Right To Privacy, Triple Talaq & Karnan: CJI Khehar’s Short Tenure Saw Many Landmark Judgements

The Logical Indian Crew

August 28th, 2017 / 4:13 PM

Image credits: financialexpress

In a short term of only 240 days as the holder of the country’s highest judicial office, Justice Khehar led the Supreme Court through three landmark verdicts. These included the tumultuous controversy surrounding Justice Karnan’s allegations, never before seen in India’s judicial history. The other two were verdicts possess great potential to shape policy and precedent in coming years on issues such as secularism and civil rights – these were the verdicts of triple talaq and the right to privacy.

Khehar’s journey

Jagdish Singh Khehar was born on August 28, 1958. He became the first Chief Justice of India (CJI) from the Sikh community when he succeeded CJI Thakur on January 4, 2017.

Khehar received his LLB and LLM from Punjab University, Chandigarh, securing the first position in the university in LLM examination.

He became a judge of the Punjab and Haryana High Court at Chandigarh on 8 February, 1999, Khehar. He had practised before the same High Court as well as the Himachal Pradesh High Court and the Supreme Court.

He was twice appointed as the acting chief justice of Punjab and Haryana High Court from August 2, 2008 and again from November 17, 2009.

He was elevated as Chief Justice of Uttarakhand High Court on November 29, 2009. Later, he was transferred as Chief Justice of Karnataka High Court.

He was elevated as judge of the Supreme Court on 13 September, 2011.

Justice Karnan case

The curious case of Justice CS Karnan shocked the country and alarmed the judicial community. It has involved several firsts in the history of India’s powerful courts – including the SC issuing contempt charges against a sitting judge, a judge ordering a CBI investigation of the Chief Justice of India, and the SC sentencing a judge to prison. The saga denigrated to Karnan becoming the first HC judge to retire while absconding arrest and him being arrested by the West Bengal police from Tamil Nadu on June 20.

Throughout this trespass onto “virgin territory”, Khehar guided the apex court.

Read more: Justice Karnan Versus The Supreme Court: All You Need To Know

Instant Triple Talaq

On August 22, in a historic verdict, the Supreme Court declared Triple Talaq as unconstitutional (verdict can be red here).

However, saying the practice cannot be done away with “hastily”, the Court gave the government six months’ time to draft a law on the matter.

In the meantime, Triple Talaq will be essentially suspended. The practice has been outlawed, voided, nullified.

Triple talaq – or, in particular, instant Triple Talaq – is the controversial Muslim divorce law that allows men to leave their wives immediately by uttering the word “talaq” (divorce) thrice.

A panel of five judges said that triple talaq “is not integral to religious practice and violates constitutional morality.”

Five judges of different faiths – Chief Justice Jagdish Singh Khehar, Justice Kurian Joseph, Justice Rohinton Fali Nariman, Justice Uday Umesh Lalit and Justice S Abdul Nazeer – heard the case over five days from May 12 to May 18.

The court called triple talaq “bad in law” and said: “We hope the legislature will consider and take into account Muslim Personal Law while making legislation. All parties must keep their politics away and decide this.”

Read more: In A Historic Moment For Indian Secularism, SC Declares Instant Triple Talaq Unconstitutional

Right to privacy

The elevation of privacy as a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution will be remembered as a watershed moment for Indian democracy. A bench of nine judges including CJI Khehar unanimously held (9-0) that privacy is a fundamental right under the Indian Constitution.

The apex court overruled its two earlier judgements (M P Sharma verdict of 1950 and that of Kharak Singh of 1960) that right to privacy is not protected under the Constitution. The SC observed that Right to Privacy is intrinsic under Article 21 of the Constitution and other freedoms guaranteed by Part III. It will come under right to life and liberty, ruled Supreme Court.

The verdict is crucial for Indian democracy – not only because privacy has become a primary debate in the digital age but also because of the intrinsic links between privacy and the government’s push to increase the mandate of Aadhaar and UIDAI.

Read more: Privacy Is A Fundamental Right Under The Indian Constitution: Supreme Court


Written by :

Edited by :

Related Stories

Hyderabad Doctor Triple Talaq

Hyderabad Doctor Offered Free Treatment For Woman Who Was Given Triple Talaq For Crooked Teeth

UP Girl Child Triple Talaq

Uttar Pradesh Man Gives Triple Talaq To Wife For Giving Birth To Fifth Girl Child

Triple Talaq Woman Burnt

UP: Woman Burnt Alive By Husband, In-Laws For Complaining Against Triple Talaq

Landmark Judgements 2018 SC

From Section 377 To Sabarimala, 10 Landmark SC Judgements Of 2018 That Created History

Woman Triple Talaq Via Whatsapp

Bengaluru: After Woman Allegedly Issued Triple Talaq Over WhatsApp, Maneka Gandhi Steps In

Triple Talaq

Unity In Divorcity: The Women Who Defeated Instant Triple Talaq

Latest on The Logical Indian

My Social Responsibility

Educating Cab Drivers On Necessary Matters Related To Banks, This Woman Entrepreneur Is Making Them Financially Literate

My Social Responsibility

This Woman Is Enabling Resurgence Of Homegrown Kiwi Through Her First In India Kiwi Winery Enterprise

My Social Responsibility

First Professionally Trained Female Trekking Guide Now Employees Only Women In Her Travel Company


Opinion: Why We Don’t Need A Corrupt Capitalist Brazilian President On Our Republic Day


Soon, Water Breaks In Karnataka Schools To Keep Students Hydrated


250 Writers, Activists Urge India To Review Cancellation Of Aatish Taseer’s Citizenship


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.