The Bombay High Court on November 18 questioned the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) and Maharashtra government over the sharp improvement in cleanliness in parts of Mumbai during the visit of important guests, while garbage and plastic waste remain persistent problems for residents. A bench of Justices Girish S Kulkarni and Neela K Gokhale pointed to Ballard Estate in south Mumbai, which appeared “shining and polished” around the time Britain’s Prince William and Princess Catherine were in the city, though the judges did not name the royal couple.
Hearing a plea concerning waste disposal at Kanjurmarg, the court said authorities should replace a “temporary show” lasting two days with a “permanent show” of cleanliness across the city. It also raised concerns over plastic waste and sought an internal audit of odour and pollution at the Kanjurmarg facility, with a report due before the next hearing on December 7.
‘Do It For Citizens’
The bench observed that the administration had demonstrated that Mumbai could be transformed “with lightning speed” when it chose to do so. Referring to Ballard Estate, the judges noted that roads had been cleaned, painted and washed with water, and questioned why ordinary Mumbaikars could not have similar roads throughout the year.
“You have to act for the common man who is the permanent resident of this city,” the court said. It urged the authorities to maintain this standard across every ward rather than carrying out short-term preparations when important personalities visit. The remarks came while Prince William and Catherine, Princess of Wales, were in Mumbai for the Earthshot Prize, but the court itself did not specifically identify them as the guests it was referring to.
Plastic Waste Raises Concern
The observations were made during a hearing on waste disposal and pollution linked to the Kanjurmarg waste-management facility. The judges had visited the site on November 17 and flagged heaps of garbage containing plastic. The bench questioned why authorities had not taken stronger steps to stop non-degradable plastic from entering the waste stream and asked the state about its existing plastic policy, including whether other states and Union Territories had moved towards complete bans.
The judges also asked about plastic restrictions at Maharashtra hill stations such as Matheran and Mahabaleshwar. While the bench advocated an “aggressive step” towards banning plastic in totality, it did not order a blanket plastic ban. It also highlighted the impact of plastic waste during the monsoon, when waste can be carried towards the sea and return to the city’s coastline.
Kanjurmarg Audit Ordered
The court has asked its monitoring committee to conduct an internal audit into odour and pollution generated at the Kanjurmarg site and submit its findings before the next hearing on December 7. The proceedings form part of a wider examination of Mumbai’s waste-management system, including the relationship between landfill operations and garbage accumulating on roads and beaches.
The court’s intervention comes as the BMC faces the broader challenge of maintaining cleanliness across the city while managing plastic and other non-degradable waste. The civic body has previously told the court about measures including wet-and-dry waste segregation, cleanliness drives and efforts to improve monitoring of illegal dumping, underscoring that the issue involves both civic enforcement and public participation.
The Logical Indian’s Perspective
Clean streets should not be a temporary privilege reserved for moments when Mumbai is hosting important visitors. The Bombay High Court’s observations highlight a larger principle of public governance: civic services should be consistent, visible and accessible to the people who live in the city every day.
At the same time, lasting cleanliness cannot rest on the BMC alone; residents, businesses and institutions must also reduce plastic use, segregate waste and avoid littering. Mumbai deserves sustainable civic care rather than short-lived makeovers. Should cities be expected to maintain the same standard of cleanliness for residents every day that they demonstrate when the world is watching?













