Fact Check: Twitter Users Claim Media Falsely Reported 'US Defence Secretary Discussed Human Rights Issues With Indian Ministers'

Social media users are claiming that NDTV falsely reported that US Defence Secretary Lloyd J Austin III spoke about the human rights crisis in India during his three days visit. The Logical Indian Fact Check team verifies the claim.

India   |   23 March 2021 12:56 PM GMT
Writer : Yusha Rahman | Editor : Bharat Nayak | Creatives : Abhishek M
Fact Check: Twitter Users Claim Media Falsely Reported US Defence Secretary Discussed Human Rights Issues With Indian Ministers

Image Credit: Wikimedia

US Secretary of Defence, Lloyd J. Austin III, was on a three-day visit to India, from March 19, 2021, to March 21, 2021. His visit to India is a part of his first overseas travel to emphasise the strength of the India-US strategic partnership.

Against this event's backdrop, many social media users are sharing screenshots of two tweets, one of NDTV and the other of ANI. While the Tweet of NDTV says, US Defence Secretary discussed Human Rights issues with the Indian Minister, the tweet by ANI quotes a source to say that US Defence Secretary did not discuss the human rights issues. The screenshots of the tweets are being shared to show that the human rights issues were not discussed by the US Defence Secretary in his meetings with India's top political leaders.

Many Twitter users are sharing the images with the hashtag '#ShutDownNDTV'.

Claim:

US Defence Secretary did not speak about the human rights issues in India amid his three days visit.

Fact Check:

The Logical Indian Fact-check team searched with the keyword, "US Defence Secretary did not speak about the human rights" and found many media reports saying that US Defence Secretary spoke about human rights with External Affairs Minister, S Jaishankar.

On being asked by an American journalist, if human rights were discussed, Austin replied, he did not get the opportunity to discuss human rights issue with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, but he discussed this with other ministers. The Print quoted Austin's statement, which he made during a press briefing to American journalists and a group of Indian journalists. In his statement, he said, "Having said that, I did have a conversation with other members of the cabinet on this issue. We have to remember that India is our partner, a partner whose partnership we value." He also said, "And I think partners need to be able to have that kind of discussion, and certainly we feel comfortable doing it. We can have those discussions in a meaningful way…" The news was reported by The Print on March 20.

We also read the entire report by NDTV, which was also published on March 20. This article is similar to the article of The Print; the only difference between the two is that NDTV mentioned that "violations of human rights, especially against Muslim minorities in the northeast."

ANI also reported that issues of human rights were raised in discussion between S Jaishankar and Lloyd J Austin III.

Link to ANI's article.

Later, on March 21, ANI published an article countering the previous reports done by other media organisation, with the title, "No discussion of human rights in India with US Defence Secretary: Sources." When we read the whole article, we found that ANI in his report had cited High-level Indian sources, who said, 'human rights and values were mentioned as shared attributes and the only mention of minorities was by EAM Jaishankar in the context of Afghanistan.'

A screenshot of the ANI report.

We also found that the United States Department of Defense had also released a transcript of the press briefing of Secretary of Defense Lloyd J. Austin III that happened in Delhi on March 20. In the transcript, one can read that a journalist had asked, "Thank you. Thank you for doing this Mr Secretary. Diplomacy and human rights an important part of the Biden/Harris administration. Since you are the first member of the administration to meet with Prime Minister Modi, did you raise the question of violations of human rights especially against Muslim minorities in (inaudible)?" As a reply to this answer, Austin says, "Thanks. And to answer your question about whether or not I engaged the Prime Minister on that specific issue, I did not have an opportunity to talk with him about that. Having said that, I did have a conversation with other members of the Cabinet on this -- on this issue. And I think -- we have to remember that India is our partner and a partner that -- whose partnership we value. And I think partners need to be able to have those kinds of discussions. And certainly, we're -- we feel comfortable in doing that. And you can have those discussions in a very meaningful way and still -- and make progress."

Link to the transcript.

Hence, we could evidently conclude that the US Defence Secretary had said that he discussed the human rights issues with Indian Ministers, unlike what is claimed by social media users.

Alt News has earlier verified the claim.

If you have any news that you believe needs to be fact-checked, please email us at factcheck@thelogicalindian.com or WhatsApp at 6364000343.

Also Read: Misleading Infographic Viral To Show Vaccines Were Free In Private Hospitals During Congress Regime

Claim Review :  US Defence Secretary did not speak about the human rights issue in India amid his three days visit.
Claimed By :  Social Media
Fact Check :  False
Suggest a correction

    Help Us Correct

    To err is human, to help correct is humane
    Identified a factual or typographical error in this story? Kindly use this form to alert our editors
  • *
  • *
  • *
  • Form Submitted Successfully
    Error in submitting form. Try again later

Contributors

Yusha Rahman

Yusha Rahman

Fact-Checker

Yusha, an engineer turned journalist with a core interest in sensible journalism. Since the time she worked in an MNC, she saw how fake news was rife to malign images of communities, leaders, etc. This encouraged her to give up her career in MNC and passionately work towards curbing fake news and propaganda.

Bharat Nayak

Bharat Nayak

Founding Editor - Special Project

As the founding editor, Bharat had been heading the newsroom during the formation years of the organization and worked towards editorial policies, conceptualizing and designing campaign strategies and collaborations. He believes that through the use of digital media, one could engage the millennial's in rational conversations about pertinent social issues, provoking them to think and bring a behavioral change accordingly.

Abhishek M

Abhishek M

Creative Supervisor

" An engineer by profession, Abhishek is the creative producer of the team, graphic designing is his passion and travelling his get away. In more ways than one, he makes the content visually appealing."

Next Story