Article 370 Myth Vs Fact: From Purchasing Land To Losing Permanent Resident Ship

The Logical Indian Crew India

August 6th, 2019 / 7:23 PM

Jammu Kashmir Special Status Myths Facts

Image Credits: DD News

Article 370 has been scrapped by the Centre. But there are various myths circulating via social media and news channels. We bring you a fact check on the fake news circulating on TV and the Internet on the controversial Article of Indian constitution.

Myth: Article 370 denies a Kashmiri woman right to own land if she marries an outsider.

Fact: The Jammu and Kashmir High Court in its judgment in the State of J&K vs Sheela Sahni case in October 2002 has said that the woman doesn’t lose her their permanent resident status on marrying an outsider. Bills were introduced in the Jammu and Kashmir Assembly to deny this right to the Kashmiri women. But none of them made it through to become an act.

Myth: Special status under Article 370 is only for Jammu and Kashmir

Fact: At the time of independence along with J&K 10 other states were given special powers. While J&K had Article 370, article 371 was made for Maharashtra, Gujarat, Assam, Nagaland, Sikkim, Mizoram, Arunachal Pradesh, and Goa which gives some special powers to these states.

Myth: You cannot purchase land only in J&K

Fact: There are several other states where, despite being an Indian citizen, one cannot purchase lands such as Himachal Pradesh, Arunachal Pradesh, and Nagaland. Due to the social and territorial situation in this state, a non-resident of these states cannot purchase land here.

Myth: Under Article 370 the Indian Parliament cannot increase or reduce the borders of the State

Fact: India Parliament could increase or decrease the borders of state with the help of Jammu and Kashmir legislature since the article says that the “concurrence” of the state government is mandatory for extending a central law on subjects.

Myth: If a Pakistani boy marries a Jammu and Kashmiri girl he gets the State’s citizenship

Fact: The article 35A clearly said that if a Kashmiri woman marries to a non-Kashmir domicile, her husband won’t get any right in the State.

Myth: Majority of Indian laws including CBI, CAG is not applicable in J&K.
Fact: CBI and CAG are operational in the Jammu and Kashmir for decades.

Also Read: TLI Explains: What Is Article 370?


Written by : Shubhendu Deshmukh

Edited by : Shraddha Goled

Related Stories

Tension Grips Kashmir

Kashmiri Citizens Fear Scrapping Of Article 35A & 370; Know Why

Menstruation Myth V/S Fact

Menstruation: Myth V/S Fact

Mehbooba Mufti Article 370

Abrogation Of Article 370 Would Result In J&K’s “Freedom” From India, Says Mehbooba Mufti

Permanent Resident Certificates

Arunachal Pradesh: Two Killed After Massive Protest Break Out Over Permanent Resident Certificates To Six Communities


South Delhi: Resident Welfare Association Claim That Public Parks Are Being Used For Political Activities

For Cancelling Tickets Without Notice, GoAir Asked To Pay Over Rs 98,000 To Mumbai Resident

Latest on The Logical Indian


Mayank Vaid Completes Enduroman Triathlon In 50 Hrs, Breaks World Record, Becomes First Indian To Do So


178 Villages in Madhya Pradesh Sink As Sardar Sarovar Dam Inches Closer To Its Peak Level


Did Piyush Goyal Agree With Arvind Subramanian On GDP Being Miscalculated?


Delhi’s Air Pollution Levels Came Down By 25% In Past 4 Yrs, Says CM Arvind Kejriwal, Announces 7 Point Plan


People Stop And Stare As Saudi Woman Walks Through Riyadh Mall Without Abaya


States Apply Brake To Hefty Traffic Penalties Under New Motor Vehicle Act, Refuse To Implement


Stories that deserve attention, delivered to your inbox!

Handpicked, newsworthy stories which deserve the attention of a rational generation.