Villagers Face Eviction Near Panna Forest Reserve

From our friends at
People's Archive of Rural India
Maithreyi Kamalanathan
Madhya Pradesh

March 31st, 2019 / 12:27 PM

Panna Forest Reserve

Families in Rampura face homelessness (Photo by Maithreyi Kamalanathan)

Story By - Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

The residents of Rampura, a small village in the buffer zone of the Panna Tiger Reserve in Madhya Pradesh, have been asked to move. But, they say, with no allocation of alternative land, where will we go?

“If they come to destroy our houses with elephants, we’ll throw all our belongings and our children into the pond, form a circle and ask them to shoot us, but we will not leave until our demands are met,” says Roop Rani, who might soon lose her house and land, as will all the other residents of Rampura.

Their village is one among 49 villages in the Panna Tiger Reserve’s buffer zone where the people say they have been told by the forest department that with the number of tigers increasing, the reserve’s core area has to be expanded. Human settlements are not allowed in the core, while buffer zones around critical tiger habitats allow more space for the free movement of tigers while also allowing humans and wildlife to co-exist. Rampura came under the Panna reserve’s buffer zone in August 2012.


In close proximity to the Panna Reserve: the boundary that separates the forest from Rampura | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

But over the last four years, plans to expand the core area have been unfolding, and Roop Rani and her neighbours are looking at a future of uncertainty. Since then, they have been trying to save their land, while also negotiating with the forest department to be relocated to five-acre plots in addition to being given Rs. 10 lakhs – the amount mandated in 2008 by the central government’s Project Tiger as the compensation per family.


The forest department post at the village entrance | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

But forest officials have told them, the villagers say, that the government has no land for rehabilitation. Roop Rani, a cattle herder and farmer, who cultivates wheat and maize along with her husband on their two acres, points out the irony: “If the government does not have land to offer us, how do they expect us to find any? How do they expect us to buy cultivable land, build a house and feed our cattle and children with Rs. 10 lakhs?”

Rampura is an Adivasi village of around 150 people (roughly 35-40 households) in Panna district of Madhya Pradesh. It is not listed in the 2011 Census. A hamlet called Kandawaha, around one kilometre away, is documented as uninhabited though it has some 20-25 households. And Itwan Kalan, Rampura’s panchayat village, 15 kilometres away, is recorded with a population of 5,994 persons.


Roop Rani asks, ‘If the government does not have land, how do they expect us to find any?’ | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

Shobha Rani and others have filed a petition with the collector | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

“Forest authorities stand in the way of us receiving any kind of benefit. As the village will be relocated, they think any schemes here will be a waste of time,” says Shobha Rani, around 55 years old, whose family depends on their 11-acre ancestral land.  (The villagers of Rampura say they all have pattas – land titles – though I was not shown any land document.)

In September 2018, Shobha and a few other women of Rampura filed a petition with the collector. “We listed our demands, got signatures. It was submitted to the [Panna district] collector. He put his seal on it, kept a copy for himself and gave one to us.”

Nothing has moved on the petition. I tried to talk to the collector, but he was out of town at the time of my visit. The only person from the forest department who spoke to me on record is a forest guard (but we are not using his name here). He says, “The government does not possess any land to offer to people anymore. The villagers can purchase the land they want with the money [given as compensation]. They can choose to settle in whichever village they want. All they have to do is submit an application to the collector to be added to that panchayat.”


Panna Forest Reserve
The villagers have jointly purchased a small solar panel for charging phones | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

Panna Forest Reserve
A copy of the petition they submitted to the collector | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

The guard also claims that the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (PCCF) visited Rampura around a year ago to strike a different deal. “He tried to convince them with an offer of a house per family and Rs. 10 lakhs compensation for every adult of the family. But the villagers refused to accept it.” (Some of the villagers also seem to recall they were offered Rs. 10 lakhs per adult, not per family, but this cannot be verified).

Rampura’s residents have reasons to be apprehensive about the PCCF’s promise. “The same deal was offered to the people of Badgadi [around 10 years ago] when they were moved out of the village, but they never got the house in the end,” says 50-year-old Basanta Adivasi. Badgadi Kalan is situated in the Hinouta range of Panna district, within the core of the tiger reserve. “Feeling betrayed, they refused to take even the compensation money from the forest department. Now many of them reside in [towns in] Chhatarpur district, where they are fighting the forest department, and don’t even have the money to pay the lawyer.”

The people of Rampura have also watched the struggles of other villages after relocation. “You know what happened to the people of Talgaon [See: Forced out of the forest and into uncertainty]. We don’t want to end up like that. That’s why before rehabilitation we want them to link us with a panchayat [which will help the villagers to access government schemes], ensure school admissions for our children and [provide] other facilities of gas and electricity as well,” Shobha Rani says.


Villagers Panna Forest Reserve
Rampra has a school, but not many other state schemes. ‘As the village will be relocated, they think any schemes here will be a waste of time’, says Shobha Rani | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

Villagers Panna Forest Reserve
Rampra has a school, but not many other state schemes. ‘As the village will be relocated, they think any schemes here will be a waste of time’, says Shobha Rani | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

Agriculture is the primary source of income in Rampura, and the main crops cultivated are black gram, maize, channa, sesame and wheat. Families here use these as their own food and sell a portion to make an average profit of Rs. 20,000 to Rs. 50,000 a year.

Living in the buffer zone does not place any restrictions on villagers to collect, use or sell forest produce. But these activities are being increasingly restricted, as is farming in the forest. The villagers now rarely go to collect forest produce, which used to contribute to their income and household needs. “Our axes are confiscated if we go to collect wood, let alone other forest produce. Our complaints don’t reach the higher authorities nor are we compensated anymore for crops destroyed by wild animals,” says Virendra Adivasi, 30, who farms on a 3.5-acre plot.

The revised guidelines (2008) of the National Tiger Conservation Authority say that compensation must be provided to forest dwellers in case of human deaths and crop depredation caused by wild animals. In Rampura, and wild boars and nilgai frequently raid the farms. “We stay up all night to chase animals away,” Virendra says. “Hurting them is a crime and we can be jailed. Most of the time they end up causing major damage to our crop.”


Villagers Panna Forest Reserve
‘How will we survive outside without land?’ asks Prem Bai | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

Villagers Panna Forest Reserve
Virendra Adivasi and Basanta Adivasi: ‘We will jointly organise a protest’ | Photo by: Maithreyi Kamalanathan/PARI

Despite these difficulties, the people have a sense of security in Rampura. One reason for this is the availability of water. “You must have seen the pond over there… water is available throughout the year. It’s difficult to find such a water source in any other village here. Our women do not have to walk miles to fetch water every day,” Virendra says.

Prem Bai, a mid-day meal worker at the village school, whose joint family cultivates around 10 acres, also alludes to this sense of security. “My husband and I are already old,” she says (she is 45). “We do not have the strength to go for daily wage labour if we go out of the jungle. At least here we have our land and we cultivate crops for our sustenance. How will we survive outside without land? We are not refusing to leave. But what is the point if conditions will only worsen? We ask for is what is rightfully ours – land, identity and a secure livelihood.”

As the people of Rampura wait patiently for action by the collector on their petition, they are also preparing for what lies ahead. “We are not the only village that will have to move,” Bansanta says. “There are other villages and they have the same demands. We will jointly organise a protest in front of the collector’s office.”


This article was originally published in the People’s Archive of Rural India on March 22nd, 2019.

People’s Archive of Rural India is looking for volunteers, if interested please visit https://ruralindiaonline.org/contribute/

Share your thoughts..

Related Stories

Sariska Tiger Reserve Rajasthan

Rajasthan: Evicted To Protect The Tigers, Villagers Of Sariska Tiger Reserve Fear Livelihood Loss

Bandipur Forest Fire

Karnataka: Major Fire In Bandipur Tiger Reserve Destroys Hundreds Of Acres of Forest Land

Elephants India-Bangladesh Border

Elephants In A Reserve Forest Along India-Bangladesh Border Struggle For Survival

SC Orders Forced Eviction

SC Orders Forced Eviction Of Over 10 Lakh Tribal & Forest Dwellers

slum dwellers evacuate

We Are Indians Not Bangladeshis; 2000 Migrant Families Face An Unfair Eviction In Bengaluru

Adivasi Women Missing

UP: After Meeting The Forest Minister, Two Adivasi Women Fighting For Forest Rights Gone Untraceable

Latest on The Logical Indian

Legal

Contempt Notice Issued To Rahul Gandhi For Attributing “Chowkidar Chor Hai” Remark To Supreme Court

Get Inspired

A Daughter Like No Other: Girl Donates 65% Of Liver To Her Ailing Father To Save His Life

News

Situation In West Bengal Like Bihar 15 Yrs Ago, Says EC Special Observer Over Violence In State

News

“Will Popularise Cow Urine After I Win The Elections,” Says Sadhvi Pragya

Awareness

How CJI Being On Bench That Judged The Allegations Of Sexual Assault Against Him “Threatens The Judiciary”

Legal

SC Orders Rs 50 Lakh Compensation To Gujarat Riots Victim Bilkis Bano; Know About Her

x

Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.