra police to go ahead with their investigation and also dismissed a plea for a SIT probe.

In this too, the only dissenting judge was Justice Chandrachud who said that “technicality should not be allowed to override substantive justice”. He also pulled up the police for making the evidence public, calling it a “disconcerting behaviour”.

Earlier this month the SC gave a minor relief to the arrested activists by placing them under house arrest. Justice Chandrachud while pronouncing the verdict had famously said, “Dissent is the safety valve of democracy if you don’t allow safety valve, the pressure cooker will burst.”

Controversial judgement

In the recent times, one judgement by him which can be termed as controversial is the verdict on the Justice Loya case. In April, SC bench headed by CJI Dipak Misra and consisting Justices Chandrachud and AM Khanwilkar dismissed petitions seeking an independent probe. The SC had then said that petitions lacked merit. The bench also observed that the conduct of the petitioners was lacking in bonafide and it revealed a misuse of the judicial process.

Also Read: 

“Dissent Is Safety Valve Of Democracy,” Says SC On Arrest Of Activists


Written by : Shraddha Goled

Edited by :

Related Stories

Allahabad Bank Reports 1,775 Crore Fraud Against Bhushan Power & Steel, After PNB Reported Fraud Of Rs 3,800 Crore

Justice Chandrachud Constitution

“When Mob Lynches A Person For The Food He/She Has, Constitution Is Lynched”: Justice Chandrachud

Mannem Sridhar Reddy Schools

His Father Adopted A Govt School Without His Knowledge, Now He Spends His Salary To Take Care Of It

Adultery Criminalization

Impact Of Decriminalisation Of Adultery On Criminalisation Of Marital Rape

Chennai Woman Suicide Adultery

Chennai Woman’s Suicide Reveals How Adultery Judgement Is Being Misunderstood

Adultery Tripura Woman Thrashed

Tripura: Woman Tied To Tree, Beaten On Suspicion Of Adultery

Latest on The Logical Indian

My Story

My Story: “I Was Shocked To See 100s Of Trees, Some As Old As 200 Yrs Old Chopped For Road Extension”


Kerala: Police Commissioner Merin Joseph Travels To Saudi Arabia & Brings Back Child Rape Accused


Supreme Court Agrees To Hear Plea On Women’s Full Right To Abort Pregnancy At Any Stage


Uttarakhand BJP MLA Who Danced Brandishing Guns In Viral Video, Expelled From Party For 6 Years


Assam: Govt Seeks Re-Verification Of 20% NRC Data, While Flood Victims Refuse To Leave Home In Fear Of Being Excluded


Assam: Govt Seeks Re-Verification Of 20% NRC Data, While Flood Victims Refuse To Leave Home In Fear Of Being Excluded


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.