Step In Right Direction: Supreme Court Approves Witness Protection Scheme, 2018

The Logical Indian Crew India

December 6th, 2018 / 5:06 PM

Witness Protection Scheme

Image Credit: Patrika

A Supreme Court bench on December 5 approved the Witness Protection Scheme, 2018. “The Union of India, as well as States and Union Territories (UTs), shall enforce the Witness Protection Scheme, 2018 in letter and spirit,” the bench consisting of Justice AK Sikri and Justice S Abdul Nazeer said.

The bench said that under Article 141/142 of the constitution, this scheme would be a law until a suitable parliamentary or state legislation is enacted upon it. The Bench also said that by the end of 2019, states and union territories will set up vulnerable witness deposition, as reported by Livelaw.

The judgement

The need for such a scheme was put forward in a petition by Mahender Chawla. Chawla had testified against Asaram Bapu and his son Narayan Sai in rape cases of a minor and two sisters. Chawla survived a murder attempt for testifying against the “Godman”.

According to Business Standard, the judgement said, “One of the main reasons for witnesses to turn hostile is that they are not accorded appropriate protection by the state. It is a harsh reality, particularly, in those cases where the accused persons/ criminals are tried for heinous offences, or where the accused persons are influential persons or in a dominant position.”

The SC, calling the scheme to be “benevolent and beneficial”, said that it would help to strengthen the justice system.

What is Witness Protection Scheme?

The Witness Protection Scheme 2018 was framed by the Centre after it received inputs from 18 states/UTs, five States’ Legal Services Authorities and open sources like civil society, High Courts and police personnel.

Under this scheme, there needs to an identification of the categories of threat perceptions. It also includes the preparation of a “Threat Analysis Report” by the head of the police.

This scheme is formulated by the Home Ministry and it categorizes the witness into three categories – threat extending to the life of witness of their families; threat extending to safety, reputation or property; a moderate threat which extends to harassment or intimidation.

The scheme allows the witness to file an application before an authority of the district where the crime is committed. This authority must be chaired by District and Session Judge. The head of the district police must be its member and the head of the prosecution in the district should be the member secretary. After an application is received, the authority is required to demand a Threat Analysis Report by ACP/DSP. The authority can order identity protection or its change and relocation of witnesses.

Also Read: Delhi Witness Protection Scheme, 2015 – A Step In The Right Direction


Written by : Shraddha Goled

Edited by : Bharat Nayak

Related Stories

Supreme Court Agrees To Hear Plea On Women’s Full Right To Abort Pregnancy At Any Stage

Haren Pandya

IPS Officer Vanzara Gave Contract To Kill Gujarat Home Minister Haren Pandya, Witness Alleges In Court

Public Has Right To Know; Supreme Court To Live Stream Court Proceedings

Supreme Court Judgements RTI

Supreme Court Judgments On Right To Information Act 2005: An Analysis By Former CIC Chairman

RTI Activists

RTI Activist Shot Dead In Bihar; Victim Was To Be Witness In A Fraud Case Says Police

Chhattisgarh: Police’s Modus Operendi To Fabricate Cases, One Boy Serves As Witness To Over 250 Cases

Latest on The Logical Indian

My Story

My Story: “I Was Shocked To See 100s Of Trees, Some As Old As 200 Yrs Old Chopped For Road Extension”


Kerala: Police Commissioner Merin Joseph Travels To Saudi Arabia & Brings Back Child Rape Accused


Supreme Court Agrees To Hear Plea On Women’s Full Right To Abort Pregnancy At Any Stage


Uttarakhand BJP MLA Who Danced Brandishing Guns In Viral Video, Expelled From Party For 6 Years


Assam: Govt Seeks Re-Verification Of 20% NRC Data, While Flood Victims Refuse To Leave Home In Fear Of Being Excluded


Assam: Govt Seeks Re-Verification Of 20% NRC Data, While Flood Victims Refuse To Leave Home In Fear Of Being Excluded


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.