CJI
Ai Generated

‘You Don’t Deserve The Chair’: Advocate Lashes Out At CJI Surya Kant, SC Mutes Proceedings

Frustrated by a 15-day wait for a response on his contempt case, an advocate bypassed Supreme Court protocol to launch a personal tirade against CJI Surya Kant, prompting the bench to mute the live feed and have him escorted out.

Supported by

On Monday, 16 November 2026, a dramatic scene unfolded inside the Supreme Court of India when an advocate launched a personal outburst against Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant during an afternoon session.

Upset over a 15-day delay in receiving a response regarding a contempt case against him, the lawyer bypassed standard listing procedures and shouted, “You don’t deserve the chair”. While the lawyer claimed he was forced to speak out due to an emergency, members of the Bar urged strict disciplinary action against his behaviour. Following the remarks, the bench muted the courtroom’s audio-video feed, and security personnel escorted the advocate out of the premises.

Escalation Over an Urgent Mentioning

The incident occurred at 2:00 PM before a three-judge bench comprising CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V. Mohana.

The counsel initially apologised for mentioning his matter out of turn, explaining that he had submitted documents to the Chief Justice’s office on 2 November and had waited 15 days without a reply. When Justice Mohana reminded him that matters could not be mentioned in such an irregular manner, the lawyer insisted his case was an emergency. CJI Surya Kant calmly asked the advocate to wait, assuring him, “We will see, you just wait”. Refusing to stand down, the lawyer lost his composure and exclaimed, “No, I won’t wait. You can’t sit in that chair, you don’t deserve.

You don’t have the integrity for that!” He added that while he respected Justices Bagchi and Mohana, he did not consider the CJI worthy of his office, prompting the court to cut the live audio-video transmission and remove him from the courtroom.

Context of Courtroom Decorum

The confrontation was reportedly triggered by the advocate’s frustration over a pending contempt matter against him.

While fellow lawyers present in the hall immediately called upon the bench to take stern action against the counsel for breaching professional ethics, the episode mirrors other recent challenges to courtroom decorum. In July 2026, a litigant appearing in person threw papers and used derogatory language before a Supreme Court bench; however, CJI Surya Kant later downplayed that episode, urging members of the legal fraternity to collectively protect the dignity of constitutional institutions rather than escalate tensions. Similarly, in October 2026, the Chief Justice had emphasised during a public lecture that while criticism and differences of opinion are legitimate in a democracy, they must always be expressed with fairness, restraint, and respect for institutional integrity.

The Logical Indian’s Perspective

At The Logical Indian, we believe that a healthy democracy thrives on the pillars of mutual respect, patience, and constructive dialogue.

While delays in legal proceedings can understandably cause immense stress and frustration for individuals seeking relief, resorting to personal attacks inside a courtroom undermines the very institutions meant to safeguard justice. True resolution comes through calm, empathetic communication and adherence to established processes, rather than hostility. Both the Bench and the Bar share an equal responsibility to uphold the dignity of our courts so that disagreements can be addressed peacefully and fairly. How do you think courts and legal professionals can better manage urgent grievances while maintaining mutual respect and courtroom decorum?

Also Read: 3 Workers Removed After Lion Is Seen Being Guided On Motorcycles At Gujarat Safari Park

#PoweredByYou We bring you news and stories that are worth your attention! Stories that are relevant, reliable, contextual and unbiased. If you read us, watch us, and like what we do, then show us some love! Good journalism is expensive to produce and we have come this far only with your support. Keep encouraging independent media organisations and independent journalists. We always want to remain answerable to you and not to anyone else.

Featured

Amplified by

Amazon Prime

For Two Nights in June, Mumbai’s Sea Link and Asiatic Library Wore Light Like They’ve Never Worn It Before

Amplified by

Ministry of Road Transport and Highways

From Risky to Safe: Sadak Suraksha Abhiyan Makes India’s Roads Secure Nationwide

Recent Stories

3 Workers Removed After Lion Is Seen Being Guided On Motorcycles At Gujarat Safari Park

‘Not AI, This Is Yamuna’: AAP Accuses BJP Government Of Failing To Clean River Amid Chhath Puja Celebrations

AIIMS Delhi Performs India’s First Open Foetal Surgery, Repairs Unborn Baby’s Spinal Defect

Contributors

Writer : 
Editor : 
Creatives :