AI-Generated

Calcutta HC Issues Show-Cause Notice To TMC’s Abhishek Banerjee Over Remarks On Judiciary

The Calcutta High Court initiated criminal contempt proceedings over Banerjee's alleged remarks questioning judicial impartiality while separately ordering a review of his security arrangements.

Supported by

The Calcutta High Court on Tuesday, November 17, issued a show-cause notice to Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Abhishek Banerjee over his alleged remarks questioning the impartiality of sections of the judiciary and suggesting political interference in judicial proceedings.

A single-judge bench of Justice Krishna Rao directed Banerjee to explain within 15 days why criminal contempt proceedings should not be initiated against him. The development follows allegations made by the Diamond Harbour MP while challenging the West Bengal government’s decision to downgrade his security cover from Z-plus to X category.

The court observed that his statements prima facie amounted to interference with the administration of justice. Separately, it directed the state government to review his security arrangements within two weeks.

Remarks Under Scrutiny

The controversy centres on statements allegedly made by Banerjee in a public interview and a social media post in which he questioned the conduct and impartiality of certain judges. The TMC leader reportedly suggested that his petition seeking enhanced security had remained pending because a section of the judiciary was aligned with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). He also accused sections of the judiciary of failing to respond adequately to threats and attacks against him.

During the proceedings, the West Bengal government’s Additional Advocate General, Billwadal Bhattacharyya, placed an audio-visual recording and its transcript before the court, arguing that Banerjee’s statements amounted to criminal contempt. He maintained that political disagreements could not justify casting aspersions on the judiciary. Banerjee’s counsel, Senior Advocate Shoeb Alam, argued that the interview was unrelated to the security petition and that his client’s comments needed to be understood in the context of the threats he had allegedly faced.

However, Justice Rao questioned the propriety of a sitting Member of Parliament making allegations about judges’ political affiliations. During an earlier hearing, the judge reportedly remarked, “You ask your client, who are the judges with the BJP and who aren’t. Since he is so intelligent, let him give a list. I will see.” The court also observed that an elected representative was expected to exercise greater responsibility while making public statements about the judiciary.

Security Dispute Background

The contempt proceedings have emerged alongside Banerjee’s legal challenge to the West Bengal government’s decision to downgrade his security cover from Z-plus to X category on May 12, shortly after the change of government in the state. Banerjee approached the High Court seeking restoration of his earlier security arrangements, alleging that the downgrade was politically motivated and that he continued to face threats. His counsel submitted that the MP and his family had faced multiple attacks since the reduction in protection, with the latest alleged incident reported outside his Kalighat residence in Kolkata on November 7.

Banerjee had also expressed frustration over the delay in hearing his security-related petition, alleging that it had remained pending despite being listed on several occasions. He reportedly questioned the judiciary’s silence over the incidents and raised concerns about the safety of ordinary citizens, asking how common people could expect protection if an elected representative faced such difficulties. During the November 12 hearing, Justice Rao clarified that the controversy surrounding Banerjee’s remarks would not influence the court’s decision on his security petition. The court subsequently reserved its order on the security-related matter.

On Tuesday, while initiating contempt proceedings, it also directed the Principal Secretary of the West Bengal Home Department to convene a meeting of the Security Review Committee within two weeks to reassess Banerjee’s threat perception and determine whether enhanced protection was necessary. The court’s show-cause notice gives the MP an opportunity to explain his position before any further action is considered. The next hearing in the contempt matter is scheduled for December 8.

The Logical Indian’s Perspective

The independence of the judiciary is fundamental to a functioning democracy, as courts must be able to deliver decisions without political pressure, intimidation or public interference. At the same time, elected representatives and citizens must retain the freedom to question institutions, raise concerns about delays and seek accountability when they believe their grievances have not been addressed.

Criticism of the judiciary, however, must be grounded in facts and expressed responsibly, particularly when allegations concern the impartiality of individual judges. Equally, contempt proceedings must be approached with due regard for freedom of expression and the importance of allowing legitimate public scrutiny of institutions.

The allegations surrounding Banerjee’s security also deserve a fair and transparent assessment, irrespective of his political position. A healthy democracy requires both an independent judiciary and institutions that remain accountable to the people they serve. How can India strike the right balance between protecting judicial independence and ensuring that citizens and elected representatives can question institutions without fear?

Also Read: 8 Killed, 20+ Injured As Bus Plunges 100 Metres Into Gorge In Uttarakhand’s Tehri Garhwal

#PoweredByYou We bring you news and stories that are worth your attention! Stories that are relevant, reliable, contextual and unbiased. If you read us, watch us, and like what we do, then show us some love! Good journalism is expensive to produce and we have come this far only with your support. Keep encouraging independent media organisations and independent journalists. We always want to remain answerable to you and not to anyone else.

Featured

Amplified by

Amazon Prime

For Two Nights in June, Mumbai’s Sea Link and Asiatic Library Wore Light Like They’ve Never Worn It Before

Amplified by

Ministry of Road Transport and Highways

From Risky to Safe: Sadak Suraksha Abhiyan Makes India’s Roads Secure Nationwide

Recent Stories

8 Killed, 20+ Injured As Bus Plunges 100 Metres Into Gorge In Uttarakhand’s Tehri Garhwal

Ahmedabad Boxer Kavya Joshi Sets Record With 750 Weighted Rope Skips In Five Minutes

Delhi’s Vivek Vihar Building Collapse Kills 2, Including a Child; 7–8 People Rescued From Debris

Contributors

Writer : 
Editor : 
Creatives :