“UPA Lacked Political Will” Why ISRO Ex-Chief Comment On Mission Shakti Should Be Taken With A Pinch Of Salt

The Logical Indian Crew India

April 1st, 2019 / 10:52 AM

G Madhavan Nair ISRO

Image Credits: Economic Times, Zee News

“The project of manned space programme was ready in 2009. Had the then government given consent, we could have sent man to space by now. Another project to develop indigenous aircraft was also in cold storage. Only a leader like Modi could show the political will to follow up such projects,” said G Madhavan Nair, the former chief of the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) on March 27 after the success of Mission Shakti.

He further said that the country had the ability for the anti-satellite missile back in 2007 under the UPA government, but due to “no political will” it failed, reported Business Standard.

Nair’s comment came after Prime Minister Narendra Modi in a national address announced that India has established itself as an elite space power with an anti-satellite weapon, A-SAT. The indigenously built A-SAT successfully shot down a live satellite on a low earth orbit which was cruising at an altitude of 300 km in space. India has now become the fourth country after China, Russia, and the US to have achieved this milestone.

Why ISRO ex-Chief comment cannot be taken seriously

G Madhavan Nair, who headed the ISRO from 2003 to 2009 and served as the Secretary to the Department of Space, Government of India, contrary to current stand in past has advocated for India not pursuing such mission. When China destroyed an ageing weather satellite by launching a missile in 2007, Nair then had said that the move was against international convention and would lead to a lot of space pollution, reported the Indian Express.

He then said that India had the technology to develop anti-satellite missile in 2007. When China pursued the mission, he condemned China’s act and said that no country should weaponise outer space by creating debris.

Nair had said, “They (China) should not have done that. It’s against international convention…. we are not supposed to weaponise outer space… by killing a satellite, you create much more debris. Today about 8,000 objects are there in orbit. By blasting one satellite, you create another few hundred (objects). I don’t know why they did that.”

Following an investigation into a controversial satellite deal with a foreign company, in 2011-12, the UPA govt had instructed the space department to not give any govt jobs to Nair and three other space officials. In 2016, CBI filed a chargesheet against Nair and three others, stating that the deal caused a loss of Rs 578 crore to the exchequer. However, there hasn’t been any conviction yet and Nair has maintained that he is not involved in any wrongdoings.

Interestingly, on 27 October 2018, G Madhavan Nair joined Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in presence of the Party President Amit Shah in Kerala.

Image Credit: Hindustan Times(ANI)

Also Read: Mission Shakti: In 3 Mins, India’s A-SAT Shoots Down Live Satellite; 4th Country To Do So


Written by : Debarghya Sil

Edited by : Bharat Nayak

Related Stories

Mission Shakti: India’s A-SAT Testing Created 400 Debris & Endangered ISS, Says NASA

G Madhavan Nair ISRO

“UPA Lacked Political Will” Why ISRO Ex-Chief Comment On Mission Shakti Should Be Taken With A Pinch Of Salt

Mission Shakti: In 3 Mins, India’s A-SAT Shoots Down Live Satellite; 4th Country To Do So

Republic Day

This Republic Day, Let’s Know Why Our Constitution Is The Salt That Makes Our Democracy Work

Plastic Salt IIT Bombay

How Safe Is Your Salt? IIT-Bombay Study Reveals Plastic Pollutants In Popular Salt Brands

Baba Ramdev & Sadhguru

Baba Ramdev & Sadhguru’s Comment On Cow Vigilantism: Why Any Justification By Them Is Dangerous

Latest on The Logical Indian

World Affairs

Indiscriminate Murders & Rapes: Know All About The Crisis That Has Gripped Sudan


Zomato Launches LGBTQIA+ Friendly Tag In All Restaurants


Following Protests, Southern Railway Forced To Withdraw Circular Asking Staff To Talk Only In Hindi & English


In A Letter To PM Modi, E. Sreedharan Opposes Delhi Govt’s Proposal To Give Free Rides To Women

Get Inspired

An Open Letter To Dad


Govt Reduces Contribution Of Employees & Employers Towards ESI Scheme; May Result In Increased Take-Home Salary


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.