A 19-month-old child from Madhya Pradesh’s Sagar district has allegedly lost his vision after receiving treatment at the Civil Hospital in Banda, with his family accusing a government doctor of mistakenly administering saline nasal drops into the child’s eyes while treating him for a cold and eye redness on May 29.
According to the complaint filed by the child’s father, Indraj Vishwakarma, the toddler’s condition deteriorated rapidly after treatment, leading to referrals first to the District Hospital in Sagar and later to AIIMS Bhopal, where the family claims doctors informed them that the vision loss was permanent and could be linked to incorrect treatment.
The father has lodged a police complaint seeking action against the doctor and hospital staff. Meanwhile, health authorities have constituted an inquiry committee to investigate the allegations.
Officials have stressed that the findings of the probe will determine whether any medical negligence occurred, while the family continues to demand accountability and a fair investigation.
Family Alleges Treatment Error
What began as a routine hospital visit has turned into a heartbreaking ordeal for the Vishwakarma family. According to the complaint submitted by Indraj Vishwakarma, his 19-month-old son Vinay developed symptoms of a common cold along with redness in his eyes on May 29.
Seeking medical attention, he took the child to the Civil Hospital in Banda, where a government doctor examined him. The family alleges that during treatment, the doctor mistakenly administered saline nasal drops into the child’s eyes instead of appropriate eye medication.
The doctor also reportedly prescribed paracetamol syrup, administered an injection and advised additional medicines before asking the family to wait for the child’s condition to improve.
However, according to the complaint, Vinay’s condition worsened within a few hours. The family remained at the hospital hoping for improvement, but when the symptoms became more severe, doctors referred the child to the District Hospital in Sagar for advanced care. As his condition continued to deteriorate, Vinay was subsequently shifted to AIIMS Bhopal for specialised ophthalmic treatment. T
he family claims that doctors there informed them the toddler had permanently lost his vision and suggested that the blindness could be linked to incorrect treatment or possible medical negligence during the initial hospital visit. AIIMS Bhopal has not publicly confirmed these claims, and the exact medical cause of the child’s vision loss remains under investigation.
Following the diagnosis, Indraj Vishwakarma filed a formal complaint at Banda Police Station, demanding legal action against the doctor and other hospital personnel involved in treating his son. Although he told police that he did not know the doctor’s name, he said he would be able to identify the individual responsible. The complaint seeks a thorough investigation into the treatment administered and strict action if negligence is established.
Inquiry Underway
The allegations have prompted an official response from the district health administration, with authorities ordering an inquiry into the incident. Block Medical Officer Yogendra Khatik confirmed that the Chief Medical and Health Officer (CMHO) has constituted a committee to investigate the family’s allegations.
Speaking on the matter, Khatik said, “The matter is being investigated by a committee constituted by the CMHO. Further action will be taken based on the findings of the probe.” So far, officials have not issued a detailed response addressing the family’s specific allegation that saline nasal drops were administered into the child’s eyes, nor have they announced any disciplinary action against the doctor or hospital staff.
The committee is expected to examine hospital records, treatment protocols, statements from the medical personnel involved and the sequence of referrals that followed the child’s deteriorating condition.
Until the inquiry is completed, the allegations remain unverified, and authorities have urged that conclusions should not be drawn prematurely. The investigation will determine whether there was any deviation from standard clinical procedures and whether any medical negligence contributed to the child’s vision loss.
Beyond this individual case, the incident has reignited concerns about patient safety and quality of care in public healthcare institutions, particularly in busy government hospitals where healthcare professionals often work under heavy workloads and resource constraints.
Medical experts generally caution that administering medicines through the wrong route or failing to follow standard treatment protocols can have severe consequences, especially for infants and toddlers whose developing organs are highly vulnerable.
The outcome of the inquiry may therefore have implications not only for the Vishwakarma family but also for broader discussions on patient safety, clinical accountability and the systems in place to prevent avoidable medical errors.
The Logical Indian’s Perspective
The alleged loss of a toddler’s vision is a deeply distressing incident that deserves both compassion and a thorough, impartial investigation. While the family’s allegations are serious, it is equally important that accountability is established through evidence rather than assumption.
Public confidence in healthcare depends not only on competent medical treatment but also on transparent mechanisms that investigate complaints fairly and act swiftly wherever negligence is proven. If systemic gaps or procedural lapses are identified, they should lead to meaningful reforms that strengthen patient safety, improve clinical oversight and reduce the risk of similar tragedies in the future.
Also read: ‘Papa, Save Me… I’m Dying’: Araria’s 17-Year-Old JEE Aspirant Jaya Shree’s Final Call Before Mysterious Death
